What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

At least Benji knows he's no 7

TiggaPlease

Guest
Messages
891
http://www.leaguehq.com.au/news/lhqnews/a-tale-of-two-halves-positions/2009/07/01/1246127580252.html

A tale of two halves positions - six appeals to Benji

Glenn Jackson | July 2, 2009

Benji Marshall believes the Wests Tigers should chase a top-class halfback to partner him for next season and beyond - and while somewhat relieved and "relaxed" his stint in the key playmaking position has been shelved, he is yet to give up hope of becoming a long-term No.7.
After Tigers coach Tim Sheens aborted - for now - his plan to shift Marshall into a permanent halfback role, the Kiwis captain admitted that he never thought the job would be as tough as it was. "My biggest asset is my running game, and it's taken that away a little bit," he told the Herald yesterday. "I've been ball-playing a bit more, and I haven't minded it - it's helped me build my leadership and talk more - but I feel I made my name on the back of my running game. Hopefully going back to six will give me an opportunity to go back to my running game. It's been good for me for my confidence as well this week. I'll still put in all the talk and help lead the team around. I'll just be two passes wide.
"I questioned it [Sheens's decision to end the experiment] at first, but just for the benefit of the team, it's the best thing for me to go back to five-eighth and get a bit of confidence back."
While the footballer in him will be relieved his game will likely lift as a result, the ego in Marshall would no doubt have been disappointed he could not make the transition work. And for that reason, he could not rule out returning to halfback in the future.
"It's a challenge, and I'm the type of person who likes having a challenge," Marshall said. "People can say that I can't play seven and that always makes me try and prove them wrong. As much as I enjoy a challenge, it was tough. I never thought it would be that tough."
As a result, Marshall would like to see the club chase a classic halfback to partner him - which he has not had since 2006, Scott Prince's last season with the club.
"It would make my job easier," Marshall said. "I didn't realise how much I would miss Princey. Obviously I'm not sure how our situation is [with the salary cap] but for us to have a successful club … I'd love to be able to play five-eighth, and play that 2005 flamboyant style."
Since 2005, when the Tigers won the premiership largely thanks to Prince's guile and Marshall's brilliance, they have not made the finals. Sheens this year had attempted to bring Marshall into the game more by playing him at halfback, and even though he has been schooled by Team of the Century No.7 Andrew Johns, the experiment could hardly be called a success, with Marshall being consistently inconsistent much of the time.

"I guess it was just up and down," Marshall said. "From good games to terrible games to games in between. It's been a big ask to move to seven and lead the team and focus on everyone else instead of focusing on myself. I'm fairly relaxed about going back to five-eighth.
"It relieves a bit of pressure - I don't feel like the pressure's on all the time. It will give me a good opportunity to go back to my normal position."




Listen to your players Sheensy
 

madunit

Super Moderator
Staff member
Messages
62,358
it was very clear cut the whole f**king time.

Morris was never the 7 we needed, it was very clear and was made even clearer since.

Benji's running game, gap running and stepping was what helped us get wins, brought crowds in etc,

So sheens decides to get rid of all that and confine him to the playmaking duties.

Dopey f**king idiot Sheens.
 

Reek_Havoc

Juniors
Messages
559
Why the hell did Benji say previously that John Morris was the man for the job, he'd rather have no one else playing along side him...ra ra ra.....peaces me off.

I think Benji will be a better player for playing at 7, but Sheens and co has caused a lot of grief to the supporters with his stubborness. He should have just stuck with Matty Head. Twat !!!

At least Bellamy took it upon himself to change his "failed experiment" with Inglis at 6 to his rightful position, and look at what has happening. Best player in the game.
 

851

Bench
Messages
3,141
Why the hell did Benji say previously that John Morris was the man for the job, he'd rather have no one else playing along side him...ra ra ra.....peaces me off.

I think Benji will be a better player for playing at 7, but Sheens and co has caused a lot of grief to the supporters with his stubborness. He should have just stuck with Matty Head. Twat !!!

At least Bellamy took it upon himself to change his "failed experiment" with Inglis at 6 to his rightful position, and look at what has happening. Best player in the game.
Agree with all that,but Bellamy for all his faults will admit when he is wrong,unlike Sheens who is like the Fonz from happy days,he can't say sorry I was wrong.
 

macnaz

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
8,501
http://www.leaguehq.com.au/news/lhqnews/a-tale-of-two-halves-positions/2009/07/01/1246127580252.html

A tale of two halves positions - six appeals to Benji

Glenn Jackson | July 2, 2009

Benji Marshall believes the Wests Tigers should chase a top-class halfback to partner him for next season and beyond - and while somewhat relieved and "relaxed" his stint in the key playmaking position has been shelved, he is yet to give up hope of becoming a long-term No.7.
After Tigers coach Tim Sheens aborted - for now - his plan to shift Marshall into a permanent halfback role, the Kiwis captain admitted that he never thought the job would be as tough as it was. "My biggest asset is my running game, and it's taken that away a little bit," he told the Herald yesterday. "I've been ball-playing a bit more, and I haven't minded it - it's helped me build my leadership and talk more - but I feel I made my name on the back of my running game. Hopefully going back to six will give me an opportunity to go back to my running game. It's been good for me for my confidence as well this week. I'll still put in all the talk and help lead the team around. I'll just be two passes wide.
"I questioned it [Sheens's decision to end the experiment] at first, but just for the benefit of the team, it's the best thing for me to go back to five-eighth and get a bit of confidence back."
While the footballer in him will be relieved his game will likely lift as a result, the ego in Marshall would no doubt have been disappointed he could not make the transition work. And for that reason, he could not rule out returning to halfback in the future.
"It's a challenge, and I'm the type of person who likes having a challenge," Marshall said. "People can say that I can't play seven and that always makes me try and prove them wrong. As much as I enjoy a challenge, it was tough. I never thought it would be that tough."
As a result, Marshall would like to see the club chase a classic halfback to partner him - which he has not had since 2006, Scott Prince's last season with the club.
"It would make my job easier," Marshall said. "I didn't realise how much I would miss Princey. Obviously I'm not sure how our situation is [with the salary cap] but for us to have a successful club  I'd love to be able to play five-eighth, and play that 2005 flamboyant style."
Since 2005, when the Tigers won the premiership largely thanks to Prince's guile and Marshall's brilliance, they have not made the finals. Sheens this year had attempted to bring Marshall into the game more by playing him at halfback, and even though he has been schooled by Team of the Century No.7 Andrew Johns, the experiment could hardly be called a success, with Marshall being consistently inconsistent much of the time.

"I guess it was just up and down," Marshall said. "From good games to terrible games to games in between. It's been a big ask to move to seven and lead the team and focus on everyone else instead of focusing on myself. I'm fairly relaxed about going back to five-eighth.
"It relieves a bit of pressure - I don't feel like the pressure's on all the time. It will give me a good opportunity to go back to my normal position."




Listen to your players Sheensy
But he plays the same no matter what number he wears.
 

ShanghaiCharlie

Juniors
Messages
321
Straight from Benji's mouth... yet people here constantly claim there is no difference between the style of play between a half and a five eight with the Tigers. Time to put that myth to bed I think.

A sidenote... the John Morris experiment has crippled this club for four years and even in his wake continues to cripple us. It's all retrospect but Head in the number 7 and we are in the finals every year since Prince left.
 

innsaneink

Referee
Messages
29,384
Straight from Benji's mouth... yet people here constantly claim there is no difference between the style of play between a half and a five eight with the Tigers. Time to put that myth to bed I think.

A sidenote... the John Morris experiment has crippled this club for four years and even in his wake continues to cripple us. It's all retrospect but Head in the number 7 and we are in the finals every year since Prince left.

I dont think they say theres no diff with the style of play.....its that when he's in #6 he will still often play half, as does farah to a lesser extent
 

TiggaPlease

Guest
Messages
891
It's all retrospect but Head in the number 7 and we are in the finals every year since Prince left.

Maybe, but odds are that Head would've done his knee in again. He definitely wasn't given enough of a go but I still have huge doubts that he would've been fit for long enough periods to be able to make a difference.
 

macnaz

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
8,501
Im sure he would have made more game appearences compared to Robert Lui-ser.
 

westie

Bench
Messages
3,936
And what is the date now?

If you can't tell the difference between Benji last week and the week before, both playing "half-back", you should pack it in.
 

macnaz

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
8,501
Maybe i should pack it in because i cant see what point you are trying to make! As for the dates, they tell me that benji prefers NOT to be fisrt reciver and play maker and the point was raised 1 year ago and it still hasnt been resolved.
 

Latest posts

Top