What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Benji dropped

DeeJ

Bench
Messages
3,119
There's a couple news articles about it. Will be replaced by Josh Reynolds. Isn't he the Tigers co captain?

There must be some falling out if he is looking to Brisbane right away. Benji doesn't seem like an ego guy who would leave after being dropped for one match and he has earned his place after last years season.
 
Messages
15,749
Only thing the cited article says is Marshall has been dumped from the side for this week's game by Michael Maguire. Nothing in it about him wanting out or the Broncos looking to sign him.

Fact is Marshall is named in the squad, but as 18th player. This article details that the tigers have made 5 changes to the side from the weekend, and Maguire points out why he has done some, without pointing fingers at individuals - https://www.nrl.com/news/2020/06/09/marshall-dropped-as-reynolds-returns/
 

84 Baby

Immortal
Messages
30,043
Reynolds after his week in for Renaissance Bunji? Are they sure it wasn’t Madge’s positive roadside test?
 

Tommy Smith

Referee
Messages
21,344
The media keep saying that Benji is playing well; but the truth is that he hasn't played consistently well since about, what, 2011?

Don't get me wrong, he was a deadset genius at his peak. An all time great who for a time was the world's best player in a competition that contained the likes of Smith, JT, Slater and GI.

But he lost his spark a long time ago and has imo been a streaky half at best for some time now.
 

Front-Rower

First Grade
Messages
5,297
The media keep saying that Benji is playing well; but the truth is that he hasn't played consistently well since about, what, 2011?

Remember Wests Tigers were favourites to win the comp in 2012? When we didn’t, that’s when;

a) our premiership window closed
b) Marshall and Farah’s time should have been over
 

shear_joy9

Coach
Messages
13,743
he kicked a field goal against the titans but other than that his performance was putrid. Good move by madge showing his team that performance is more important than standing and reputation.
 

The unknown

Juniors
Messages
2,495
I don’t think he’ll leave but if he does I wouldn’t be too upset. It’s a sad state of affairs when most of our fans expect Benji to line up and win us every game when in reality he’s been past it since about 2011 and maybe shown some glimpses every now and then

Will always be my favourite player but should have closed the Marshall & Farah era last year together imo.
 
Messages
8,480
The media keep saying that Benji is playing well; but the truth is that he hasn't played consistently well since about, what, 2011?

Don't get me wrong, he was a deadset genius at his peak. An all time great who for a time was the world's best player in a competition that contained the likes of Smith, JT, Slater and GI.

But he lost his spark a long time ago and has imo been a streaky half at best for some time now.

My opinion is that he's played his best season in ages for the Tigers last year. And definitely his best since leaving the Tigers. He also blew the Dragons away almost single handedly in Round 1 with his kicking game alone.

I'd be gobsmacked if this was true.
 

Fangs

Coach
Messages
14,574
He hasn't been great this year. Though I thought he has been underrated for the last couple years.

Broncos desperately need capable halves. He would be a great signing for them and a loss for the Tigers who also seem to have no idea about player recruitment (Started with Ivan). 9th again it seems.
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
154,216
Marshall dropped as Reynolds returns
Author
Brad WalterNRL.com Senior Reporter
New Zealand great Benji Marshall has been dropped from the Wests Tigers starting team, with Josh Reynolds named in the No.6 jersey for Saturday night's clash with Canberra.

Marshall, who is equal second in Dally M voting after the opening four rounds, was one of five players axed by Tigers coach Michael Maguire from the team beaten 28-23 by the Titans and has been named in jersey No.18.


Second-rower Luke Garner, winger Robert Jennings, back-up dummy half Billy Walters and interchange forward Oliver Clark were also dropped, while prop Thomas Mikaele moves to the bench.

Besides Reynolds, the new faces are winger Tommy Talau, former Kiwis Test prop Russell Packer, second-rower Michael Chee-Kam and front-rower Zane Musgrove.

Chris Lawrence shifts from the interchange to second-row in place of Garner, while Talau replaces Jennings and Musgrove starts upfront for Mikaele, while Packer and Chee-Kam were named on the bench.

remote.axd

Round 5 - Marshall dropped, Taumalolo in line for return


Round 5 - Marshall dropped, Taumalolo in line for return

Maguire hinted at changes after the match, which the Tigers twice led by 10 points before allowing the Titans back into the contest.

Marshall kicked a 77th-minute field goal to give the Tigers a 23-22 lead but the Titans regained possession from the re-start and Phillip Sami scored to give the Titans their first win in almost a year.

The result left the 2014 premiership-winning coach to question the hunger of his players, who have had hard-fought wins over St George Illawarra and Cronulla and suffered a 42-24 loss to Newcastle.

"That performance is unacceptable for where we're at," Maguire said.

Deep down I was very, very confident because I knew I had done nothing

Wests Tigers utility Josh Reynolds
"I’m sick and tired of the ups-and-downs of performance. We need to change that.

"If you can’t be hungry enough to win a game of football then you need to look in the mirror, and those are the sort of things we need to be honest about."

Reynolds' recall continues a rollercoaster 12 months for the former NSW Origin five-eighth, who made just seven NRL appearances last season and had been 18th man for the last two matches.


Off the field, Reynolds successfully fought to clear his name after domestic violence charges were dropped by police and he was booked on Monday for driving with an expired licence.

He had been on his way home from Bankstown Airport after the team's return from Brisbane when stopped by police for a random alcohol and drugs test at 1.30am.

After recording what he described as a "false positive", Reynolds was then taken to Sutherland Police Station for a further test, which was negative.

A third swab was sent for testing at a laboratory and Reynolds insists he has nothing to fear.

remote.axd

Marshall field goal gives Wests Tigers a lead


Marshall field goal gives Wests Tigers a lead

"First of all I was in shock ... but deep down I was very, very confident because I knew I had done nothing," Reynolds told Sydney radio station 2GB on Tuesday.

"I've got nothing to hide. The guy who did my second test was a really good fellow.

"When the test came back negative he said 'I know you have had a bad run over the last month or whatnot but in the whole time I have been a copper I have never seen a test change from this point', so it has never gone from negative to positive."

The Tigers informed the NRL of the incident and no action has been taken against Reynolds, who said he was unaware his drivers licence had expired.

https://www.nrl.com/news/2020/06/09/marshall-dropped-as-reynolds-returns/
 

Vic Mackey

Referee
Messages
25,532
Benjis been Benji. He schooled a horrible saints team then produced 20 mins of magic against the sharks.

That’s with ball in hand. In defence he has been Darius like, and I’m not exaggerating.

Tigers right side has conceded 11 tries this season (most of any side) and Benji has been cited with 6 'try-causes' from FoxSportsLab, the most of any half along with the most missed tackles and the worst TE%

He also dominates Brooks who goes into his shell next to Benji (this isn’t all his fault, Brooks needs to stop being a pussy and tell Benji to get out of his way, he’s 25 and played 130 games now FFS)

Its the right call, whether Reynolds is a better option isn’t really the point.
 
Top