Best, Worst, Favourite and Most Under-Rated From Each Team

[thehattrickrabbit]

Thoughts and Opinions ???

Canberra
Best: Clinton Schifcofske
Worst: Adrian Purtell
Favourite: Adam Mogg
Under-Rated: Todd Carney

Broncos
Best: Darren Lockyer
Worst: Scott Minto
Favourite: Justin Hodges
Under-Rated: Tame Tupou

Knights
Best: Andrew Johns
Worst: Kurt Gidley
Favourite: Brian Carney
Under-Rated: Jarrod Mullen

Tigers
Best: Benji Marshall
Worst: Daniel Fitzhenry
Favourite: Benji Marshall
Under-Rated: Dean Collis

Storm
Best: Cameron Smith
Worst: Chris Walker (still a good player tho)
Favourite: Cameron Smith
Under-Rated: Steve Turner or Ryan Hoffman

Bulldogs:
Best: Sonny Bill Williams
Worst: Ben Czislowski
Favourite: Hazem El Masri
Under-Rated: Luke Patten

Rabbitohs:
Best: David Faalogo
Worst: Ben Walker
Favourite: John Sutton
Under-Rated: Luke McDougall

Cowboys:
Best: Johnathon Thurston
Worst: Neil Sweeney
Favourite: Josh Hannay
Under-Rated: Ty Williams

Roosters:
Best: Anthony Minichiello
Worst: Sam Perrett
Favourite: Amos Roberts
Under-Rated: Amos Roberts

Dragons:
Best: Mark Gasnier
Worst: Chris Sheppard
Favourite: Matt Cooper
Under-Rated: Dean Young

Warriors:
Best: Steve Price
Worst: Todd Byrne
Favourite: Clinton Toopi
Under-Rated: Sonny Fai

Panthers:
Best: Tony Puletua
Worst: Lee Hookey
Favourite: Frank Pritchard
Under-Rated: Michael Gordon

Manly:
Best: Ben Kennedy
Worst: Paul Stephenson
Favourite: Steve Menzies
Under-Rated: Kylie Leuluai

Parra:
Best: Nathan Hindmarsh
Worst: Matt Petersen
Favourite: Timana Tahu
Under-Rated: Wade McKinnon

Sharks:
Best: Nigel Vagana
Worst: Dave Simmons
Favourite: Brett Kimmorley
Under-Rated: Paul Gallen
--------------------------
Its Hard To Find a Crack or a Loose Nut in The Storm Team, So Storms Trash, would be another teams Treasure, Melbourne Cant Find Room In Their Side For Chris, So Thats why i think he is the worst

The Sharks could be contested between kimmorley, vagana or gallen imo

otherwise i think its pretty uncontested

 

[mattyg]

Canberra
Best: Clinton Schifcofske
Worst: Adrian Purtell
Favourite: Adam Mogg
Under-Rated: Todd Carney

Broncos
Best: Darren Lockyer
Worst: Scott Minto
Favourite: Shane Webcke
Under-Rated: Tame Tupou

Knights
Best: Andrew Johns
Worst: George Carmont
Favourite: Brian Carney
Under-Rated: Jarrod Mullen

Tigers
Best: Benji Marshall
Worst: Daniel Fitzhenry
Favourite: Benji Marshall/Robbie Farah
Under-Rated: Dean Collis

Storm
Best: Cameron Smith
Worst: Chris Walker
Favourite: Cameron Smith
Under-Rated: Ryan Hoffman

Bulldogs:
Best: Sonny Bill Williams/Willie Mason
Worst: Ben Czislowski
Favourite: Sonny Bill Williams
Under-Rated: Luke Patten

Rabbitohs:
Best: David Faalogo
Worst: Ben Walker
Favourite: John Sutton
Under-Rated: Nathan Merritt

Cowboys:
Best: Johnathon Thurston
Worst: Neil Sweeney
Favourite: Johnathan Thurston
Under-Rated: Ty Williams

Roosters:
Best: Anthony Minichiello
Worst: all of them :lol:
Favourite: none
Under-Rated: none

Dragons:
Best: Mark Gasnier
Worst: Chris Sheppard
Favourite: Luke Bailey
Under-Rated: Dean Young

Warriors:
Best: Steve Price
Worst: Todd Byrne
Favourite: Steve Price
Under-Rated: Patrick Ah Van

Panthers:
Best: Craig Gower
Worst: Lee Hookey
Favourite: Frank Pritchard
Under-Rated: Michael Gordon

Manly:
Best: Ben Kennedy
Worst: Paul Stephenson
Favourite: none
Under-Rated: Kylie Leuluai

Parra:
Best: Nathan Hindmarsh
Worst: Matt Petersen
Favourite: Jarrod Hayne
Under-Rated: Wade McKinnon

Sharks:
Best: Nigel Vagana
Worst: LUKE COVELL
Favourite: Lance Thompson
Under-Rated: Paul Gallen

 

[lockyno1]

Storm

Best: Greg Ingliss
Worst: None, maybe Chris Walker.
Underated: Ryan Hoffman
Favourite: Cooper Cronk

Bulldogs:

Best: Wille Mason
Worst: Ben Cizralski
Underated; Daniel Holdsworth
Favourite: Hazem El Masri

Broncos

Best: Lockyer
Worst: Jane Carlaw
Underated: Corey Parker
Favourite: Justin Hodges/Lockyer

Eagles

Best; Kennedy
Wost: Dunley
Underated: Chris Hicks
Favourite; Brett Stewart

Eels

Best: Nathan Hindmarsh
Worst: ?
Underated: Luke O'Dwyer
Favourite: Luke Burt

Knights:

Best: Danny Buderus
Underated: Craig Smith
Worst: Carmont
Favourite: Milton Thaiday

Dragons

Best: Matt Head
Underated: Ben Hornby
Worst: Colin Best!
Favourite: Dean Young

Raiders

Best: Schifoscke
Worst: Purtell
Underated: Alan Tongue
Favourite: Phil Graham

Sharks:

Best: Adam Dykes
Worst: Brett Kimmorley/Beau Scott!
Underated: Paul Gallen
Favourite: Ben Pommeroy

Panthers

Best; Craig Gower
Underated: Luke Priddis
Worst: Lee Hookey
Favourite: Rhys Wesser

Cowboys:

Best; Johnathon Thurston
Worst: Firman (only on his form for the cowboys)
Underated: Justin Smith
Favourite: Aaron Payne

Warriors

Best: Steve Price
Underated: Nathan Fien
Worst: ?
Favourite: Vatuvei

Roosters

Best: Craig Fitzgibbon
Worst: Anasta
Underated: Sam Perett
Favourite: Amos Roberts

Tigers

Best :Benji Marshall
Worst: Fitzhenry
Underated: Dean Collis
Favourite: Prince

Rabbitohs

Best: John Sutton
Worst: Ben Walker
Underated: Peter Cusak
Favourite: David Peachey.

 

[Pure_Knight]

Thoughts and Opinions ???

Canberra
Best: Clinton Schifcofske
Worst: David Howell
Favourite: Todd Carney
Under-Rated: Phil Graham

Broncos
Best: Darren Lockyer
Worst: Scott Minto
Favourite: Michael Ennis
Under-Rated: Tame Tupou

Knights
Best: Andrew Johns
Worst: George Carmony/Regan Tanner
Favourite: Brian Carney
Under-Rated: Jarrod Mullen/Steve Simpson
Over-Rated: Kurt Gidley lol

Tigers
Best: Benji Marshall
Worst: Daniel Fitzhenry
Favourite: Robbie Farah
Under-Rated: Anthony Laffranci

Storm
Best: Cameron Smith
Worst: Jeremy Smith
Favourite: Cooper Cronk
Under-Rated: Ryan Hoffman

Bulldogs:
Best: Sonny Bill Williams
Worst: Corey Hughes
Favourite: Willie Mason
Under-Rated: Daniel Holdsworth

Rabbitohs:
Best: David Faalogo
Worst: Ben Walker
Favourite: Luke Macdougall
Under-Rated: Nathan Meritt

Cowboys:
Best: Matthew Bowen
Worst: Justin Smith
Favourite: Matt Scott
Under-Rated: Gavin Cooper

Roosters:
Best: Anthony Minichiello
Worst: Sam Perrett
Favourite: Amos Roberts
Under-Rated: Josh Lewis

Dragons:
Best: Mark Gasnier
Worst: Andrew Price
Favourite: Trent Barrett
Under-Rated: Dean Young

Warriors:
Best: Brent Webb
Worst: Jerome Ropati
Favourite: Brent Webb
Under-Rated: Grant Rovelli

Panthers:
Best: Craig Gower
Worst: Lee Hookey
Favourite: Rhys Wesser
Under-Rated: Joel Clinton

Manly:
Best: Ben Kennedy
Worst: Mark Bryant
Favourite: Brett Stewart
Under-Rated: Travis Burns

Parra:
Best: Timana Tahu
Worst: Ben Smith
Favourite: Eric Grothe
Under-Rated: Luke O'Dwyer

Sharks:
Best: Adam Dykes
Worst: Luke Covell
Favourite: Paul Gallen
Under-Rated: Greg Bird
--------------------------

 

[lockyno1]

Luke Covell is not as bad as Beau Scott at least for the Sharks!

 

[Phillips]

Canberra
Best: Clinton Schifcofske
Worst: Adrian Purtell
Favourite: Josh Miller
Under-Rated: Alan Tongue

Broncos
Best: Darren Lockyer
Worst:
Favourite: Justin Hodges
Under-Rated: Shaun Berrigan

Knights
Best: Andrew Johns
Worst:
Favourite: Brian Carney
Under-Rated: David Seage

Tigers
Best: Benji Marshall
Worst:
Favourite: Taniela Tuiaki
Under-Rated: Dean Collis/Ben Galea

Storm
Best: Cameron Smith
Worst:
Favourite: Jake Webster/David Kidwell
Under-Rated: Cooper Cronk

Bulldogs:
Best: Sonny Bill Williams
Worst: Ben Czislowski/Corey Hughes
Favourite: Willie Tonga
Under-Rated: Tony Grimaldi

Rabbitohs:
Best: David Peachey
Worst: Mick Moran
Favourite: John Sutton
Under-Rated: Peter Cusack

Cowboys:
Best: Johnathon Thurston
Worst: Ashley Graham
Favourite: Luke O'Donnell
Under-Rated: Aaron Payne

Roosters:
Best: Anthony Minichiello
Worst: Braith Anasta/Joel Monaghan
Favourite: Adrian Morley
Under-Rated: Amos Roberts

Dragons:
Best: Mark Gasnier
Worst:
Favourite: Reece Simmonds
Under-Rated: Matt Bickerstaff

Warriors:
Best: Steve Price
Worst: Clinton Toopi (now with Leeds lol)
Favourite: Wairangi Koopu
Under-Rated: Micheal Luck/George Gatis

Panthers:
Best: Tony Puletua
Worst:
Favourite: Luke Priddis
Under-Rated: Craig Stapleton

Manly:
Best: Ben Kennedy
Worst: Jason King
Favourite: Steve Menzies/Kylie Leuluai
Under-Rated: Mark Bryant

Parramatta:
Best: Nathan Hindmarsh
Worst: Matt Petersen
Favourite: Wade McKinnon/Glenn Morrison/Eric Grothe/Timana Tahu
Under-Rated: Wade McKinnon/Glenn Morrison

Sharks:
Best: Paul Gallen
Worst: Brett Kimmorley
Favourite: Ben Pomeroy
Under-Rated:

 

[Frederick]

Broncos:
Best: Darren Lockyer
Worst: Dane Carlaw
Favourite: Shane Wekcke
Under-rated: Tame Tupou

Bulldogs:
Best: Willie Mason
Worst: Ben Czislowski
Favourite: Umm...:?
Under-rated: Daniel Holdsworth

Raiders:
Best: Clinton Schifcofske
Worst: Adrian Purtell
Favourite: Thom Learoyd-Lahs
Under-rated: Todd Carney

Sharks:
Best: Adam Dykes
Worst: Luke Covell
Favourite: Paul Gallan
Under-rated: Ben Pommeroy

Knights:
Best: Andrew Johns
Worst: Kurt Gidley
Favourite: Brian Carney
Under-rated: Jarrod Mullen

Cowboys:
Best: Jonathan Thurston
Worst: Brett Firman
Favourite: Matt Bowen
Under-rated: Gavin Cooper

Eels:
Best: Nathan Hindmarsh
Worst: Matt Peterson
Favourite: Jarryd Hayne
Under-rated: Josh Cordoba

Sea-Eagles:
Best: Ben Kennedy
Worst: Shane Dunley
Favourite: Steve Menzies
Under-rated: Travis Burns

Storm:
Best: Cameron Smith
Worst: Chris Walker
Favourite: Cameron Smith
Under-rated: Brett White

Panthers:
Best: Preston Campbell
Worst: Lee Hookey
Favourite: Joel Clinton
Under-rated: Michael Gordon

Rabbitohs:
Best: David Fa-alogo
Worst: Ben Walker
Favourite: Nathan Merritt
Under-rated: Nathan Merritt

Dragons:
Best: Matthew Head
Worst: Chris Sheppard
Favourite: Matthew Head
Under-rated: Dean Young

Roosters:
Best: Anthony Minichiello
Worst: Braith Anasta or Brett Finch
Favourite: None...
Under-rated: Shaun Foley

Warriors:
Best: Steve Price
Worst: Epalahame Lauaki
Favourite: Evarn Tuimavave
Under-rated: George Gatis

Tigers:
Best: Benji Marshall
Worst: Daniel Fitzhenry
Favourite: Brett Hodgson
Under-rated: Shannon McDonnell

 

[Pure_Knight]

Luke Covell is not as bad as Beau Scott at least for the Sharks!

Its an opinion thing i gues...
I think beau scott has alot of potential
Covell imo is very average. Way to slow for a winger. Good kicker, good size, tries hard but yea just my opinion

 

[Dr Crane]

Warriors:
Best: Steve Price
Worst: Todd Byrne
Favourite: Clinton Toopi
Under-Rated: Sonny Fai

Pick again!

 

[Smiley]

Thoughts and Opinions ???


Broncos
Best: Darren Lockyer
Worst: Scott Minto
Favourite: Michael Ennis
Under-Rated: Tame Tupou


--------------------------

how the hell can he be favourite hes only played 5 games. Also Brett Seymour is a worst player.

 

[Utey]

Parra:
Best: Nathan Hindmarsh
Worst: Matt Petersen
Favourite: Fuifui Moimoi
Under-Rated: Luke Burt

 

[Master Rooster]

Best : Minichiello
Worst : Finch
Favourite : Minichiello (used to be morley)
Underrated : Lewis/Soward as our halves

 

[douglasallen91]

haha favourite clinton toopi. every warriors fan went into party mode when he left

 

[mxlegend99]

Broncos:
Best: Darren Lockyer
Worst: Jane Carlaw
Favourite: Karmichael Hunt
Under-rated: Tame Tupou


Bulldogs:
Best: Willie Mason
Worst: Ben Czislowski
Favourite: Sonny Bill Williams
Under-rated: Luke Patten


Raiders:
Best: Clinton Shifcofske
Worst: Steve Clark
Favourite: Phil Graham
Under-rated: Todd Carney


Sharks:
Best: Adam Dykes
Worst: Darren Albert
Favourite: Ben Ross
Under-rated: Ben Pomeroy


Knights:
Best: Andrew Johns
Worst: Kurt Gidley
Favourite: Andrew Johns
Under-rated: Milton Thaiday


Cowboys:
Best: Johnathon Thurston
Worst: Josh Hannay
Favourite: Matt Bowen
Under-rated: Aaron Payne


Eels:
Best: Nathan Hindmarsh
Worst: Matt Peterson
Favourite: Eric Grothe Jr.
Under-rated: Luke Burt


Sea Eagles:
Best: Ben Kennedy
Worst: Shane Dunley
Favourite: Brett Stewart
Under-rated: Brett Stewart


Storm:
Best: Cameron Smith
Worst: N/A
Favourite: Greg Inglis
Under-rated: Steve Turner


Panthers:
Best: Luke Priddis
Worst: Lee Hookey
Favourite: Paul Aiton
Under-rated: Michael Gordon


Rabbitohs:
Best: David Peachey
Worst: Ben Walker
Favourite: Joe Gulavou
Under-rated: Peter Cusack


Dragons:
Best: Mark Gasnier
Worst: Trent Barrett (due to the curse)
Favourite: Mark Gasnier
Under-rated: Ben Hornby


Roosters:
Best: Anthony Minichello
Worst: Brett Finch
Favourite: Amos Roberts
Under-rated: Shaun Foley


Warriors:
Best: Steve Price
Worst: Jerome Ropati
Favourite: Ruben Wiki
Under-rated: Brent Webb


Tigers:
Best: Scott Prince
Worst: Daniel Fitzhenry
Favourite: Paul Whatuira
Under-rated: Shannon McDonnell

 

[Loz]

Raiders:
Best: Clinton Shifcofske
Worst: Steve Clark
Favourite: Phil Graham
Under-rated: Todd Carney

:lol: :lol: :lol:

 

[mxlegend99]

He would've been the best except he got the penalty count around the wrong way.

 

[Cletus]

Manly

Best: Kennedy
Favourite: Beaver
Worst: Robertson at fullback
Most Underrated: Chris Hicks

 

[sooperdooper]

eels
best: Hindmarsh
Worst: Peterson (plays with alot of heart)
Fave: Hindmarsh/fui
Under rated: McKinnon

 

[thehattrickrabbit]

how can he be the best centre in the world along side jamie lyon in 2002, to become the warriors worst player

to suggest mannering is better than toopi is joke
to suggest martin is better than toopi is a joke

he is one of your best players, sure he isnt in form, but every player goes through a stage of lack of form

in the NZ Test this year or last year cant remember which one, he smoked gasnier and cooper put together, scored 2 or 3 tries against one of them, cant remember which one..

NZ Team

Webb
Meli
Webster
Toopi
Vainikolo
Nigel Vagana
Jeremy Smith (any one is better than leuluai)

 

[Dr Crane]

how can he be the best centre in the world along side jamie lyon in 2002, to become the warriors worst player

to suggest mannering is better than toopi is joke
to suggest martin is better than toopi is a joke

he is one of your best players, sure he isnt in form, but every player goes through a stage of lack of form

That is the question we are all asking.



Mannering is way better than Toopi.
Martin is more reliable and therefore better than Toopi.

He's gone now and he's making an arse of himself for Leeds. Sometimes he shows up to smoke Australia, but he's never in it week in week out.

And your New Zealand team is crap too.