Waddell was must better - couldn't get much worse from his first appearance.
However, let's look long term.
I said it earlier in the year - Nikorima looks like he's just not happen coming in off the bench. He is a half being shoehorned into the No. 9 spot, and I honestly don't see him as a long-term proposition.
Depending on how long Jack Reed takes to make it back the Nikorima situation might work itself out.
Most likely we lose him to another club though.