Great thread - I was mulling over that very question since their win versus Souths. My answer after considering all the facts ,and not just looking at the table is...no. Lets analyse,
1 Who in the top 8 have they beaten? Melb - without Cam Smith, playing Sat in Perth, after a Monday night game and the week from hell. Discount this result as irrelevant.
2 Other wins - Cronulla, wow NSW cup side. Warriors, after sacking their coach, and by 1 pt. Souths - NSW cup side, with a bench straight out of a WW1 novel, by 1 pt. Chooks - in the wet, and with brains like Maloney, the Dogs were ready to lose. Lucky by 1 pt too.
Who have they lost to? Penrith - top 8 contender and at full strength,and the Broncos. Now this is the game we should judge them on. Full strength Broncos away from home ,toyed with them - gave them a fair old pounding.
Its great for the NRL that their SBS team is doing well, it keeps the west interested in the footy. I don't get fooled easily, if at all, and this Dogs team hasn't won me over - they are dogs in sheep's clothing.
I only hope that the Dogs, with their unattractive/boring football ,don't drag the game back to the eighties, the game doesn't need to revisit such dark football days ever again.