Buy of the Year 2007

[ashee9]

Who do you think has been the buy of the year for 2007?
Im swinging towards Wade McKinnon but hard to look past Roy Asotasi.

Your thoughts

 

[Timmah]

Not Jamie Lyon.


In all seriousness... I don't know :-s

I don't think Asotasi or McKinnon, if they were such great buys their teams would be in the eight on the back of their form.

Best buy for the Bulldogs would have to definitely be Darryl Millard.

 

[smeghead]

Probably Prince for the Titans IMHO

 

[Rovelli]

We had a thread about this very recently.

 

[ashee9]

Yeah Lyon has to be the worst buy. There are a few more out there too:

• Sharks: Brett Seymour
• Knights: Todd Polglase
• Panthers: Brett Firman
• Roosters: Ntae Myles

Where are all these guys this year?!?!?! Myles has played origin this year, but has had a very poor season, probably becuase of the team he so stupidly joined.:crazy:

 

[roosterman57]

jamie soward... he didnt do much at the roosters but hes doing miracles for the dragons lately...

 

[PARRA_FAN]

Roy Asotasi for sure, the Souths forwards have been going well thanks to Roy.

McKinnon isnt far behind though.

Another is Prince for Gold Coast, his current form doesnt surprise me.

 

[Sugar]

Matt Elliott

 

[Nook]

It'd have to be Prince.

 

[NK Arsenal]

Best: Wade McKinnon, Roy Asotasi, Scott Prince and Jamie Soward
Worst: Jamie Lyon

 

[always a raider]

Matt Elliott

:lol:

I beleive some Panther fans call him "The Messiah"

 

[always a raider]

Neville Costigan and Scott Logan for the Green.

 

[Mayor_Quimby]

Lyon closely followed by Asotasi

 

[Timmah]

Lyon is a liability :lol:

 

[PARRA_FAN]

What about Jason Moodie.?

 

[CharlieF]

Lyon, one only has too look at the improvement in Manly in 2007. It is about the best buy of 2007 isn't it?? Who gives a crap about SOO.

Roy Asotasi gets an honorable mention, even though Kidwell seemed to have given just as much value when he was there.

 

[CharlieF]

Lyon is a liability :lol:

I think there might be another thread about worst buy of the year, but this is not it.

 

[Mayor_Quimby]

Lyon is a liability :lol:

jealous

 

[Timmah]

Conversely, they've been better without BK... what do you make of that?

Attributing Manly's improved form solely to WeeWaaF*cktard is moronic.

 

[Timmah]

jealous

Of? You have a fat dribbler in your team whose selection contributed to the downfall of NSW in SOO this year.