Byrne or Vatuvei

[K1w1 Lurvin]

I will have to go with Todd Byrne on this 1 because Vatuvei absolutely drives me crazy with his silly errors......

 

[RHYTHM AND STEALTH]

What a sh*t poll. Manu any day of the week

 

[MKEB...]

Byrne runs like he is in moonboots...seriously. And doesnt really instill fear into the heart of an opposition player.

Vatuvei's errors were earlier in the season and I dont think he has done much wrong lately.

 

[SpaceMonkey]

Vatuvei. Way more dangerous on attack and does a lot of work as an extra forward bringing the ball out of his own end. Byrne was a useful player when he went looking for work in the centres but was average at best when he just stayed out on his wing.

 

[Lego_Man]

We havent seen the best of Vatuvei, but if he loses weight and fulfils his potential to any significant degree....he'll be 10x the player than Byrne is.

 

[K1w1 Lurvin]

Vatuvei drops about 6 or 7 balls.. half of them in the in goal area...
Tackles like a little school boy jersey grabing...
Runs the ball into touch a few times
And then scores 2 trys to make himself look good......
Meanwhile Byrne is a great finisher (maybe not as good as Vatuvei) tackles his heart out and is consistant most of the time......

 

[Mixmasterreece]

and is consistant most of the time......

isnt that a contradiction ?

 

[Martli]

Vatuvei, easy question.

 

[SpaceMonkey]

Vatuvei drops about 6 or 7 balls.. half of them in the in goal area...

lol in a season maybe.... and it's not as if Byrne never dropped a ball.

Tackles like a little school boy jersey grabing...

Nothing wrong with his tackling that I've seen, he's pulled off a few try-savers nailing players into touch in the corners.

Runs the ball into touch a few times

He's a winger, they get the ball near the sideline, of course they're gonna run out of room occaisionally.

And then scores 2 trys to make himself look good......

Well that's what wingers are supposed to do isn't it....

Do you have a hard-on for Turtle Byrne or did Manu f**k your sister or something?

 

[Dr Crane]

Vatuvei drops about 6 or 7 balls.. half of them in the in goal area...
Tackles like a little school boy jersey grabing...
Runs the ball into touch a few times
And then scores 2 trys to make himself look good......
Meanwhile Byrne is a great finisher (maybe not as good as Vatuvei) tackles his heart out and is consistant most of the time......

How many Warriors games have you ever watched?

 

[NZ Warrior]

It's Todd Byrne everybody!!! *claps*

We've all forgotten about you, Toddy. Hence why the poll currently reads 11-1. Back to Bartercard for you, pal.

 

[Mixmasterreece]

Man this is the most inane thread Ive come across in a looooooong time

 

[Mixmasterreece]

Ive said it once and I'll say it a thousand times again ; I once saw two guys kissing on a park bench and that was the gayest thing I'd EVER seen until I read this thread.

 

[Iafeta]

This is funny!

That said though, we've written Toddy off fairly quickly - we shouldn't forget he played fantastic for us last year all told. 14 tries or something, 7 tries in 7 games at one stage including a couple of decisive ones - notably the killer blow against Melbourne.

 

[ozbash]

makes you wonder tho,, great one year, rubbish the next..

why ?

 

[byrne_rovelli_fan82]

I worry about Manu when it comes to his very prone hamstrings.

 

[Dr Crane]

makes you wonder tho,, great one year, rubbish the next..

why ?

Lack of motivation? Who expected either Misi or Blinky to be up there as starting wingers?

 

[Iafeta]

oz, he seemed to be playing injured - a bit of strapping around the thigh.

My prediction is he'll bounce back next season. He's a good chance at sticking with us in the fact he's probably (at a guess) decent value for performance per dollar paid.

 

[Kakihara]

Kemp allowed him to roam last year and it worked out best for him.

 

[Bullseye]

Heard a rumour that Bradford are interested in Manu. Anything in it?