Discussion in 'Parramatta Eels' started by butch82, Jun 3, 2008.
It was like 993 this morning!! What's the go?!?! :lol:
all of the gold from late last night of me and others battling with Jatz Crackers was moved to the Swamp so that brought the post count down significantly for this thread.
We shall just have to WORK HARDER then! :lol:
So you're saying if Etu had played there was a chance he would have had played better than Williams did in his last two games?
No he's saying that if Etu was fit, Williams would still be in NYC.
If you refer to my original question I was asking if that was right or not.
Im being very positive here but i was thinking, maybe we've got a pretty got deal with Williams.
Look at all the big stars to play the game, they always have what they call the 2nd year syndrome even Hayne had it IMO.
So we have him while the other coaches don't know hes weaknesses and other wingers, centres and general players etc haven't played against him so don't know how he plays. People get carried away with players like Williams but being strong and quick doesn't always mean you will be a great first grade player.
I don't know, I don't have a Crystal ball. I don't know how Etu would have played in the last two games, nor really do we know how Eric would have played in those games.
Tony put in a great piece of defensive play against the Raiders holding a bloke up, don't get me wrong, but he is getting a few kicks put in behind him as well as jamming in on the centre to leave the wingers unmarked.
Based on what you've seen out of Etu and Williams who would you have played in first grade if you were the coach?
No worries - happy to oblige. The great Tony Williams will he or won't he has got to be in the running for the League Unlimited Forum's Thread of the Year Award.
Incidentally, if no such award is in existence, as I suspect it is not, then I propose that "chance T Williams might stay..." be named the inaugural winner.
I have seen Etu play more full back than wing, but he is quick. Tony I have seen play Second row and his runs over people (at least in the 20's at that position). So at wing, I don't know, and I am not the coach.
I know you're not the coach but hypothetically if you had to choose last week who do you think should have been picked if both were available?
Two weeks ago, I would have picked Jono Wright if I had my Choice.
Come on you lazy sods lift this thread to 1000, or I may have to go back and talk to the horse. By the way I still don't believe the big boy has offically signed !
horse! horse! horse! horse! ....
this is like an exciting announcement
I asked a horse if Tony was staying....he wasn't saying nuffing
So whats happening with Parramatta Judas The 2nd?
Me or Judas :sarcasm:
Separate names with a comma.