Coach of the year?

[Loudstrat]

• The cases:

Ricky Stuart
For:

• Within a shot of minor premiership
• With one game to go, have inproved by 14 competition points

Against:

• Have only scored ONE more point than last year so far.

Brad Fittler
For:

• Improved their points differential by 220 points
• Taken then from non-finalists to top four

Against:

• IN a slump
• Did nothing not expected of him with all that talent

Brian Smith
For:

• Improved their points differential by 342 points
• Taken them from second last to finals (almost)

Against:

• Only three more wins so far than in 07

Neil Henry
For

• Points differential improvement of 225 points on 07
• Taken spoon favorites to an ace of the top 4

Against:

• Knifed the club off field.
• ONly jagged three more wins

Nathan Brown
For

• Points differential increase by 217
• Overcame major drama at club, including his demise as head coach

Against:

• Still should be higher with his squad

Craig Bellamy
For:

• Probable minor premiers
• Still a force despite GF win
• Best points differential in comp.

Against:

• Lost 5 more games so far
• Scored 86 less points

Des Hasler
For:

• Shot at Minor Premiership

Against:

• Lost three more games so far (with two to play)

NB - wouldn't it be funny if Brownie got it - only sacked coach to win coach of the year :lol::lol:

 

[watatank]

My pick is Stuart but I think it may be decided by who takes out the minor premiership.

Nathan Brown
For

• Points differential increase by 217
• Overcame major drama at club, including his demise as head coach

Against:

• Still should be higher with his squad

How high *should* the Dragons be? We aren't playing with the same side we were two or three years ago when you might have had a point. IMO we have grossly overachieved this year. Most experts were tipping us to miss the eight.

 

[lockyno1]

Henry, easily. Team tipped to get the spoon will come top6.

 

[Ausguy]

thats an amazing stat that the sharks have 14 more competition points this year but have only scored 1 more point.....

 

[maple_69]

I don't get it..where's Matt Elliott?













Oh right.

 

[Eels Dude]

Is this poll about who WILL win? Or who SHOULD win? I'll only vote on the latter as I believe the former is pointless, so if you could clear that up Loudstrat it would be great.

 

[McLovin]

Ricky Stuart - Look at the cattle of the Storm, Rooster, Eagles...Now look at the Sharks. How he has managed to get that team into the top 4 is beyond me...

 

[Slackboy72]

Where's the option for Michael Hagan?

 

[Frederick]

Brian Smith
For:

• Improved their points differential by 342 points
• Taken them from second last to finals (almost)

Against:

• Only three more wins so far than in 07

Mind you he's also done all this with a completely new team after the massive player cleanout last year. The fact that he's got a team with so many mass changes to gel so quickly that they've just knocked off the best team for the past 3 years and are on the verge of making the playoffs is brilliant within itself.

 

[wittyfan]

Ricky Stuart without a doubt.

 

[Godz Illa]

Brian Smith
For:

• Improved their points differential by 342 points
• Taken them from second last to finals (almost)

Against:

• Only three more wins so far than in 07

Signing Danny Wicks should equal instant disqualification.

 

[Loudstrat]

Is this poll about who WILL win? Or who SHOULD win? I'll only vote on the latter as I believe the former is pointless, so if you could clear that up Loudstrat it would be great.

Read the title of the thread. Then all will be revealed.

 

[Frederick]

[/list]
Signing Danny Wicks should equal instant disqualification.

True that :lol:
The kid has the potential to be anything, but is just so f**king fat it's not funny. I also cannot believe that he stayed at home on Saturday night as he had a cold...

I hope Smith fires a massive rocket up his arse during the off-season

 

[gurstar]

i didnt see tim sheens name there ha ha ha

 

[azza]

Henry, easily. Team tipped to get the spoon will come top6.

Although it's possible, it's unlikely IMO the Raiders will finish in the top 6.

 

[Matt23]

I'd give it to Ricky Stuart

 

[Special K]

sticky no doubt

 

[Ausguy]

I'd give it to Ricky Stuart

id give it to ricky stuart to if he wins me a comp :crazy:

 

[Jono078]

Probably Ricky Stuart.

Although Sharks arent the prettiest team to watch he has gotten them to the top.

For coach that gets their team up and playing good to watch footy, id give it to Brian Smith or Neil Henry.

 

[BWNB]

Sticky, just look how he got the boys to play on Friday. Weren't the sharks tipped to finish bottom 3?