Old Kogarah Boy 1
First Grade
- Messages
- 5,415
As long as Mary doesn't de-skill him.
Merah, you do make a valid point.
As long as Mary doesn't de-skill him.
SGI has a few really talented players who are top shelf. The likes of Hunt, Norman, Vaughan, Frizell and Sims are a good core of players to build a competitive team around. Our second tier players, McInnes, Graham and maybe K Sims are the standard of player we should be recruiting to support our top shelf players.Thought Norman played overall very composed considering he debuted in a decider in Sydney.
That kick for the first try of the match was on a dime
Was also pleased to see Hunt among the QLD better players again. His line break in the 78th minute should have had more support, he almost got them within field goal range with that run
SGI has a few really talented players who are top shelf. The likes of Hunt, Norman, Vaughan, Frizell and Sims are a good core of players to build a competitive team around. Our second tier players, McInnes, Graham and maybe K Sims are the standard of player we should be recruiting to support our top shelf players.
Of course there is room for up and coming players like Lomax, Pearson, Leilua, Saab and yes Ravalawa. However, there is really no excuse for retaining some of the deadwood we are currently stuck with Dufty, Aitken, Lafai, Maranta, Runciman and Nicholls some of which are eating up valuable salary cap and preventing SGI from holding the depth needed to succeed in the NRL competition.
We often see at other clubs new young 18 year olds bring blooded into NRL sides and then forming the necessary depth or pushing through to first grade level. Unfortunately at SGI we seem to go for players like Marenta over Masters and contract Nicholls over Clune and we lament that we 'can't keep them all' when players like Robson, Timm, Masters and maybe a few other young plaers feel the need to leave SGI.
I say the way to avoid most of this and set on a path which would allow us to move forward with a squad of better depth and first graders of a higher standard is to:
1. Plan to rid the club of our deadwood ASAP. This includes the coachng staff.
2. Recruit only first grade player 'like for like OR BETTER' to fill our first choice first grade 17.
3. Back fill with depth comprising a mix of our best and brightest young players and credible second tier first graders who come at an economical price.
4. Improve our pathways system by creating 5 level stages of progress with a criteria of skill-sets that players are required to meet before moving to the next stage of the ladder path for selection to first grade. SGI should ensure that those young players coming through can tackle, pass the ball both ways, competently take a pass and/or a high ball and have a good understanding of positional play.
5. The separation between the management of pathways/recruitment/retention and coaching should revert to the old system of reporting to the head coach. The head coach should report to the football manager or the CEO depending on the structure preferred by the Board.
SGI has a few really talented players who are top shelf. The likes of Hunt, Norman, Vaughan, Frizell and Sims are a good core of players to build a competitive team around. Our second tier players, McInnes, Graham and maybe K Sims are the standard of player we should be recruiting to support our top shelf players.
Of course there is room for up and coming players like Lomax, Pearson, Leilua, Saab and yes Ravalawa. However, there is really no excuse for retaining some of the deadwood we are currently stuck with Dufty, Aitken, Lafai, Maranta, Runciman and Nicholls some of which are eating up valuable salary cap and preventing SGI from holding the depth needed to succeed in the NRL competition.
We often see at other clubs new young 18 year olds bring blooded into NRL sides and then forming the necessary depth or pushing through to first grade level. Unfortunately at SGI we seem to go for players like Marenta over Masters and contract Nicholls over Clune and we lament that we 'can't keep them all' when players like Robson, Timm, Masters and maybe a few other young plaers feel the need to leave SGI.
I say the way to avoid most of this and set on a path which would allow us to move forward with a squad of better depth and first graders of a higher standard is to:
1. Plan to rid the club of our deadwood ASAP. This includes the coachng staff.
2. Recruit only first grade player 'like for like OR BETTER' to fill our first choice first grade 17.
3. Back fill with depth comprising a mix of our best and brightest young players and credible second tier first graders who come at an economical price.
4. Improve our pathways system by creating 5 level stages of progress with a criteria of skill-sets that players are required to meet before moving to the next stage of the ladder path for selection to first grade. SGI should ensure that those young players coming through can tackle, pass the ball both ways, competently take a pass and/or a high ball and have a good understanding of positional play.
5. The separation between the management of pathways/recruitment/retention and coaching should revert to the old system of reporting to the head coach. The head coach should report to the football manager or the CEO depending on the structure preferred by the Board.
Another big chance for him to step up tonight and fell extremely flat. Probably his worst performance of all, and he's had a few. He ran rings around the Bulldogs and kicked two important field goals this year. Everything else has been putrid from him.
Second worst signing blooper we've made.
But remember...he's much better than widdop according to many on here...
Widdop walks right back in to number 6.
Widdop walks right back in to number 6.
For what purpose? A token gesture only or a reminder that SGI will be losing one of the NRL’s elite players next year?
Either thought is utterly depressing.
If Widdop is returning next week I would use it as the opportunity to give Norman a much required attitude test and drop him to cc for the rest of the season, he is kidding everyone including himself based on what he did tonight.I know there is nothing to be gained but you pick your best team, or 'your least worst team' in our case.
Wait he’s like so many of our much vaunted forward packIf Widdop is returning next week I would use it as the opportunity to give Norman a much required attitude test and drop him to cc for the rest of the season, he is kidding everyone including himself based on what he did tonight.
Wait he’s like so many of our much vaunted forward pack
A rep player beyond reproach and a certainty to be picked every week
Are you being serious?How we going this year without him ???? We were a much better side with him @ 6 and Hunt @ 7....
Regardless the main issue is McGregor.....
I'm still not convinced about Norman, except for his field goal kicking.Another big chance for him to step up tonight and fell extremely flat. Probably his worst performance of all, and he's had a few. He ran rings around the Bulldogs and kicked two important field goals this year. Everything else has been putrid from him.
Second worst signing blooper we've made.