What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Cowboys steaming over heat breaks

nqboy

First Grade
Messages
8,914
LINK

By Dean Ritchie
September 14, 2007 12:00am


THE NRL will consider implementing heat measures for Sunday's sudden-death semi-final in Townsville - but the move has angered the North Queensland Cowboys.

The mercury is expected to soar as high as 31C at Dairy Farmers Stadium by the 4pm kickoff for the Cowboys' semi-final against the New Zealand Warriors. If the heat is oppressive, doctors from both clubs could introduce a one-minute drinks break midway through each half, an extended 15-minute halftime break and have all three trainers carrying water bottles.

There are concerns for the Warriors players, who are coming from a 13C climate in Auckland and will be wearing black jumpers. Having home ground advantage, the Cowboys have opted to wear their white away jumpers rather than the blue home strip - forcing New Zealand to wear black.

But North Queensland chief executive Peter Parr told The Daily Telegraph last night each half should be a continuous 40 minutes. "We don't get to use heaters over in Auckland after 20 minutes of each half," Parr said. "We do have to consider the welfare of our players but it is a finals game. "I would have thought we'd play under the same rules as normal, where you play 40 minutes straight through. I don't think the Warriors would be expecting a break either. "Maybe a bit more is being made about the heat than it should be."

Warriors chief executive Wayne Scurrah said the club's medical staff were best qualified to make the decision over the heat. "It will be something best left to the medical people," he said. "But if they agree that it (the heat measures) should be done for the players' welfare, then it should happen. There's been a lot of debate about the heat. But the game is on at 4pm, not midday, so hopefully the sun won't be on the field with the grandstands there at Dairy Farmers."

Asked about having to wear black jumpers, Scurrah said: "That's our colour. There are no complaints about having to wear black."

The Warriors are, however, yet to apply to the NRL to have additional water breaks during the game. NRL chief operating officer Graham Annesley said player welfare was crucial. "We have had rules in place all year that cater for the possibility of extreme heat," Annesley said. "If the two club doctors agree some relief is required, the heat measures we can introduce are there to make sure everything possible is done to protect player welfare."

The Cowboys are keen to use the heat to their psychological advantage. Hooker David Faiumu said: "Sunday at four o'clock. It doesn't get any hotter than that in Australia." Cowboys coach Graham Murray added: "It will be a hot day up here on Sunday, no doubt about that."
 

innsaneink

Referee
Messages
29,368
Very very simple solution, play this game on the Saturday nite, and the Bulldogs/Eels clash on the Sunday...but noooooo....noooo waaaay, too difficult, toooo sensible, toooo logical for gallop & co.
 

nqboy

First Grade
Messages
8,914
I've mixed feelings on this, given that the Sydney-centric TV-sycophantic Nein's Rugby League have seen fit to schedule Parra/Dogs on the Saturday night before they even knew who was playing in the other game or where it would be. I feel strongly that the finals should be played under the same rules as regular season games but I also feel that the players' health is the highest priority.

When was the last time premiership fixtures were played in quarters because of the heat?
 

Dr Crane

Live Update Team
Messages
19,531
nqboy said:
I've mixed feelings on this, given that the Sydney-centric TV-sycophantic Nein's Rugby League have seen fit to schedule Parra/Dogs on the Saturday night before they even knew who was playing in the other game or where it would be. I feel strongly that the finals should be played under the same rules as regular season games but I also feel that the players' health is the highest priority.

When was the last time premiership fixtures were played in quarters because of the heat?

They have water breaks during hot games all the time - i saw it in the Super League a month or two ago, and there is normally the same thing done early in the season in Townsville and Brisbane games.
 

beave

Coach
Messages
15,669
mate the NRL are damned for being geniused and not being flexible with the scheduling of this game. Saturday night would have been ideal for both teams.... but like Ink said... Noooooo
 

Nathan B

Juniors
Messages
556
innsaneink said:
Very very simple solution, play this game on the Saturday nite, and the Bulldogs/Eels clash on the Sunday...but noooooo....noooo waaaay, too difficult, toooo sensible, toooo logical for gallop & co.

Not to mention the winner of Parra/Dogs gets an 8-day break before they take on Melbourne, and the winner of Cows/Warriors gets a 6-day break. Swapping them would give both winners a 7-day break between games.

But that wouldn't make sense, either.
 

Shorty

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
15,555
They shouldn't be cranky about this at all,it's really starting to f**k me off the way that they're going about this game.
I mean geez it's a f**king extended break so that the teams don't get dehydrated and I believe it's probably needed.

So what?
How about we focus on actually winning the game by playing well instead of changing all the f**king variables.
 

SpaceMonkey

Immortal
Messages
40,231
nqboy said:
But North Queensland chief executive Peter Parr told The Daily Telegraph last night each half should be a continuous 40 minutes. "We don't get to use heaters over in Auckland after 20 minutes of each half," Parr said.

Idiotic comment. Auckland never really gets much below 10 degrees during matches, and at that temperature when you're running around and exerting yourself, you get warm pretty quickly anyway. Thats the reason Rugby League is traditionally a WINTER sport. It's a completely different situation to running around in 31 degree heat where the exertion of playing is going to push your body temperature higher and dehydration or heatstroke are a very real medical possibility.

If it was requested during a pre-season trial or even early in the season then nobody would bat an eyelid.
 

Jobdog

Live Update Team
Messages
25,696
What an absolute joke. They're professional footballers FFS. Its a semi final, both teams have to play in the same conditions, so why the need for an extended break at halftime and a drinks break after 20 minutes?
 

nqboy

First Grade
Messages
8,914
Jobdog said:
What an absolute joke. They're professional footballers FFS. Its a semi final, both teams have to play in the same conditions, so why the need for an extended break at halftime and a drinks break after 20 minutes?
Oh, let's see. Because of the danger of heatstroke, perhaps?
 

Frederick

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
27,632
Jobdog said:
What an absolute joke. They're professional footballers FFS. Its a semi final, both teams have to play in the same conditions, so why the need for an extended break at halftime and a drinks break after 20 minutes?
You're an idiot Jobber. Deadset idiot :lol:
 

Dr Crane

Live Update Team
Messages
19,531
Jobdog said:
What an absolute joke. They're professional footballers FFS. Its a semi final, both teams have to play in the same conditions, so why the need for an extended break at halftime and a drinks break after 20 minutes?

Funny bugger
 

PARRA_FAN

Coach
Messages
17,659
I am concerned about the players health as well.

because Dairy Farmers doesnt really have much cover, and they'll hardly be a shady spot.

Not just for the fans, the fans obviously dont have a problem with, its the players.

How much water are they provide for this game, for both teams.

And not to mention the game will ordinary, slippery balls, poor defence, players are gonna be stuffed

The NRL has once again stuffed up their pre plan, as mentioned they wouldve moved it to Sat night, and have Bulldogs/Eels on Sunday, which wouldve got 50,000 regardless. Surely that wouldntve been a problem.
 

Spike

First Grade
Messages
7,115
It's probably more the humidity rather than the actually temperature. Makes a moderately warm day feel hotter than a bowl of f*ck
 

Latest posts

Top