Curtis Scott

[Glenn012]

Apparently Melbourne are trying to get rid of him even though he is under contract for another year after this.

I'm wouldn't be in favor of SGI signing him. In the games I have seen him play, I have only ever thought he is massively overrated at best, not NRL standard at worst.

Having said that, the guy won a premiership with Melbourne!!!! There may even be a photo of him holding the trophy aloft with Bellamy in the picture. Sign him on marquee player money! I must be a moron and he a superstar because I think he is a premiership winner with Melbourne.

 

[muzby]

 

[TomRedVRiver]

Nah.

Bellamy said during the week that if his current players can't get the job done, he's going to start finding other players.

Scott would be the first of that exodus, I don't want us to be seen as the first club to pick up a reject seen as "not good enough". It'll set a dangerous precedent.

 

[watatank]

We need wingers

 

[Dragons 09]

Nah.

Bellamy said during the week that if his current players can't get the job done, he's going to start finding other players.

Scott would be the first of that exodus, I don't want us to be seen as the first club to pick up a reject seen as "not good enough". It'll set a dangerous precedent.

Anyone who hangs one off the end of Dylan Walkers chin is OK by me

I think you're right though, he's not one of Bellamy's favourites and if he can't get him to perform at the top level, our coach has no hope. Mind you, i think Croft would be the first of the exodus if Bellamy wields the axe, he offers very little as support to Smith and Munster and is really under achieving if all the early hype about him was to be believed.

 

[Frank Facer]

I would sign Scott and play him centre with Lomax the other centre. He has a great build for centre. i am very surprised that Bellamy is letting him go.

 

[Coffs dragon]

Pointless as Mary McJetski would turn him to shit real quick or throw him on the bench to play 7 minutes in the middle.

 

[redVinme]

Posted this in rumours thread. I'd be for it. Or that Broncs winger that just got dropped issakho* goal kicker would be a good pre June 30 signing. Heaps of upside

 

[AyiosYiorgos]

I'm pretty sure @Awynn_er mentioned that Scott originally left the sharks due to some bad influences in the area, so doubt he would want to come back somewhere close to the shire...

 

[dragon thomo]

I would look at Issako and Oats at Brisbane thats where we are struggling this year the wings

 

[gitano]

I would sign Scott and play him centre with Lomax the other centre. He has a great build for centre. i am very surprised that Bellamy is letting him go.

Games aren't won in front of a mirror.

Big no from me.

 

[avocado]

Nah. Happy with Lomax/Lafai

 

[Glenn012]

I would sign Scott and play him centre with Lomax the other centre. He has a great build for centre. i am very surprised that Bellamy is letting him go.

I was being sarcastic. I have seen it said before something to end that any player who was in a premiership winning team and isn't retiring or getting very close to it, must be a superstar. As dumb as that is, it sadly isn't an uncommon opinion.

From what I have seen, no way would I want SGI to sign him. Who cares about ISP and that is the only place he would get a game unless we were in dire straights. As @Dragons 09 stated, if Bellamy can't get him playing at a high level after a few years, what hope has McGregor got?

 

[st.phil]

Yes from me

 

[Glenn012]

I would look at Issako and Oats at Brisbane thats where we are struggling this year the wings

Oats is great at making a lot of meters but makes so many mistakes. I'd be interested in the other guy to see if he can make it as a fullback. Dufty isn't cutting it. The occasional freakish try isn't enough to compensate for his shortcomings.

 

[dragon thomo]

Issako has got talent and he can also goal kick. You right about Oats making mistakes but atleast he can break the line with size and speed

 

[HenryTatana]

I'm pretty sure @Awynn_er mentioned that Scott originally left the sharks due to some bad influences in the area, so doubt he would want to come back somewhere close to the shire...

Epic Bender Crew.

 

[Walpole]

A centre from Melbourne you say? Maybe we could give him a run at fullback for two games, drop him to reggies for half a season, bring him back to randomly play every position in the backline, then play him off the bench for 8 minutes a game as some sort of undersized middle forward hybrid. Worked out well for the last bloke...

 

[Frank Facer]

I was being sarcastic. I have seen it said before something to end that any player who was in a premiership winning team and isn't retiring or getting very close to it, must be a superstar. As dumb as that is, it sadly isn't an uncommon opinion.

From what I have seen, no way would I want SGI to sign him. Who cares about ISP and that is the only place he would get a game unless we were in dire straights. As @Dragons 09 stated, if Bellamy can't get him playing at a high level after a few years, what hope has McGregor got?

If Tom Turbo isn't fit for origin. Then Leilua and Scott would both come into contention for my team. That is how highly I rate Scott.

 

[2010]

If my memory serves me correctly didn’t we sign a reject from the Storm, Paul Vaughan, he seems to be doing well even with McIdiot coaching.