What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Does Brad Arthur deserve the hype?

hindmarshisgod

Juniors
Messages
638
You can't work offloads into a gameplan.
They are a variable - you never know when the chance to do one will come.

You can never work offloads into a game plan strategically, but you can allow them to play whats in front of them. Brad the dope seems to have them shackled and overcoached.

If they played with some risk like they did when it was all too late, they would have won tonight.
 

Bandwagon

Super Moderator
Staff member
Messages
44,891
Offloads tonight were 15 / 11 in parra's favour.

Its our edge defence that killed us, and our set play in the oppositions 20, same issue as the last coupla seasons
 

yy_cheng

Coach
Messages
18,734
I agree that he has no real gameplan against a specific opposition.

He is trying to repeat and repeat the same formula over and over irrespective of the opposition.

I guess very Melbourne like

We won't win it this way as we don't have brown paper bags nor the players
 

yy_cheng

Coach
Messages
18,734
I agree that he has no real gameplan against a specific opposition.

He is trying to repeat and repeat the same formula over and over irrespective of the opposition.

I guess very Melbourne like

We won't win it this way as we don't have brown paper bags nor the players
 

Chipmunk

Coach
Messages
17,375
Hey pou, any chance of some stats on how a team has gone after winning the spoon?

Only kidding

But I reckon this will show Arthur has done a fair effort with the side this year

Roosters made the GF after winning a spoon only 2-3 years ago if I recall
 
Last edited:

hindmarshisgod

Juniors
Messages
638
Offloads tonight were 15 / 11 in parra's favour.

Its our edge defence that killed us, and our set play in the oppositions 20, same issue as the last coupla seasons

I think you will find our offloads came in the second half when we piled on points on and gave ourselves some hope.
 

Joshuatheeel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
20,176
While our halves need to improve most of our losses have been due to terrible piss weak defence. Tonight the stats show both sides were pretty close, but gee some of those raiders tries were piss week, two were up the middle.
 

hindmarshisgod

Juniors
Messages
638
While our halves need to improve most of our losses have been due to terrible piss weak defence. Tonight the stats show both sides were pretty close, but gee some of those raiders tries were piss week, two were up the middle.

Yep.

Pissweak defence.

Edwards was poor in defence tonight especially.
 

hindmarshisgod

Juniors
Messages
638
Hey TS Quint, since you are so knowledgable, can you please explain super coach's decision to have pritchard on the bench?
 

T.S Quint

Coach
Messages
14,559
So what is your explanation on the minimal offloads this season?

We are weak up the middle which is where most offloads come from, so find it hard to get our arms free to get the ball away.
Players go for the ball straight away in most tackles and hopefully hold on until their mates can come and complete the tackle.
We are especially bad at this which is why we get beaten in the forwards.
 

T.S Quint

Coach
Messages
14,559
Hey TS Quint, since you are so knowledgable, can you please explain super coach's decision to have pritchard on the bench?

I would hazard a guess that he figured DeGois wouldn't be able to last the entire 80 effectively.
I don't pretend to know all the ins and outs of the game but surely that one isn't rocket science.
 

Swiftstylez

Bench
Messages
2,858
If you looked at our this team this year on paper and they played the same as 2013 we would be wooden spoon contenders 2014, not potentially finishing on 30 pts. We haven't made that much of an improvement in our roster this year, if anything it has been a few steps backwards with the injuries we have had. The one thing that Arthur has done is made our underperforming players of last year (I'm not going to name names) perform at the level they are capable of and players that weren't as good or are young and inexperienced over-perform. We always had a team that could compete they just didn't believe in themselves or the game-plan and if you can't appreciate the difference Brad Arthur has made to the joint then you wont appreciate anything. The players are the ones that can hang their heads in shame and some of them will be on their last legs with their inconsistency... and a few of them can pack their bags if they dish that shit up again against the Raiders.

Arthur doesn't make players throw passes that look like they are thrown by someone having an epileptic fit, or beg them to drop balls without a single hand on them. Basic, fundamental errors by a few players like that cost the team the game against the Knights at a time when you could have put them to bed. You can take a player to water but you can't force some of them to drink. The club will not be playing the coach merry-go-round anytime soon my friends.
 

hindmarshisgod

Juniors
Messages
638
We are weak up the middle which is where most offloads come from, so find it hard to get our arms free to get the ball away.
Players go for the ball straight away in most tackles and hopefully hold on until their mates can come and complete the tackle.
We are especially bad at this which is why we get beaten in the forwards.

Your a dope.

You have proved it with this post.
 

hindmarshisgod

Juniors
Messages
638
I would hazard a guess that he figured DeGois wouldn't be able to last the entire 80 effectively.
I don't pretend to know all the ins and outs of the game but surely that one isn't rocket science.

So you are telling me a guy like de gois who has been playing 80 mins for 3 months now, needs to be replaced by a guy who has not played nrl for over 18 months and who has just overcome a major injury, to play in the biggest game for the eels this season.

You are an absolute f**king idiot and dont embarrasse yourself further by replying f**kstick.
 

Latest posts

Top