Doust: & I thought Finch was a sook.

mickdo · Jul 11, 2005

innsaneink said:
Marshs right elbow hit Barrets shoulder, Marshs left hand glanced Barretts chin.
Get it right, tell it the way it really is, not the way you wanna see it.

He didnt try to take his head off, he was putting pressure onthe kicker, quite obvoiusly......take off the red n white glasses.

Im amazed by people that say one thing when its obviously another and there for all to see inblack& white or inthis case, colour.

Thank you for bringing some sanity to this

mickdo · Jul 11, 2005

taxidriver said:
explain to me how the cocked elbow caught by video and stills wasn't there ??

Still having trouble with your anatomy classes are you? Elbow connected to forearm. Forearm raised straight. Elbow moves too (always troubled the Dragons fans that one). Elbow not pointed ahead of straight forearm. Elbow not cocked.

Dog-E · Jul 11, 2005

That kind of thing happens EVERY SINGLE WEEK!!

Shifty Sherwin got absolutely BARRELLED by some of those big, nasty Kiwis a number of times

yesterday for eg!...Many of them, they COULD have pulled out of their challenges - IF tyhey had wanted to!

But that's the just way the game is!...Did Shifty bounce to his feet, burst into tears & run over & start king-hitting Temata or Faumuina???

No. he got to his feet, dusted himself down and just got on with his sh!t...and HIS team ended up winning a tight game!

That's how a MAN handles that kind of situation!

Youre ona hiding to nothing here taxidriver & Doust!

mickdo · Jul 11, 2005

Dog-E said:
That kind of thing happens EVERY SINGLE WEEK!!

Shifty Sherwin got absolutely BARRELLED by some of those big, nasty Kiwis a number of times yesterday for eg!...Many of them, they COULD have pulled out of their challenges - IF tyhey had wanted to!

But that's the just way the game is!...Did Shifty bounce to his feet, burst into tears & run over & start king-hitting Temata or Faumuina???

No. he got to his feet, dusted himself down and just got on with his sh!t...and HIS team ended up winning a tight game!

That's how a MAN handles that kind of situation!

Youre ona hiding to nothing here taxidriver & Doust!

Precisely

miketyson · Jul 11, 2005

Thats garabge , marsh led with his elbow!

Regardless if he hit him in the head or the shoulder!

HE LED WITH HIS ELBOW! Which you should never do!

mickdo · Jul 11, 2005

miketyson said:
Thats garabge , marsh led with his elbow!

Regardless if he hit him in the head or the shoulder!

HE LED WITH HIS ELBOW! Which you should never do!

:lol: :lol: :lol:
O O O O O O OPSM

booeycollector · Jul 11, 2005

Tommy Smith said:
Doust is spot on.

Who does PJ think he is coming out in the media and whinging like a little bitch, "hey he hit me, waahhhhh, wahhhahaaaaaa".

Get over it you sook and let the judiciary take care of it.

What happens on the field, stays on the field you cry baby.

Yep 40 v 14............cry baby!!!!!!

miketyson · Jul 11, 2005

mickdo said:
:lol: :lol: :lol:
O O O O O O OPSM

http://foxsports.news.com.au/common/imagedata/0,5001,5025711,00.jpg

And you think thats not leading with the elbow?

mickdo · Jul 11, 2005

miketyson said:
http://foxsports.news.com.au/common/imagedata/0,5001,5025711,00.jpg

And you think thats not leading with the elbow?

That is after contact has been made and he is already past him. It proves nothing. This shot below on the other hand before contact shows him bracing for impact with his forearms locked and his elbows pointing down. And just notice in the image how far his front forearm is below Barretts head. A big distance.

ParraDude_Jay · Jul 11, 2005

Dog-E said:
That kind of thing happens EVERY SINGLE WEEK!!

Shifty Sherwin got absolutely BARRELLED by some of those big, nasty Kiwis a number of times yesterday for eg!...Many of them, they COULD have pulled out of their challenges - IF tyhey had wanted to!

But that's the just way the game is!...Did Shifty bounce to his feet, burst into tears & run over & start king-hitting Temata or Faumuina???

No. he got to his feet, dusted himself down and just got on with his sh!t...and HIS team ended up winning a tight game!

That's how a MAN handles that kind of situation!

Youre ona hiding to nothing here taxidriver & Doust!

Best post made on this topic so far

JJ · Jul 11, 2005

I think Marsh was careless - maybe 1 week, I found it hard to come to any firm conclusion on the footage. Although mickdo' photo shows Marsh was clearly charging the ball down, and not attacking Barrett's head

Barrett cannot attack a player from behind - if he'd been as skillful as Danny Williams and knocked Marsh senseless (which was clearly his intention i.e., he attacked his head, from behind) then wouldn't we be demanding a lengthy suspension. Aside from anything else, it was another instance of Barrett showing he's a very dumb player

Many people have raved about Cayless et al charging in, but what were they supposed to do, let a team-mate be viciously attacked from behind?

ParraDude_Jay · Jul 11, 2005

mickdo said:
That is after contact has been made and he is already past him. It proves nothing. This shot below on the other hand before contact shows him bracing for impact with his forearms locked and his elbows pointing down. And just notice in the image how far his front forearm is below Barretts head. A big distance.

Can't argue with photographic proof Dragons, blind freddy can see initial contact will be made on Barrett's arm and deflect into his shoulder (Marsh didn't elbow Barrett in the chin!)

miketyson · Jul 11, 2005

That is after contact has been made and he is already past him. It proves nothing. This shot below on the other hand before contact shows him bracing for impact with his forearms locked and his elbows pointing down. And just notice in the image how far his front forearm is below Barretts head. A big distance.

How is that the contact showing after he has 'passed him' when his elbow is jammed into the bottom of his jaw?

miketyson · Jul 11, 2005

Dog-E said:
That kind of thing happens EVERY SINGLE WEEK!!

Shifty Sherwin got absolutely BARRELLED by some of those big, nasty Kiwis a number of times yesterday for eg!...Many of them, they COULD have pulled out of their challenges - IF tyhey had wanted to!

But that's the just way the game is!...Did Shifty bounce to his feet, burst into tears & run over & start king-hitting Temata or Faumuina???

No. he got to his feet, dusted himself down and just got on with his sh!t...and HIS team ended up winning a tight game!

That's how a MAN handles that kind of situation!

Youre ona hiding to nothing here taxidriver & Doust!

Is this the same sherwin that takes a dive anytime adrian morley gets within 3 feet of him..

mickdo · Jul 11, 2005

miketyson said:
How is that the contact showing after he has 'passed him' when his elbow is jammed into the bottom of his jaw?

Are you legally blind, or just ignorant? The photo you showed has his elbow well past his chin. Here... have another look...

I'll give you a hint. That's Marsh's elbow below Barrett's right ear, past his chin.

smeghead · Jul 11, 2005

In the end still photos prove nothing either way. Slow motion replays can also be a hinderance. Watch the incident at full speed and I thought it was a deflection. Barrett is an idiot. Maybe he and Mick Crocker can go to anger management during their respective suspensions

Kiwi · Jul 11, 2005

Tommy Smith said:
Doust is spot on.

Who does PJ think he is coming out in the media and whinging like a little bitch, "hey he hit me, waahhhhh, wahhhahaaaaaa".

Get over it you sook and let the judiciary take care of it.

What happens on the field, stays on the field you cry baby.

Can you tell that to the king of the whinge, Mr Ryan I should be picked for origin waaaahhh waaaaaaaaa I'm not a gouger waaaaaaaahhhh waaaaaaaaa Cross?

Kiwi · Jul 11, 2005

Tommy Smith said:
But it wasnt on the street, it was on a football field and Marsh provoked it by raising his elbow.

Foul play occurs against players EVERY week, do you see them publically asking the judiciary to do something about it because "he hit me"? I dont even think Mark O'Neill did that...he just let the judiciary take care of it just as Marsh should.

Do you see other players laying into the back of the head of another player because of it?

mickdo · Jul 11, 2005

Tommy Smith said:
Foul play occurs against players EVERY week, do you see them publically asking the judiciary to do something about it because "he hit me"? I dont even think Mark O'Neill did that...he just let the judiciary take care of it just as Marsh should.

I don't think O'Neill said anything for the next couple of months because his jaw was wired up, and he probably didn't remember anything

Dog-E · Jul 11, 2005

miketyson said:
Is this the same sherwin that takes a dive anytime adrian morley gets within 3 feet of him..

Nope - i can only assume that must be a different one mate!

When has Adrian Morley ever been fast enough to GET within 3 feet of Brent Sherwin (the one of the team formerly known as the Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs I am talking about here!) - just for a START!? :lol:

Would you care to name any particular incidences of this? Because I sure as hell can't recall any!!!

Doust: & I thought Finch was a sook.

Coach

Coach

Juniors

Coach

Juniors

Coach

Juniors

Juniors

Coach

First Grade

Immortal

First Grade

Juniors

Juniors

Coach

Bench

First Grade

First Grade

Coach

Juniors