What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Dragons after Finch?

Cagey Mac

Bench
Messages
4,005
Look, in all honesty I can't see us signing Finch. The thing that worries me with Finch leaving though, is it leaves Parra with more room under the cap to come sniffing around for Poore and Creagh. We should wipe the memory and the notion of Finch wearing the Red V, and concentrate on getting our boys off contract locked up.

But they'll have to buy a good half and that ain't easy
 

rushndude

Bench
Messages
2,578
Initially i'd say no, however I am happy to trust benny's judgement. one important thing to remember benny won a GF with Perry at 1/2.
You could have a turkey run out in the #7 jumper and still win a premiership when Lockyer is your five-eighth.
We dont have that luxury at the Dragons..

I agree though that if Bennett wants him..im willing to see what he can make of him.
 

Tanner Ave

Juniors
Messages
539
If he comes then at some point of the season he would be used at dummy half considering the lack of a dominate one for us at the moment, so what would his reaction be?
I for one am happy with the set up at the moment, not the absolute greatest situation but it has gotten the job done so far.
I agree that we should be doing all we can to have some stability by resigning the boys coming off contract and trust the development of the juniors.
 
Messages
12,516
Growing up watching Robert Finch in the Red V, I thought it was a mere formality that his son would play for us.
Wayne Bennett knows a lot more than me so I'm happy to go with what he decides.

Hmmmm..........If you follow that logic through, we should get Joel Reddy on board as well. No thanks. Nup.
 

watatank

Coach
Messages
14,348
I must say, I am surprised that so many people seem to be against this decision...most people think we are supposed to be in the market for a halfback...whatever emotions may be felt toward Finch he is a genuine halfback, a very good player, has plenty of experience and has the game to complement Soward very well. It also helps that he's one of the better defensive halfbacks in the competition. He's down on form this season but he is a very good player IMO and would fit well here.

Bennett will have to make a extremely tough decision here and tbh I don't envy it. It's a dilemma either way you look at it...

*How important is securing Finch, or any other halfback for that matter?
*And where does this leave Hornby after naming him club captain?

Going to fullback would have been the natural proposition for mine but Boyd going so well at fullback Beau Scott going so well in the centres (although he can play back row), even Morris' form on the wing has complicated matters...as has the possibly of Sailor staying on...

Hooker is probably the best option for him to ensure team balance and it means that we wouldn't need to go into the market for a hooker...but then he's not a long term option for hooker either...and you have two stop gap options here (although admittedly Young will play more at lock)

We could always bench him (and relieve him of the captaincy) or release him (do the delight of some people here, I am sure) but I doubt those scenarios will occur given that he's been named captain.
 
Last edited:

Ron Jeremy

Coach
Messages
25,700
careful what you wish for guys.....

he's useless, i dont want you guys to see what us Parra, Raiders and Roosters fans have had too.
 

MattYg1

Bench
Messages
3,525
I think if Brownie was head coach Finch would of been signed next day and playing parra tonight...

we can all agree that we thank god/buddah/allah that the Brown era is over
 

Willow

Assistant Moderator
Messages
111,221
careful what you wish for guys.....

he's useless, i dont want you guys to see what us Parra, Raiders and Roosters fans have had too.
Parramatta have more problems than just Brett Finch.

Interesting game tonight. Players bailing out or threatening to do so. They either galvanise or crumble. I suspect we'll have a fair idea after the first 20 minutes.
 

Ron Jeremy

Coach
Messages
25,700
Parramatta have more problems than just Brett Finch.

Interesting game tonight. Players bailing out or threatening to do so. They either galvanise or crumble. I suspect we'll have a fair idea after the first 20 minutes.

Willow, we didn't expect our halves to fire tonight after the sh*t that has gone on, but it was pretty obvious that when KK was at half we had more sting in our attack then the 1 and a half years finch was our halfback.

We also scored a try whilst attacking tonight, one more then against the roosters, signs of improvement already haha
 
Top