I didn't think it was too bad really, obviously some improvements should be made but all in all it was an ok show.
1: Brian Carney was great... he seemed a bit nervous at times, but if that went he'd be awesome on the show. They should look to using him full time instead of Chief, if they can somehow manage it.
2: Benji Marshall... every now and then he comes out with something funny, but otherwise he just stutters through everything and eventually spits out some cliche, twice. I don't get why everyone thinks he has TV potential, I don't think I've ever seen him say a complete sentence properly.
3: The 5 questions thing reminded me a bit of those good American sports shows like PTI and Around The Horn... they should do ALOT more of that, only ban Chief from participating. How can someone talk so much but really have nothing to say?
4: Teach Fatty to read an autocue, jesus.
5: Get rid of Mario's bits, reserve Reg's spot for awards shows and things like that. No one cares what some fat woman on the street thinks.
So yeah wasn't a bad show, I just wish they'd get a bit more serious about the league stuff... and that doesn't mean extended explanations of why they think Andrew Johns is the greatest player of all time.