Future Stars

[Detox]

What are your top five future stars? There's quite a few young players running around who have been playing quite well.

Here's mine..

Karmichael Hunt
Sonny Bill Willams
Danny McGuire
Ben Creagh
Gary Tupou

 

[ByRd]

ill only do the NRL because of i havnt seen much of Mcguire but he has to test himself sometime in the NRL to really prove himself. My top 5 would be:

1) Sonny Bill
2) Karmichael Hunt
3) Reni Maitua
4) Gary Tupou
5) Joe Williams/Brett Stewart

 

[Iafeta]

1) SBW
2) Matt Head
3) Ashton Sims
4) Brett Stewart
5) Jerome Ropati

 

[Corbin]

1) Sonny Bill Williams
2) Benji Marshall
3) Karmichael Hunt
4) Iosia Soliola
5) Marcus Perenara
6) Gary Tupou
7) Jerome Roparti
8) Peewee Moke
9) David Faiumu
10) Bronson Harrison
11) Joe Williams

 

[Detox]

1) Sonny Bill Williams
2) Benji Marshall
3) Karmichael Hunt
4) Iosia Soliola
5) Marcus Perenara
6) Gary Tupou
7) Jerome Roparti
8) Peewee Moke
9) David Faiumu
10) Bronson Harrison
11) Joe Williams

Nice five! :lol: :roll:

 

[Stagger eel]

1 SBW!!

sorry, there must be a gap between 1 and 2.

2 KMH
3 Matt Head
4 Anthony Topou
5 Ashton Simms

 

[Stagger eel]

players that will break through this year!!

1 Iosa Soliola
2 Todd Carney
3 Trent Cutler
4 Marcus Peranara
5 Josh Davis

 

[God-King Dean]

Firman would be in the top 5

 

[SaintTPP]

Firman would be in the top 5

We'll haveto wait and see about that, I don't think he will live upto expectations.

My top5:
1.SBW
2.Head
3.KMH
4.Sims
5.Tupou.

Although I also think that Creagh has something going for him and so too Joe Williams.

 

[Stagger eel]

Firman would be in the top 5

We'll haveto wait and see about that, I don't think he will live upto expectations.

My top5:
1.SBW
2.Head
3.KMH
4.Sims
5.Tupou.

Although I also think that Creagh has something going for him and so too Joe Williams.

quick question!

how do you rate Poore?

 

[ByRd]

Sonny Bill Williams is a distant first i agree but i just wanna know if the people on here rate Reni Maitua. In his debut season in 2004 he played 24 first grade & steped up whenever the dogs needed him to. He can play 5/8 when needed (roosters game when we won 40-12) & but is best used in the backrow (strated grand final in backrow). The try that he also scored in the prelim final was a match winning moment. He is a future rep player & im not complaining about him not being in peoples lists cause everyone has their opinions, im just wondering if you people rate RENI MAITUA. I personally think that he is a great young player & one to look out for in the future.

Whats your opinion of him???

 

[Stagger eel]

Matua would be playing firstgrade at five-eight for my club if we had him. I have no doubt about that.

 

[tiger_nick]

Most of the players above mentioned are already stars

1) Rangi Chase
2) Dean Caldwell
3) Shannon MacDowell
4) David Pangai
5) Sam Moa

 

[God-King Dean]

how do you rate Poore?

I rate him well. He has an excellent work rate & consistent but I wouldn't put him in the top 5 future star players. I imagine he would be like Skandalis, very solid & hard working

 

[Big Mick]

I'll mention players that havn't played first grade:

1) Junior Moors
2) Pee Wee Moke
3) Todd Carney
4) Peter Wallace
5) Cameron Phelps

 

[Magpie Nick]

Carney has played First Grade.

 

[Raider_69]

ill do 3 lists. One for canberra, one for players not played first grade and one for those who have played by debut last year

Debut last year:
1. Sonny Bill Williams
2. Karmicheal Hunt
3. Anthony Tupou
4. Aston Simms
5. Brent Stewart

No debut:
1. Peewee Moke
2. Jamie Soward
3. Trent Cutler
4. Peter Wallace
5. Iosa Soliola

Canberra:
1. Todd Carney
2. Micheal Weyman
3. Marshall Chalk
4. William Zillman
5. Jermaine Ale

 

[God-King Dean]

I'll mention players that havn't played first grade:

1) Junior Moors
2) Pee Wee Moke
3) Todd Carney
4) Peter Wallace
5) Cameron Phelps

I'd have Naiqama on that list. The problem for him is getting a regular first-grade spot, with Gasnier & Cooper in front of him. You will almost definatly see him in FG this year, providing he isn't injured at the same time as Gaz #-o

 

[Booyah]

I'll ignore the obvious ones and throw up a few new ones in no particular order.

1. Iosia Soliola - Roosters
2. Pee Wee Moke - Roosters
3. Troy Boston - Souths
4. Beau Champion - Souths
5. William Zillman - Raiders

All will have an impact if they play firsts this year, especially Soliola.

 

[Raider_69]

I'll mention players that havn't played first grade:

1) Junior Moors
2) Pee Wee Moke
3) Todd Carney
4) Peter Wallace
5) Cameron Phelps

I'd have Naiqama on that list. The problem for him is getting a regular first-grade spot, with Gasnier & Cooper in front of him. You will almost definatly see him in FG this year, providing he isn't injured at the same time as Gaz #-o

ive herd alot bout this bloke but never seen him so i cant comment