General Discussion Thread

[Fangs]

The Dogs have had a very soft first 6 weeks. St George Titans Eels Sharks Knights Rabbits.

Yes I agree with you. It's a knock on them. But they've banked 6 wins. Low Origin representation.

I want a Penrith v Canterbury grand final. I'm predicting it in fact.

 

[Oldpanther86]

It's been coming. No Walsh either which may have helped. Too many chefs in the kitchen?

They are absolutely a contender. Dogs are too if they keep staying in games. Tonight is an exception.

He's got the most errors in the league. Can be great when he's on but is a total momentum killer.

 

[Fangs]

He's got the most errors in the league. Can be great when he's on but is a total momentum killer.

Isn't playing with a lot of confidence right now.

Missing Origin might be good for him. Slater should pick Ponga.

 

[Pjf04b]

Can somebody PLEASE explain to me what the line drop-out rule is now. Surely a kick that doesn't go 10m or goes out on the full is incontestable and should be a penalty. Some games out on the full is a penalty, sometimes not!
It is a rule change that should be thrown out and go back to what it was originally.

 

[Fangs]

Can somebody PLEASE explain to me what the line drop-out rule is now. Surely a kick that doesn't go 10m or goes out on the full is incontestable and should be a penalty. Some games out on the full is a penalty, sometimes not!
It is a rule change that should be thrown out and go back to what it was originally.

Totally agree.

It is a remarkably stupid rule. Brings us closer to RU and not in a good way either. Terrible rule change.

 

[age.s]

They don't care. They're building ammunition for a court case that may or may not eventuate this century.