What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Good SMH article on Mason

iggy plop

First Grade
Messages
5,293
http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2004/05/26/1085461830620.html

Mason a scapegoat for league's troubles By Miranda Devine
May 27, 2004


The whole sordid business of rugby league's sex and booze scandals has come to be embodied by one man: Willie Mason, the 195cm tall, 115kg frizzy-haired forward for the Canterbury Bulldogs team. Despite the talent displayed in last night's State of Origin match, the group-think decision of the rugby league world is that bad boy Bubba is to blame for all that ails the game.

The former Penrith star Mark Geyer gave voice last weekend to the growing anti-Willie lynch mob: "The public are getting sick of a boofhead like him dominating front and back pages for the wrong reasons," he told Channel Nine's The Footy Show.

"Let's get rid of Willie Mason, tomorrow or today, get him out of the team and everything will be kosher. I guarantee it."

:lol: Ray Hadley :lol: , 2GB's influential announcer, also launched into Mason, accusing the 24-year-old of swearing within earshot of children at an autograph-signing last week in Harvey Norman's Liverpool store.

The baying for Mason's blood reached such a pitch the Bulldogs management took the extraordinary decision to disclose private medical advice that he suffers from attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. But if the intention was to elicit sympathy for Mason, it backfired. Howls of derision filled letters pages and talkback radio.

Soon every real or imaginary grievance of any league fan was being pinned on Mason and given a wide airing. The criticisms became farcical when league officials had to confiscate and examine the tablecloth from the Harvey Norman autograph table after complaints Mason had doodled on it.

The doodles, said his accusers, were obscene caricatures of men, women and dogs with "oversized genitalia". Even the Harvey Norman boss, Gerry Harvey, got involved in the tablecloth examination, calling in three female staff to ask if they found Willie's doodles offensive. They didn't.

After further examination, a press conference was called to present the tablecloth to the salivating media. And lo and behold, Mason's doodles turned out to be innocent, child-like pictures of a flower in a pot, a little fat man, funny faces, noughts and crosses and stick figures, the kind of doodles you might find on any journalist's pad. The great tablecloth incident was a fizzer.

But it reinforced the impression in the public mind that Mason was a sicko, and a bad influence in the game. This is how a witch-hunt starts. Once the mob has found its target, there is no turning back.

The man once loved by the public for his openness and larrikin nature, unmistakeable because of his huge frame and trademark Afro, had become the whipping boy of league.

Yet the real Mason is quite different from the media caricature. To his mother, Sonya, he is the dutiful third-born child who puts money into her bank account every week to help support his seven brothers and sisters, who range in age from seven to 26. He is the 17-year-old who sat "crying non-stop" in the hospital room where his father died of pancreatic cancer seven years ago.

He is the nine-year-old junior league star who told his proud parents one day he would buy them a house. He is the son who drives his mother to mass, never forgets Mother's Day or her wedding anniversary, and arrives at Christmas and birthdays laden with presents. "I believe a lot of people don't know William or what he's done," said Sonya Mason yesterday before getting on a train near Newcastle to come to Sydney and see the State of Origin.

Part Tongan, Samoan and African-American, Sonya met Willie's Australian father, Ian, in New Zealand where he was soon working two jobs to support his growing family. "It was a struggle bringing up eight kids and Willie remembers that," said Sonya, sitting in the five-bedroom house her son bought her last year.

Sonya has been in tears, worrying about her Bubba. "I know he's not happy," she said yesterday. "I wanted to tell him to just walk out but he told me if he did the public would think he did something wrong."

Of course, a loving mother will always see the best in her son. But on the plain facts it is clear Willie Mason has been unfairly targeted. He was not involved in the most damaging story for rugby league this year: the allegation by a Coffs Harbour woman that she was gang raped by a number of Bulldogs players. The accused players were never named, leaving the whole team under a cloud, especially the high-profile Mason.

Finally the club coach, Steve Folkes, was forced to tell journalists this week: "[Willie] is still being mentioned for being involved in what happened in Coffs Harbour and he was not one of the fined players and he certainly had nothing to do with anything up there but he's still getting labelled with that." Mason's only sin was to dress too casually when he turned up for a police interview with his team-mates. He was fined $10,000 for wearing a T-shirt.

Mason did not make the obscene mobile phone call that convulsed the Origin team last week. He wasn't even in the same cab as the player who did. Mason is no angel. He drinks too much at times and, like a lot of footballers, when he goes out on the town with his team-mates he can behave badly, even uncharacteristically.

In psychology, this phenomenon of behaving differently when in a group is known as de-individuation. The anonymity and loss of a sense of self in a group "reduces an individual's self-restraint and normative regulation of behaviour", says an online paper by Dr Tom Postmes, associate editor of the British Journal of Social Psychology.

But the behaviour of footballers in a group is no more reprehensible than the blood lust of the lynch mob out to get Mason. Footballers are named and shamed, fined and sacked. But the lynch mob rides on unpunished, looking for its next victim.


Well said Miranda. Five days ago I was all for getting rid of Willie, but I now see the media vendetta for what it is. He's not a crim like some people would have you think.
 

wittyfan

Referee
Messages
29,892
A fairly poor article from Miranda, who is usually pretty much on the ball. While she makes some good points in her defence of Mason, she doesn't go into much detail about the list of incidents he's been involved in recent years, which has created this "lynch mob".
 

Dogaholic

First Grade
Messages
5,075
sullyfan said:
A fairly poor article from Miranda, who is usually pretty much on the ball. While she makes some good points in her defence of Mason, she doesn't go into much detail about the list of incidents he's been involved in recent years, which has created this "lynch mob".

Dead set, you are the biggest moron ever to grace a forum. You read what you want to read, and believe what you want to believe. You hate all things Bulldog and are willing to believe the worst of everything in a hope that it is true. Why?

:roll:

Well done Miranda :clap: :clap: :clap:
 

wittyfan

Referee
Messages
29,892
Its a Dogs World said:
sullyfan said:
A fairly poor article from Miranda, who is usually pretty much on the ball. While she makes some good points in her defence of Mason, she doesn't go into much detail about the list of incidents he's been involved in recent years, which has created this "lynch mob".

Dead set, you are the biggest moron ever to grace a forum. You read what you want to read, and believe what you want to believe. You hate all things Bulldog and are willing to believe the worst of everything in a hope that it is true. Why?

:roll:

Well done Miranda :clap: :clap: :clap:

This is from the same Miranda Devine that wrote this excellent article on March 11:

Bulldogs players need to learn the difference between right and wrong, says Miranda Devine.

As if the Canterbury Bulldogs rugby league club wasn't already in a pickle, now it has been saddled with a "gender studies expert".

Even before meeting the National Rugby League's chief executive, David Gallop, to take up her new "adviser" role last week, Catharine Lumby, a Sydney University associate professor, warned against "moral panic", said consensual group sex was not aberrant and that players needed education in "gender politics".

But knowing it is wrong to gang rape a woman is not some obscure concoction of the postmodern academic discipline of gender politics and it can't be separated from the apparent culture of "gang banging" and misogyny which suffuses rugby league and other male team sports.

When Sydney's gang rapes of 2000 came before the courts, legitimate questions were raised about what it was about the culture in which the young Lebanese Muslim perpetrators were brought up that made them have such contempt for the "Australian" women they targeted.

If any of the current allegations are proved you would have to ask similar questions about some members of the Canterbury rugby league team, only this time no one can blame any Lebanese subculture. In fact, the most prominent Lebanese player in the sport, the Muslim role model Hazem El Masri, is the only Bulldog to have been publicly exonerated by club officials and police over allegations that six players sexually assaulted a 20-year-old woman in Coffs Harbour last month. He has refused a DNA test as an insult to his dignity and police have declined to push the issue.

El Masri's lawyer, Adam Houda, described him last week as "non-smoking, non-drinking; when he was single he didn't fornicate". What a pity some of the others in the team didn't follow El Masri's example.

Instead, according to a well-sourced article by Danny Weidler in The Sun-Herald, for some players, wild parties and group sex are a way of life. "Some of the boys love a 'bun'," one Bulldogs player told Weidler. "Gang banging is nothing new for our club or the rugby league." Some players also told Weidler that sex with the 20-year-old Coffs Harbour complainant last month had been consensual.

One of the ironies is that Canterbury used to be known as the family club, the Catholic fiefdom of the late Peter "Bullfrog" Moore. The folklore was that country families would allow their talented teenage sons to go to the Big Smoke to play because they trusted Bullfrog to look after them and billet them with nice local families.

But the "protective armour" provided by Bullfrog, to ensure any scandals never saw the light of day, died with him, leaving Canterbury peculiarly vulnerable to scandal.

Today, when the Bulldogs appear on TV so do the words "anal, oral and vaginal rape". How many families with children who are Bulldogs fans have struggled to shield them from the allegations being aired about the club? What sponsor is going to want to be associated with that?

This week police have described the statements provided by 23 Bulldogs players as "scant". But whether or not the sexual assault allegations survive the tortuous journey into a courtroom, it is clear there are at least some Bulldogs players, by their own admission, who are guilty of "gross moral turpitude", a useful legal term which has fallen into general disuse. It is defined as: "Conduct which is so far contrary to the moral law, as interpreted by the general moral sense of the community, that the offender is brought to public disgrace, is no longer generally respected, or is deprived of social recognition by good living persons."

It's not just the Bulldogs, either. There are also sexual assault allegations against two members of the Melbourne Storm. And it's not just rugby league. English soccer is again tainted by rape claims after three Leicester City players were alleged to have attacked three women in a Spanish hotel room last week.

And in the US, the University of Colorado football team is embroiled in a scandal in which seven women allege they were raped by players over the past four years. Politicians there have denounced a culture in which alcohol and sex are used as recruiting tools and sexual assaults are condoned and covered up by university officials.

What we have heard in recent weeks about rugby league and, for all we know, other sports, is its general atmosphere of disrespect for women, who are called "buns" and passed around between players like pieces of meat to be "roasted". In such an atmosphere gang rape is arguably just a small step away.

From the reporting of the Bulldogs story, you would think group sex was commonplace. Those people in the community not engaging in wild mass romps in hotel spas might have thought they were prudes.

But in the largest study of its kind, La Trobe University surveyed 20,000 people for its 2002 Australian Study of Health and Relationships and found the reality to be more prosaic. Just 2.3 per cent of men and 0.6 per cent of women reported having had group sex. Reportedly most men who engage in group sex are gay, which brings to mind the homoerotic overtones of such memorable rugby league events as the wandering finger of Manly winger John Hopoate. The cross-dressing on Channel Nine's The Footy Show is, of course, just panto.

Some Bulldogs, by their own admission, can't enjoy sex with a woman privately, but need their friends to join in. This is aberrant behaviour, despite any attempts by league's gender adviser to say otherwise, and someone ought to tell the players. The Bulldogs don't need lessons in gender politics. They should be told that sportsmen are accorded special privileges and esteem by the community that goes beyond simple prowess on the field. In return they are supposed to hold to higher, not lower, standards of behaviour than the rest of us.

Team sport is important to Australian life and to the upbringing of children. But it is not indispensable.

Source: http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2004/03/10/1078594433425.html?from=storyrhs
 
Messages
835
I for one hope that Canterbury and the NRL persist with Willie...he can be a good player to watch when in form (as he has been the last few weeks since being axed from Australian side) and is marketable.

If he can get some guidance and help in one way or another, he could be have an excellent career instead of a short, controversial one
 

Dogaholic

First Grade
Messages
5,075
Quite a contrasting article.

Which one is the most recent? When she wrote each article, in which instance did she have more information at hand? a clearer picture and understanding of events? In which article would she have given a better judgement keeping this in mind?

You also futhered my point of you bias against the Bulldogs. Your quick to jump on any article against them with praise, calling it an excellent article and so on. No wonder the "witch hunting" media continue to hound when they have loyal supporters. I am sure people like Jeff wells would be pleased to know that he has you as a supporter.
 

wittyfan

Referee
Messages
29,892
Its a Dogs World said:
Quite a contrasting article.

Which one is the most recent? When she wrote each article, in which instance did she have more information at hand? a clearer picture and understanding of events? In which article would she have given a better judgement keeping this in mind?

You also futhered my point of you bias against the Bulldogs. Your quick to jump on any article against them with praise, calling it an excellent article and so on. No wonder the "witch hunting" media continue to hound when they have loyal supporters. I am sure people like Jeff wells would be pleased to know that he has you as a supporter.

I'm just expressing an opinion on her article today. I like reading her articles but today I think she left some important stuff out.
 

Shifty

Juniors
Messages
842
My friend of Misery - Metallica

You just stood there screaming
fearing no one was listening to you
they say the empty can rattles the most
the sound of your voice must soothe you
hearing only what you want to hear
and knowing only what you've heard
you you're smothered in tragedy
you're out to save the world

misery
you insist that the weight of the world
should be on your shoulders
misery
there's much more to life than what you see
my friend of misery

you still stood there screaming
no one caring about these words you tell
my friend before your voice is gone
one man's fun is another's hell
these times are sent to try men's souls
but something's wrong with all you see
you you'll take it on all yourself
remember, misery loves company

misery
you insist that the weight of the world
should be on your shoulders
misery
there's much more to life than what you see
my friend of misery
you just stood there creaming
my friend of misery
 

wittyfan

Referee
Messages
29,892
Shifty said:
Yeah, you love anything involving a media beat-up. ;-)

Sometimes it's not always a media beat-up. ;-) Though the media was somehow way off with the doodles on the table cloth. :?
 
Top