Newcastlerabbit
Coach
- Messages
- 14,937
PETER BADEL THE COURIER-MAIL OCTOBER 10, 2013 12:00AM 22
Ex coach Graham Lowe says Stephen Kearney should have chased Sonny-Bill Williams properly before naming World Cup squad
SOUTHS legend John Sattler has launched a stinging attack on "half-a-game" Sonny Bill Williams, saying his likely departure from the NRL will not be the crushing blow many envisage.
Williams' murky future took another bizarre twist on Tuesday night when he made himself available for New Zealand's World Cup campaign - just hours after ruling himself out of the event.
The shock backflip prompted Test selector Richie Barnett to accuse the Roosters superstar of "disrespecting" the Kiwis as he weighs up a likely return to New Zealand rugby after the World Cup.
While Williams' signing with the NZRU appears a fait accompli, Roosters chairman Nick Politis is refusing to give up hope of keeping the dual international at Bondi.
But Sattler is not convinced Williams' weekly contributions match the hype. Souths' last premiership-winning captain in 1971, Sattler attended last Sunday night's grand final and walked away lukewarm about the Kiwi Test star's game of two halves.
The Roosters have formally approached the NRL seeking salary cap assistance to retain Williams, but Sattler says the code owes the 108kg forward no favours.
Roosters presentation night - Jack Gibson Medal
Sonny Bill Williams has won the Jack Gibson Medal as best and fairest of new NRL premier the Sydney Roosters. Picture: Toby Zerna
"I don't think we'd miss him, the game goes on," said Sattler, a former Test captain.
"Once they start this, 'will I or won't I go' ... well just leave Sonny Bill.
"If your heart isn't in rugby league, go and play another code.
"The game shouldn't do any more than it has already to keep him."
While he made uncharacteristic mistakes in the opening half of the grand final, Williams produced a superb second stanza, finishing with 23 tackles and 141 metres from 14 runs.
Tohu Harris has been punted from NZ's rugby league World Cup squad to make way for Sonny Bill Williams.
This season, the 28-year-old has averaged 12 hit-ups, 24 tackles and 108 metres per game, figures Sattler believes do not denote greatness.
"He can't be considered a great of the game, imagine putting him in the same league as Bob McCarthy, Ron Coote or Reg Gasnier," Sattler said.
"He doesn't get involved enough, he hangs around and every so often he will make a great run, but he has no work-rate.
"His first half the other night was woeful, in grand finals your first half is crucial so he really played half-a-game.
"Sonny Bill wouldn't hold a candle to Coote or McCarthy. There's no doubt he has plenty of ability but in my opinion he just doesn't do enough work."
Despite Barnett's blast, the NZRL eventually added Williams to their Cup squad, just prior to the forward explaining his backflip on social media.
"Without thinking the whole situation through, I eagerly jumped at the chance to chill out and rest," he said.
"After having some time to really think about how much representing my country means to me, I decided to put my name forward for selection."
Maroons coach Mal Meninga believes NRL hierarchy can do no more to prevent Williams returning to play for the Chiefs and All Blacks in 2014.
"I think the NRL have done enough," Meninga said.
Sonny Bill Williams has issued an apology for his World Cup selection backflip, insisting his decision to take a holiday was not thoroughly considered.
"Sonny Bill understands how much the game wants him to stay. It's a personal decision. The game has told Sonny Bill how much they want him to stay and they will do everything they possibly can, but at the end of the day it will be his decision."
Broncos rival Justin Hodges urged Williams not to walk away from rugby league.
"I think he has been fantastic for the game," he said.
"When you lose players like Karmichael (Hunt) and 'Izzy' (Folau) to other codes, it makes their codes bigger.
"We need our big names to stay, a guy like Sonny Bill draws fans and entertains.
"Having him this year made the game a bit more hyped and I think he's a fantastic athlete. The Roosters have the money to keep him, it's just a matter of whether he wants to stay on. I hope he does."
http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sp...end-john-sattler/story-fni3gn3s-1226735605332
Ex coach Graham Lowe says Stephen Kearney should have chased Sonny-Bill Williams properly before naming World Cup squad
SOUTHS legend John Sattler has launched a stinging attack on "half-a-game" Sonny Bill Williams, saying his likely departure from the NRL will not be the crushing blow many envisage.
Williams' murky future took another bizarre twist on Tuesday night when he made himself available for New Zealand's World Cup campaign - just hours after ruling himself out of the event.
The shock backflip prompted Test selector Richie Barnett to accuse the Roosters superstar of "disrespecting" the Kiwis as he weighs up a likely return to New Zealand rugby after the World Cup.
While Williams' signing with the NZRU appears a fait accompli, Roosters chairman Nick Politis is refusing to give up hope of keeping the dual international at Bondi.
But Sattler is not convinced Williams' weekly contributions match the hype. Souths' last premiership-winning captain in 1971, Sattler attended last Sunday night's grand final and walked away lukewarm about the Kiwi Test star's game of two halves.
The Roosters have formally approached the NRL seeking salary cap assistance to retain Williams, but Sattler says the code owes the 108kg forward no favours.
Roosters presentation night - Jack Gibson Medal
Sonny Bill Williams has won the Jack Gibson Medal as best and fairest of new NRL premier the Sydney Roosters. Picture: Toby Zerna
"I don't think we'd miss him, the game goes on," said Sattler, a former Test captain.
"Once they start this, 'will I or won't I go' ... well just leave Sonny Bill.
"If your heart isn't in rugby league, go and play another code.
"The game shouldn't do any more than it has already to keep him."
While he made uncharacteristic mistakes in the opening half of the grand final, Williams produced a superb second stanza, finishing with 23 tackles and 141 metres from 14 runs.
Tohu Harris has been punted from NZ's rugby league World Cup squad to make way for Sonny Bill Williams.
This season, the 28-year-old has averaged 12 hit-ups, 24 tackles and 108 metres per game, figures Sattler believes do not denote greatness.
"He can't be considered a great of the game, imagine putting him in the same league as Bob McCarthy, Ron Coote or Reg Gasnier," Sattler said.
"He doesn't get involved enough, he hangs around and every so often he will make a great run, but he has no work-rate.
"His first half the other night was woeful, in grand finals your first half is crucial so he really played half-a-game.
"Sonny Bill wouldn't hold a candle to Coote or McCarthy. There's no doubt he has plenty of ability but in my opinion he just doesn't do enough work."
Despite Barnett's blast, the NZRL eventually added Williams to their Cup squad, just prior to the forward explaining his backflip on social media.
"Without thinking the whole situation through, I eagerly jumped at the chance to chill out and rest," he said.
"After having some time to really think about how much representing my country means to me, I decided to put my name forward for selection."
Maroons coach Mal Meninga believes NRL hierarchy can do no more to prevent Williams returning to play for the Chiefs and All Blacks in 2014.
"I think the NRL have done enough," Meninga said.
Sonny Bill Williams has issued an apology for his World Cup selection backflip, insisting his decision to take a holiday was not thoroughly considered.
"Sonny Bill understands how much the game wants him to stay. It's a personal decision. The game has told Sonny Bill how much they want him to stay and they will do everything they possibly can, but at the end of the day it will be his decision."
Broncos rival Justin Hodges urged Williams not to walk away from rugby league.
"I think he has been fantastic for the game," he said.
"When you lose players like Karmichael (Hunt) and 'Izzy' (Folau) to other codes, it makes their codes bigger.
"We need our big names to stay, a guy like Sonny Bill draws fans and entertains.
"Having him this year made the game a bit more hyped and I think he's a fantastic athlete. The Roosters have the money to keep him, it's just a matter of whether he wants to stay on. I hope he does."
http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sp...end-john-sattler/story-fni3gn3s-1226735605332
