Hall of Fame and Immortals

[Tommy Smith]

No doubt a great player. But his off field antics should have been considered. But hey,I guess it's all good as it paves the way for Fittler to eventually get the nod.

(BTW,I'm still steaming that Paul Cariage didn't get a blazer)

What off field antics? Popping a few pills? How many men haven't taken a few party drugs. Crime of the Century right there.

That'd rule Lockyer out too btw. And well, 99% of league players. Let's rule out JT for Coffs Harbour. And Smith & Slater for cheating the cap (they didn't know lololol).

The only Immortal left for candidacy will be Jesus by the time we're done.

 

[King hit]

The original surviving immortals wrote him a rather scathing letter back in the day regarding that.

It was Raper who wrote it and said it to him in person. He got a rousing cheer for it as well.

 

[Life's Good]

What off field antics? Popping a few pills? How many men haven't taken a few party drugs. Crime of the Century right there.

That'd rule Lockyer out too btw. And well, 99% of league players. Let's rule out JT for Coffs Harbour. And Smith & Slater for cheating the cap (they didn't know lololol).

The only Immortal left for candidacy will be Jesus by the time we're done.

Cmon Tommy, he may have won 2 Dally M’s but Hayne has been too inconsistent.

 

[carcharias]

What off field antics? Popping a few pills? How many men haven't taken a few party drugs. Crime of the Century right there.

That'd rule Lockyer out too btw. And well, 99% of league players. Let's rule out JT for Coffs Harbour. And Smith & Slater for cheating the cap (they didn't know lololol).

The only Immortal left for candidacy will be Jesus by the time we're done.

Nah ...Gallen took the peptides

 

[Quicksilver]

No doubt a great player. But his off field antics should have been considered. But hey,I guess it's all good as it paves the way for Fittler to eventually get the nod.

(BTW,I'm still steaming that Paul Cariage didn't get a blazer)

Well, some of the stories I've heard about the originals...

 

[Miller was a legend]

What off field antics? Popping a few pills? How many men haven't taken a few party drugs. Crime of the Century right there.

That'd rule Lockyer out too btw. And well, 99% of league players. Let's rule out JT for Coffs Harbour. And Smith & Slater for cheating the cap (they didn't know lololol).

The only Immortal left for candidacy will be Jesus by the time we're done.

Na, he won’t qualify. He let the other 12 players down by hanging out with the wrong crowd

 

[axl rose]

It was Raper who wrote it and said it to him in person. He got a rousing cheer for it as well.

I thought it was signed by the immortals/Kangaroo captains but I could be wrong. Reg Gasnier use to brush SmellmeFinger at functions back in the day, and rightly so. Lucky for Mal they don't take into account a players character off the field.

 

[no name]

Meninga? Is this the Immortals or the Ungratefuls?

 

[Diesel]

We bag the NRL when they mess up but welll done to them tonight. Some great players named tonight

 

[Jimmy Clark]

How does Andrew “the self confessed drug addict” Johns fit in with this group of MEN? What a f**king joke it is.

 

[nick87]

Long overdue for Mal.

The most decorated RL identity ever. Combine his playing career with his QLD and Aus coaching career and find me a player with more credentials than him. He's the real GOAT

 

[Brutus]

Greenberg didn't know anything about rugby league before he got a gig with ANZ Stadium.

 

[Brutus]

Long overdue for Mal.

The most decorated RL identity ever. Combine his playing career with his QLD and Aus coaching career and find me a player with more credentials than him. He's the real GOAT

Needed to mention more of his time with the South Brisbane Magpies.

 

[Life's Good]

Greenberg didn't know anything about rugby league before he got a gig with ANZ Stadium.

Not much has changed.

Although I’m happy with tonight(Immortals & HoF recognition).

 

[typicalfan]

How does Andrew “the self confessed drug addict” Johns fit in with this group of MEN? What a f**king joke it is.

Halfback of the century. Case closed.

 

[Saxon]

Never mind

 

[typicalfan]

Long overdue for Mal.

The most decorated RL identity ever. Combine his playing career with his QLD and Aus coaching career and find me a player with more credentials than him. He's the real GOAT

Great leader of men. Possibly better leader than player.

 

[GongPanther]

What off field antics? Popping a few pills? How many men haven't taken a few party drugs. Crime of the Century right there.

You're kidding...Condoning what Johns did is a ridiculous thing to say. A right example for the kids to look up to that he is...never.

 

[Brutus]

Raper smashed a journalist’s car, streaked in England, had bar fights, brushes with the law and turned up stone drunk to play test matches. Should he be excluded to? Didn’t Lewis spit on a referee or player once and fought with administrators within the game.

If we dumped anyone who did something wrong just once there would hardly be anyone left.

Wally never spat at a ref. He spat on Gold Coast Giant forward Jim Cowell during a local derby at Lang Park. Crazy Jim was one of those players who needed to be spat on now and then. Geno got stuck into him in a Wynnum-Manly v Redcliffe game a few years earlier.

 

[Quicksilver]

You're kidding...Condoning what Johns did is a ridiculous thing to say. A right example for the kids to look up to that he is...never.

I'd hate for my kids to take something that makes them feel good.