What's new
By:
Advanced search…
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Has a coach ever been successful (won a comp) after being sacked?

dragon_around

dragon_around

Juniors
Messages
1,291
adamkungl said:
The ONLY coach in the NRL era who won their first premiership at their second (or third) club, is John Lang.

Sheens and Bennett have won premierships after leaving a club, but of course they had already won premierships before that.

So if Cleary manages to win it this year, it would be an interesting historical note. Also at Penrith, too.
Click to expand...
What about Nathan Brown?

Sacked by the Dragons in '08. Won the 2014 Super League Grand Final with St Helens.
 
Bring back John Fifita

Bring back John Fifita

First Grade
Messages
8,480
Walpole said:
The "Sack Tipping" and "Sack Kearney" threads would be overflowing!
Click to expand...

Dragons forum starter kit.

images
 
Bring back John Fifita

Bring back John Fifita

First Grade
Messages
8,480
Valheru said:
Yeah isn't there some stat that if a coach doesn't win a comp in the first 3 years of their career or something close to that then they never will?

Cleary has a decent chance to break that trend.
Click to expand...

Geez never knew that. And yeah it rings true now that I think of it.. NRL era at least...
 
The_Frog

The_Frog

First Grade
Messages
6,390
Valheru said:
Yeah isn't there some stat that if a coach doesn't win a comp in the first 3 years of their career or something close to that then they never will?

Cleary has a decent chance to break that trend.
Click to expand...
John Lang won his maiden and only premiership in his 271st game, in his 10th season as an NRL coach. He'd coached in the Brisbane comp for at least a decade before that. Cleary is now in his 14th season as an NRL coach, with 347 games.

Tim Sheens was in his 6th season when he won his first title. Craig Bellamy's first premiership that was not subsequently stripped came in his 10th season.
 
Last edited:
Valheru

Valheru

Coach
Messages
19,218
The_Frog said:
John Lang won his maiden and only premiership in his 271st game, in his 10th season as an NRL coach. He'd coached in the Brisbane comp for at least a decade before that. Cleary is now in his 14th season as an NRL coach, with 347 games.

Tim Sheens was in his 6th season when he won his first title. Craig Bellamy's first premiership that was not subsequently stripped came in his 10th season.
Click to expand...

I wouldn't count Bellamy.

Fair call on the other 2 though.
 
Captain Apollo

Captain Apollo

Coach
Messages
15,497
From this article on the NRL's website (source: https://www.nrl.com/news/2020/09/04/the-recycled-or-the-rookie-how-to-hunt-a-title-winning-coach/)

Since 1990 only two coaches have won their first premiership after more than six seasons of trying at first-grade level – John Lang (Penrith, 2003) and Steve Folkes (Canterbury, 2004).

And only two coaches in that same 30-year timeframe have landed that breakthrough title after coaching 200 games – Lang again, and Manly Immortal Bob Fulton, who coached 229 games before winning the 1987 title, and 348 games en route to the 1996 premiership.

The average numbers of your premiership-winning coach – 99 games, four years into his head coaching career, and roughly 45 years old.

stat-attack-coaches_20200903a.jpg
Click to expand...
 
soc123_au

soc123_au

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
19,867
adamkungl said:
The ONLY coach in the NRL era who won their first premiership at their second (or third) club, is John Lang.

Sheens and Bennett have won premierships after leaving a club, but of course they had already won premierships before that.

So if Cleary manages to win it this year, it would be an interesting historical note. Also at Penrith, too.
Click to expand...
If it does happen, then the other similarity is the Father Son connection as well. It would be quite the quinella.
 
TheRam

TheRam

Coach
Messages
13,907
Penrose Warrior said:
Ivan Cleary will win one and become the answer.

f**k you Wayne Scurrah. I just read Simon Mannering's book and for someone as non-outspoken as Simon, he's pretty strong on the fact we shat on the next 10 years (and counting) of our club by getting rid of Cleary.
Click to expand...

Cleary is and always was a great young coach. I couldn't believe the Warriors and then the Panthers got rid of him.

Well sanity prevailed at the Panthers at least and they have corrected their original error at least.

The Warriors are still a basket case though and Brown will need to really up his game if he wants to turn their attitude around.
 
Captain Apollo

Captain Apollo

Coach
Messages
15,497
Cockadoodledoo said:
Was going to post this. Souths definitely sacked Jack Gibson in 1979. .
Click to expand...

I'd forgotten it actually (it has been a whilst since I read Jack's biography). He was sacked by the Souths Board as in 1979 they wanted him to use a full selection committee, something he'd done away with in 1978. Jack had also asked for pay raises for his assistants. When Jack refused to re-instate a selection committee, they sacked him.

This was public knowledge as after he was told, with Club Secretary Terry Parker present, Jack assembled all 3 grades and told them that he'd been sacked and why.

Earlier that year some Souths ex-players, notably Bob McCarthy, who'd retired at the end of 1978, had turned on Jack because he would not have the side play "the Souths way" (i.e. attacking football) so they were blasting him in the media.As Jack said at the time, outside of Terry Fahey, they didn't have the talent in the backs to play an expansive attacking game.

Jack sat out the 1980 season and only agreed to coach at Parramatta in 1981 as the Parramatta Eels Board gave Jack everything he wanted (namely full control of selection).
 
T

TheDalek079

Bench
Messages
4,432
Captain Apollo said:
I'd forgotten it actually (it has been a whilst since I read Jack's biography). He was sacked by the Souths Board as in 1979 they wanted him to use a full selection committee, something he'd done away with in 1978. Jack had also asked for pay raises for his assistants. When Jack refused to re-instate a selection committee, they sacked him.

This was public knowledge as after he was told, with Club Secretary Terry Parker present, Jack assembled all 3 grades and told them that he'd been sacked and why.

Earlier that year some Souths ex-players, notably Bob McCarthy, who'd retired at the end of 1978, had turned on Jack because he would not have the side play "the Souths way" (i.e. attacking football) so they were blasting him in the media.As Jack said at the time, outside of Terry Fahey, they didn't have the talent in the backs to play an expansive attacking game.

Jack sat out the 1980 season and only agreed to coach at Parramatta in 1981 as the Parramatta Eels Board gave Jack everything he wanted (namely full control of selection).
Click to expand...


Shame on souffs! Imagine the idiocy of sacking Jack Gibson!! No wonder they won nothing for 40 years!
 
A

AJB1102

First Grade
Messages
6,339
Valheru said:
Yeah isn't there some stat that if a coach doesn't win a comp in the first 3 years of their career or something close to that then they never will?

Cleary has a decent chance to break that trend.
Click to expand...

Flanno took 5 and a bit seasons at Cronulla. 4 and a bit if you take out his ban year, but back to 5 and a bit since he copped a second ban for being too involved during his first ban.

Without looking I'd think that stat would be pretty accurate. I tend to think that probably has a lot to do with how often some clubs sack coaches. The data would be heavily skewed by the likes of Warriors, Tigers and Titans for instance.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Top