hayne cleared to play

[johns_reds]

as i mentioned in another thread disgraceful decision but at least now we won't hear any moaning from nsw fans next week after qld beat thier BEST team available!

 

[bluey]

IMO not one of them deserves a suspension the league has got i all wrong, if any thing follow crickets lead for small stuff fine them a % of match payment once they are over a certain amount and it is more serious the sit them down.

 

[Grail]

as i mentioned in another thread disgraceful decision but at least now we won't hear any moaning from nsw fans next week after qld beat thier BEST team available!

It isn't their BEST team available though, and never will be whilst the selectors are making stupid decisions. Saying that, Hayne should have been suspended under the current system, and Slater did make contact, it was just light - he should also have been charged and suspended.

 

[sooperdooper]

I think hayne not getting suspended is fair... considering thurston and slater did as well.

A tackle like lewis's is far more dangerous than a love tap that hayne did.

If hayne were to be suspended then so should have slater.

 

[mickdo]

Slater got off because no contact was made

:lol:

 

[cornerposter]

IMO not one of them deserves a suspension the league has got i all wrong, if any thing follow crickets lead for small stuff fine them a % of match payment once they are over a certain amount and it is more serious the sit them down.

f**k me, 1200+ posts and you've finally got one to make sense

 

[pantherz9103]

Intent does not come into it- it was not graded as intentional. It was a careless tackle and was graded that way. Mind you Lewis being out is better for NSW anyway as they might stop hyping this good club footballer to be anything more than that!

In my opinion Luke Lewis is one of the top five footballers in the competition.

 

[parraeelz]

In my opinion Luke Lewis is one of the top five footballers in the competition.

Damn straight Lewis is killing it this year..hes EVERYWHERE!
He's ball playing running into holes and setting up tries for the panthers.
What a gun
whoever said he shouldn't be in the team seriously what are you smoking..wouldn't mind to see him in the halves..would also do an alright job at 5/8th

 

[Mark Rudd]

I thought what Hayne did was one of the most violent acts ever seen on a football field of any code of football in the world.

Sickening.