So much speculation about stuff none of us know anything about.
Ash Taylor going here or there, Hayne being a poor trainer, what Hayne will do after his current deal expires (LOL) etc....
Just to answer a few questions though before I'm accused (again) of being a Hayne apologist.
1. Do I think he is match fit? No. He has clearly struggled at times. He has also clearly lost some pace. Neither of which he cannot get back.
2. Do I think we should have got Hayne back to the Eels at all costs? No. Not at all. There is a balance needed in salary cap expenditure that could have been upset with his return.
3. Are the Eels better off without him? Tbh, who knows? At this stage, probably yes, but in the long run, it is only speculation and nobody knows.
4. (Delboy) Did or Has Hayne hurt his brand? Amongst the majority of Eels fans, probably yes. I'm pissed off too at the way things panned out. I'm not sure ALL the blame can be laid on Hayne and his management though, unless we know all the facts, which none of us ever will. I'm not sure the fans or management of the Titans would be thinking along these lines though.
5. I'm not even going to remotely approach some other laughable suggestions that have been posted here over the last few days because honestly, they are embarrassing.
My personal opinion is that Hayne was a magnificent player for our club and gave me plenty of great memories. He was the most talented player I've ever seen that wore the blue and gold.
He has made several life and career defining decisions that many of us haven't liked. Including me.
But I'm sitting here giving him the benefit of the doubt to make his own choices in life and will continue to not be judgmental of him for doing what he thinks is right. If his decisions piss some people off, that's fine and nothing I say will change that.
What I have difficulty in accepting is innuendo and non factual accusations and name calling, and beyond that, there is the ignorant, juvenile bullshit,
Each to their own I suppose.
Ash Taylor going here or there, Hayne being a poor trainer, what Hayne will do after his current deal expires (LOL) etc....
Just to answer a few questions though before I'm accused (again) of being a Hayne apologist.
1. Do I think he is match fit? No. He has clearly struggled at times. He has also clearly lost some pace. Neither of which he cannot get back.
2. Do I think we should have got Hayne back to the Eels at all costs? No. Not at all. There is a balance needed in salary cap expenditure that could have been upset with his return.
3. Are the Eels better off without him? Tbh, who knows? At this stage, probably yes, but in the long run, it is only speculation and nobody knows.
4. (Delboy) Did or Has Hayne hurt his brand? Amongst the majority of Eels fans, probably yes. I'm pissed off too at the way things panned out. I'm not sure ALL the blame can be laid on Hayne and his management though, unless we know all the facts, which none of us ever will. I'm not sure the fans or management of the Titans would be thinking along these lines though.
5. I'm not even going to remotely approach some other laughable suggestions that have been posted here over the last few days because honestly, they are embarrassing.
My personal opinion is that Hayne was a magnificent player for our club and gave me plenty of great memories. He was the most talented player I've ever seen that wore the blue and gold.
He has made several life and career defining decisions that many of us haven't liked. Including me.
But I'm sitting here giving him the benefit of the doubt to make his own choices in life and will continue to not be judgmental of him for doing what he thinks is right. If his decisions piss some people off, that's fine and nothing I say will change that.
What I have difficulty in accepting is innuendo and non factual accusations and name calling, and beyond that, there is the ignorant, juvenile bullshit,
Each to their own I suppose.