Hayne Vs Inu

[Stagger eel]

sheesh!! it was hard enough comparing Ella to Kenny...

I think I'll pass on this one.

 

[The Colonel]

I'll take both please Eddie...... they both have their strengths and weaknesses in different areas. They are young and extremely talented and are now both internationals. Couldn't care less.

 

[yy_cheng]

sheesh!! it was hard enough comparing Ella to Kenny...

I think I'll pass on this one.

What about Sterlo and Paul Taylor both play Fullback and Halfback, Both tackled around the legs, both had blond hair.

 

[Stagger eel]

What about Sterlo and Paul Taylor both play Fullback and Halfback, Both tackled around the legs, both had blond hair.

easy!!

1 played well above his weight and natural talent the other was a deadset freak!! ;-)

 

[Eelementary]

Inu for mind, Jarryd is brilliant but sometimes the spirit in which he plays the game leaves a little to be desired in my opinion.

Have to agree with that.

 

[hineyrulz]

INU is ahead of Jarryd ATM, is that because that there is speculation that Jarryd may be leaving Parra???? Or is it INU seems a more likeable player. I dont know, but Jarryd excelled in Origin, thats good enough for me.

 

[parra_jesus]

im a big fan of inu. so inu gets my vote

 

[COACH STERLING]

Legends of the game should never be compared.

Both will be legends in a few years

 

[Parra Guru]

Inu can't put a foot wrong so he gets my vote.

I agree with some of the sentiments already said on Jarryd.... Lack of urgency, poor sportsmanship, and massive ego are all down points in his game IMO.

 

[Galeforce]

good Souths will be please with Hayne where he would recieve marque treatment.he would be equilavent for our backline as Asotasi is for our forwards.

 

[HayneHindi]

Go home you scum.

I feel that Hayne will turn into a has been if he goes to Souths. Look what you have done to Widders. He used to be a decent player when he was at the eels, now he is a fat slob. You were all after Jeremy Smith and now you want to get rid of him.

You get rid of Moi Moi, now he is in the NZ side. Maybe Joe will smash your team next time the sides meet.

 

[Galeforce]

Haynehindi ,
do not think you stated one logical point.

1) I was not aware that Jeremy smith played NZ tests when he was with the Eels. As i recall he was your second string half. As I understand that he is made his test debut today after playing with Souths all year.I also understand that Souths did not pay a lot to get him from Eels.

2) fui fui , well he left Souths in the piggins era and came to Eels and played most games in PL until this year . so do not understand your point , unless you want to delve into all the parra players that you have let go in the last five years.

3) as for Haynes , your feeling that he would not play well if he went to Souths. your opinion. Mine is he will play well with any team that has a decent pack of forward. Souths forwards are souths strength , so i think you are justing pissing in your pants.

 

[Tizzun]

For mine Hayne is the better player, has a natural skill with both hands and feet. Given the opportunity could kick goals as well as INU. I like INU but today he showed that he is only human. Hayne is a machine.

Along similar lines given the space Hayne had today when he scored his try would INU have scored? I've got some doubt about that.

 

[Redback71]

id have to go Hayne at the moment, but only by a whisker.

 

[Suitman]

Along similar lines given the space Hayne had today when he scored his try would INU have scored? I've got some doubt about that.

:lol:

Inu would have walked over untouched.

Suity

 

[caylo]

Haynehindi ,
do not think you stated one logical point.

1) I was not aware that Jeremy smith played NZ tests when he was with the Eels. As i recall he was your second string half. As I understand that he is made his test debut today after playing with Souths all year.I also understand that Souths did not pay a lot to get him from Eels.

2) fui fui , well he left Souths in the piggins era and came to Eels and played most games in PL until this year . so do not understand your point , unless you want to delve into all the parra players that you have let go in the last five years.

3) as for Haynes , your feeling that he would not play well if he went to Souths. your opinion. Mine is he will play well with any team that has a decent pack of forward. Souths forwards are souths strength , so i think you are justing pissing in your pants.

1) he was talked up as ready to play the test last year before he was suspended for pushing the ref, and he only made it becuase relay their is noone else.

2) FuiFui has been playing well for about 3 years, it is obvious he has potential, but south coaches are blind. It caused by a caterax disease you pick up in redfern. Hence why the players play as if they were blind too.

3) Hayne would struggle in the Rabbitohs team because they have no flair. You halves are about as good as the dogs, you guys are neck and neck as having the worst halves pairing in the history of the game. Hayne doesn't need a forward pack that dominates, he just needs to see some ball and that is something that you guys can't provide.

4) FROM THIS CONSTANT CRAP HAYNE BLEEDS RED AND WHITE: he grew up in campbeltown, that is about 90min drove to redfern. It's also easy to distinguish

campbeltown --> lots of trees, and farm land
Redfern --> lots of junkies and needles.

Why would he play for an area that increases his chances of being infected with HIV by 200%

 

[Paranoid]

Hayne by a nose.

 

[Galeforce]

Caylo,

your prognosis misses key points as well. so let me help you.

Eels halves ain;t nothing in my view and i prefer Souths PL to your top. The problem with Souths backline has NOT been the halves . Unless you believe the halves must make all the breaks and throw perfect balls to players into space and kick perfect balls.

Souths problem has been there has not been speed and "line breakers" in the threequarters or from fullback. my view is if Souths got a Hayne type into fullback , and another centre who stand and break , then all souths needed were halves who could pass the ball out the line , without doing anything spectacular. The outside men would cause the trouble. By the way once you can do this , then suddenly there is less pressure on the halves , as opponent defence focus becomes spread and suddenly even mediocre halves start making more breaks. Sorry for the football lesson ,but you were asking for it.

As for Souths prior coaches not recognising talent........what a joke of a statement coming from someone following Parramatta. YOu guys have leaked so much talent it is not funny.

 

[caylo]

Caylo,

your prognosis misses key points as well. so let me help you.

Eels halves ain;t nothing in my view and i prefer Souths PL to your top. The problem with Souths backline has NOT been the halves . Unless you believe the halves must make all the breaks and throw perfect balls to players into space and kick perfect balls.

Souths problem has been there has not been speed and "line breakers" in the threequarters or from fullback. my view is if Souths got a Hayne type into fullback , and another centre who stand and break , then all souths needed were halves who could pass the ball out the line , without doing anything spectacular. The outside men would cause the trouble. By the way once you can do this , then suddenly there is less pressure on the halves , as opponent defence focus becomes spread and suddenly even mediocre halves start making more breaks. Sorry for the football lesson ,but you were asking for it.

As for Souths prior coaches not recognising talent........what a joke of a statement coming from someone following Parramatta. YOu guys have leaked so much talent it is not funny.

No, Peachy was in good form, you have Merrit, Mellor. Their are good players there. Even when Jeremy Smith was at Parramatta i thought his option taking was terrible and he struggled to create things. Rogers is meh, alright but nothing else. Williams has a good kicking game, but that is it and he is gone now. That young hooker you guys have is the most creative player in your... Wing will be a good addition tbh, may add some spark from halfback.

On the other hand we have Tim Smith who is 3rd highest on try assist (only behind Thurston and Price), has been playing well all year and outside him is an experianced origin player, who has more creativity that all your halves combined but yet doesn't have a tenth of the creativity that Timmy has. TBH souths made the 8 on their defence, and a string forward pack show. They were smashed in their finals game, and sent home packing.

Parramatta has it over Souths in the halves and the backline. Hell our PL halves are better than your buddy.

 

[Eelementary]

1) I was not aware that Jeremy smith played NZ tests when he was with the Eels. As i recall he was your second string half. As I understand that he is made his test debut today after playing with Souths all year.I also understand that Souths did not pay a lot to get him from Eels.

2) fui fui , well he left Souths in the piggins era and came to Eels and played most games in PL until this year . so do not understand your point , unless you want to delve into all the parra players that you have let go in the last five years.

(1) Jason Taylor has a permanent hard-on for the over-rated (MASSIVELY over-rated) Jeremy Smith - and so he was practically our starting halfback over a few weeks there for a while.

(2) Mostly PL games? Fui has been a regular in our 17 for years now - it's only injuries and suspensions that have stopped him from playing more matches.