If we miss the finals, should Tim Sheens walk

[Das Hassler]

Andrew..yep..just about back to close to full strength but the engine will probably still be running a bit rough for a couple of weeks...the combinations don't just fall into place when they come back after a few months right?...The way Lawrence has come back nearly beggars belief..if Tiquiri gets up to speed as quick then i'm pretty optimistic for the rest of the season...Ellis will be back to his best very soon as well...we'll be long odds against Manly (after Easts) but it won't be the cakewalk they think it'll be (despise those f--kers)

 

[andrew9148]

From memory, we have easts, titans, sharks and parra plus st george and manly and one other? those first 4 i mention we should beat. that will be all we need to do i think

 

[westie]

I'm all for moving old, past it players on to make sure we don't stagnate. The opposite has happened, during our main run at the trophy.

 

[macnaz]

Always so many f**king excuses.

Sorry, "reasons, not excuses" as the great man says.

Let's face it, we could get the spoon three years running and he'd still be there.

That about sums it up.

 

[super_coach]

At the start of the season we were thinking top two and specials for top four. Now we are preying for 8th position and maybe as high as 6th position if we get lucky. Okay we had some major injuries but really that is not a excuse for where we are today. Losses to the dogs,rabbits, gold coast,chooks and parramatta just plain unacceptable.

Also how come Sheens decided mid season that we needed to go down another track for 2012 and beyond ?? I mean most of the players he had shown the door to and just signed new contracts????

Anyway back to the point--Yes he should walk--no he wont walk

 

[N.C.]

No.

He needs to put his money where his mouth is. If he has a plan, then let's see it in action. You can't shake up a roster like that and then just walk away. How about a little bit of follow through?

If we get similar results in 2012, then send him packing.

 

[glockers]

If the Dogs go for Stuart or Potter, then I wouldn't mind Dymock to be honest. I have heard good things about his coaching for quite some time.

 

[leoc]

anything short of the premiership and he should walk. You can make all the excuses you like but I think the disharmony within the club will only fester over the next season if we don't take the premiership. Then we will be a moral for the spoon in 2012.

 

[Borat.]

NO-

The club should no stick by him after re signing him....

If they were going to punt him they should have not have let him tear apart the team - no point pissing him off , signing a new coach who inherits a bunch of players he never wanted

 

[macnaz]

I said Yes and after looking at the injuries and then the turmoil at releasing players i thought NO he should stay and see this through.. BUT after hearing Tim go on about having to build a bigger more aggressive pack because thats what is needed in this day of NRL footy then i see the kok sucker pick 2 backs on the bench plus a criple in Payten and then Fulton in the pack just shows he is talking out his arse as always and regardless of the players he has at his disposal in 2012 he will still pick the wrong players or players out of position,,, So its still a big YES to piss this overated clown off as soon as possible.

 

[andrew9148]

I said Yes and after looking at the injuries and then the turmoil at releasing players i thought NO he should stay and see this through.. BUT after hearing Tim go on about having to build a bigger more aggressive pack because thats what is needed in this day of NRL footy then i see the kok sucker pick 2 backs on the bench plus a criple in Payten and then Fulton in the pack just shows he is talking out his arse as always and regardless of the players he has at his disposal in 2012 he will still pick the wrong players or players out of position,,, So its still a big YES to piss this overated clown off as soon as possible.

So he picked a team that won a game?

 

[macnaz]

So he picked a team that won a game?

Hardly a convincing win, we had a million to one penalty count and.we struggled against the spooners.

 

[Borat.]

NO-

The club should no stick by him after re signing him....

If they were going to punt him they should have not have let him tear apart the team - no point pissing him off , signing a new coach who inherits a bunch of players he never wanted

WTF was I thinking - is that the wost use of an inter chabge in the history of the NRL.....

On purely that one "use " of the bench in last nights game I say piss the old bastard off-

 

[macnaz]

WTF was I thinking - is that the wost use of an inter chabge in the history of the NRL.....

On purely that one "use " of the bench in last nights game I say piss the old bastard off-

lol i was the same ,, almost thought the dumb merkin was worth persevering with... but really he's f**ked ....FULLSTOP !!!! Get rid of him

 

[innsaneink]

I think we now will scrape into the semis...should get 4 more wins

 

[andrew9148]

I think we now will scrape into the semis...should get 4 more wins

I agree. If they are fiar dinkum they should get to 30 points. 6th place is whats important.

 

[Old Time Tiger]

Not walk, run please.

The stewards should have called an emergency meeting after the naming of the bench on Saturday night.

Forget that they won, the fact that he was allowed to play with that bench and then use Ryan like he did :crazy::crazy::crazy:yep crazy.

 

[TroopyF]

He'll never walk and I doubt the club is in a position to pay the bugger out either. Whats worse he will already have the "rebuilding stage" excuse ready for next year and beyond.

 

[super_coach]

When you have put in so many crap years for so long you become a expert at finding ways to fool people in order to survive and that what our man is "a survivor"
Even when the media starts to turn on him he pulls a ace out of his pocket, pulls a press conference rambles on about rubbish, puts them in their place and everyone loves him again.

He will be in the joint till the day he cant keeping pulling the wool over the boards eyes and that will be for ever

 

[Mr Fourex]

Shouldn't be given the opportunity to walk. He should be just arse-holed regardless of what HE wants to do.

The sooner he gets fu*ked off from the national coaching position the better off we'll be as well.