Opinion Is Ricky Stuart the most overrated coach ever?

[The Enforcer]

Found it touching how Ricky felt sorry for the poor refs and the corner the media had pushed them into even though he has a 10 year career of bullying the refs.

Nostrils is a whingeing hypocrite.

 

[Walt Flanigan]

True
Though Bennett has a win ratio of over sixty two per cent while Ricky has a win ratio of less than 48 per cent
ricky does not have a good record as a coach

This is known.

Was just a weird statement given that guys like Bennett, Sheens & Brian Smith have a lot more total losses than Stuart.

Stuart's win/loss ratio is a genuine criticism. Granted he hasn't been coaching noted NRL high-flyers in the Sharks, Eels & Raiders but I think any coach worth his salt should be able to do something with the roster he's built at Canberra. Just have to wait and see.

 

[TonyT6]

As a Saints fan I'd take Stuart over Price or Mary every day of the week

 

[Meapro Ham]

Like to know what that win loss ratio would be excluding the Fittler years post 2004. Under 40% I'm guessing. Hey let's pay that guy a million bucks a year! I don't get it...

 

[Meapro Ham]

As a Saints fan I'd take Stuart over Price or Mary every day of the week

Mary has a 100% strike rate of reaching the finals. That's a lot better than Stuart.

Don't get the Dragons fans criticism of Macgregor. Has done a pretty decent job with a limited roster

 

[Walt Flanigan]

Mary has a 100% strike rate of reaching the finals.

50%

 

[Meapro Ham]

50%

If you count the part year of 2014 then yeah it's 50%. The point still stands considering the limited squads he's had there

 

[TonyT6]

Mary has a 100% strike rate of reaching the finals. That's a lot better than Stuart.

Don't get the Dragons fans criticism of Macgregor. Has done a pretty decent job with a limited roster

The dope picked half of that "limited roster" & his tactical genius has seen us score a total of 89 points in 9 games.

 

[JamesRustle]

As a Saints fan I'd take Stuart over Price or Mary every day of the week

Don't think the Sharkies would take him back.. not even as an assistant.

 

[Horrie Is God]

As a Saints fan I'd take Stuart over Price or Mary every day of the week

Virtually choosing between a glass of someone else's vomit, a shit sandwich or being repeatedly kicked in the balls..

 

[Cloud]

I wonder if a "Is Matthew Elliot overrated as a coach" thread would get as many replies.

 

[El Diablo]

Elliot was never on the coin Stuart gets

 

[Walt Flanigan]

I wonder if a "Is Matthew Elliot overrated as a coach" thread would get as many replies.

Probably not. This thread is pretty much kept alive by bitter Eels supporters and Queenslanders that Ricky trolled during his time as NSW coach.

 

[Glen]

I wonder if a "Is Matthew Elliot overrated as a coach" thread would get as many replies.

Probably not, since no one rates him and no one will employ him as a head coach. Surely Ricky will join him soon if he can't turn this Canberra team into a threat

 

[--Storm--]

The dope picked half of that "limited roster" & his tactical genius has seen us score a total of 89 points in 9 games.

It was he previous coach that got rid of Soward and bought Benji and Widdop :lol:

 

[Penrose Warrior]

I wonder if a "Is Matthew Elliot overrated as a coach" thread would get as many replies.

No one rates Matthew Elliott, and he doesn't keep getting jobs on big coin, so it's unlikely to ever see the light of day.

 

[The Enforcer]

Probably not. This thread is pretty much kept alive by bitter Eels supporters and Queenslanders that Ricky trolled during his time as NSW coach.

And you've got no self control and can't help posting to defend the overrated f**king whinger in here

 

[Walt Flanigan]

And you've got no self control and can't help posting to defend the overrated f**king whinger in here

Nothing wrong with a bit of banter.

 

[THE CHAMP]

Nothing wrong with a bit of banter.

True.
But you don't banter.
You whinge.

 

[bileduct]

Too easy, Walt