Opinion Is Ricky Stuart the most overrated coach ever?

[betcats]

Because in the context of the interview Ricky's credibility as a coach was being questioned . Who knows maybe Farrah never actually did consider it and just didn't have the heart to tell Ricky he wouldn't play for him if he was the last coach on earth .

:lol:

Why would I believe that^ over what Robbie actually said?

 

[Wizard Sleeve]

:lol:

Why would I believe that^ over what Robbie actually said?

Didn't ask you to believe it , I wasn't stating any of it as a fact .

 

[betcats]

Didn't ask you to believe it , I wasn't stating any of it as a fact .

Good because it was some pretty fine straw clutching.

 

[Danish]

A crazy but brilliant acquaintance put together the below list of every signing made by Ricky Stuart from his time at the Sharks onwards... He is a nutter so its edited very thoroughly

2007 Sharks Gains

ANDERSON, Fraser (Brisbane)
COOPER, Dustin (Newcastle 2005)
DE GOIS, Isaac (Wests Tigers)
HANNAY, Josh (North Queensland)
PERENARA, Henry (Parramatta)
SEYMOUR, Brett (Brisbane)
STAPLETON, Craig (Penrith)
STEPHENSON, Paul (Manly Warringah)
TAULAPAPA, Misi (Warriors)

2008 Sharks Gains

GREEN, Blake (Parramatta)
NORRIE, Bryan (Penrith)
NUTLEY, Danny (Sydney)
PEEK, Adam (St George Illawarra)
SEU SEU, Terence (Newcastle)
SNOWDEN, Kade (Newcastle)

2009 Sharks Gains

AFAMASAGA, Jack (Manly Warringah)
BARRETT, Trent (Wigan)
CAINE, Tony (St George Illawarra 2007)
DONNELLY, Ian (Melbourne 2007)
GOODWIN, Bronx (Canberra)
HUGHES, Corey (Bulldogs)
MAITUA, Reni (Bulldogs)
TUPOU, Anthony (Sydney

2010 Sharks Gains

AITON, Paul (Penrith)
COLLIS, Dean (Wests Tigers)
CORDOBA, Josh (Parramatta)
CUTHBERTSON, Adam (Manly Warringah)
FLANAGAN, Stuart (Canberra)
HARLEN, Luke (North Queensland 2008)
MORRIS, John (Wests Tigers)
SMITH, Tim (Wigan)
TAUTAI, Taulima (Parramatta)
WRIGHT, Broderick (Parramatta)

2013 Eels Gains

HARRISON, Daniel (Manly Warringah)
LUSSICK, Darcy (Manly Warringah)
PAULO, Junior (Parramatta 2008)

2014 Eels Gains

GOWER, David (Manly Warringah)
HOPOATE, William (Manly Warringah 2011)
HUNT, Justin (South Sydney)
MA'AFU, Lorenzo (Canterbury 2008)
MOSSOP, Lee (Wigan)
NORMAN, Corey (Brisbane)
PEATS, Nathan (South Sydney)

2014 Raiders Gains

BAPTISTE, Kurt (Brisbane 2012)
O'DONNELL, Kyle (Newcastle 2012)
PANGAI, Mosese (North Queensland 2012)
RAPANA, Jordan (Gold Coast Titans 2008)
SETU, Lagi (Melbourne)
TUPOU, Bill (Warriors)



Truly tremendous proof that Ricky is a squad developing genius :lol:

 

[betcats]

Hoppa is the best signing on that list by a long way and Ricky didnt even sign him!

 

[Pete Cash]

Some of those raiders signings are pre Stuart.

 

[T.S Quint]

Hopoate wasn't signed by Stuart.
That was done when Kearney was still coach.

 

[herbert henry1908]

He didn't recruit Hopoate or I'd suggest any of those 2013 eels recruits.

 

[El Diablo]

not all of those are correct

Lussick and the other 2013 signings weren't Stuart's

Hoppa and Gower weren't signed by Stuart

 

[Wizard Sleeve]

Good because it was some pretty fine straw clutching.

:lol:yeh bro you really had me back pedalling there , now excuse me whilst I chamois my brow. So tell me did Farrah reject Ricky or not ?

 

[betcats]

:lol:yeh bro you really had me back pedalling there , now excuse me whilst I chamois my brow. So tell me did Farrah reject Ricky or not ?

I never said he didn't you moron.

You acted like me believing what Farah said was stupid then when I asked why the best you could make up was "MAYBE he felt bad for ricky".

 

[Danish]

not all of those are correct

Lussick and the other 2013 signings weren't Stuart's

Hoppa and Gower weren't signed by Stuart

Thats probably why 2013 and some of 2014 are the stand out years on that list I'd say

 

[Wizard Sleeve]

A crazy but brilliant acquaintance put together the below list of every signing made by Ricky Stuart from his time at the Sharks onwards... He is a nutter so its edited very thoroughly

2007 Sharks Gains

ANDERSON, Fraser (Brisbane)
COOPER, Dustin (Newcastle 2005)
DE GOIS, Isaac (Wests Tigers)
HANNAY, Josh (North Queensland)
PERENARA, Henry (Parramatta)
SEYMOUR, Brett (Brisbane)
STAPLETON, Craig (Penrith)
STEPHENSON, Paul (Manly Warringah)
TAULAPAPA, Misi (Warriors)

2008 Sharks Gains

GREEN, Blake (Parramatta)
NORRIE, Bryan (Penrith)
NUTLEY, Danny (Sydney)
PEEK, Adam (St George Illawarra)
SEU SEU, Terence (Newcastle)
SNOWDEN, Kade (Newcastle)

2009 Sharks Gains

AFAMASAGA, Jack (Manly Warringah)
BARRETT, Trent (Wigan)
CAINE, Tony (St George Illawarra 2007)
DONNELLY, Ian (Melbourne 2007)
GOODWIN, Bronx (Canberra)
HUGHES, Corey (Bulldogs)
MAITUA, Reni (Bulldogs)
TUPOU, Anthony (Sydney

2010 Sharks Gains

AITON, Paul (Penrith)
COLLIS, Dean (Wests Tigers)
CORDOBA, Josh (Parramatta)
CUTHBERTSON, Adam (Manly Warringah)
FLANAGAN, Stuart (Canberra)
HARLEN, Luke (North Queensland 2008)
MORRIS, John (Wests Tigers)
SMITH, Tim (Wigan)
TAUTAI, Taulima (Parramatta)
WRIGHT, Broderick (Parramatta)

2013 Eels Gains

HARRISON, Daniel (Manly Warringah)
LUSSICK, Darcy (Manly Warringah)
PAULO, Junior (Parramatta 2008)

2014 Eels Gains

GOWER, David (Manly Warringah)
HOPOATE, William (Manly Warringah 2011)
HUNT, Justin (South Sydney)
MA'AFU, Lorenzo (Canterbury 2008)
MOSSOP, Lee (Wigan)
NORMAN, Corey (Brisbane)
PEATS, Nathan (South Sydney)

2014 Raiders Gains

BAPTISTE, Kurt (Brisbane 2012)
O'DONNELL, Kyle (Newcastle 2012)
PANGAI, Mosese (North Queensland 2012)
RAPANA, Jordan (Gold Coast Titans 2008)
SETU, Lagi (Melbourne)
TUPOU, Bill (Warriors)



Truly tremendous proof that Ricky is a squad developing genius :lol:

I won't even start punching holes in your mates work but I will ask , where the f**k is Karl Falinga ?

 

[Wizard Sleeve]

I never said he didn't you moron.

You acted like me believing what Farah said was stupid then when I asked why the best you could make up was "MAYBE he felt bad for ricky".

It was a joke dummy supposed to be funny . Obviously I failed as my target audience of niff nuff f**k sticks didn't get it .

 

[betcats]

Still clutching at straws.

 

[God-King Dean]

2007 Sharks Gains

PLODSON, Fraser (Brisbane)
COOPER, Plodstin (Newcastle 2005)
DE PLOD, Isaac (Wests Tigers)
PLODDAY, Josh (North Queensland)
PLODENARA, Henry (Parramatta)
PLODMOUR, Brett (Brisbane)
PLODLETON, Craig (Penrith)
PLODSON, Paul (Manly Warringah)
TAULAPAPA, Plodi (Warriors)

2008 Sharks Gains

GREEN, Plod (Parramatta)
PLODIE, Bryan (Penrith)
NUTLEY, Plody (Sydney)
PEEK, Plodam (St George Illawarra)
SEU SEU, Plodence (Newcastle)
PLODDEN, Kade (Newcastle)

2009 Sharks Gains

AFAMAPLODA, Jack (Manly Warringah)
PLODETT, Trent (Wigan)
CAINE, Plody (St George Illawarra 2007)
PLODDELLY, Ian (Melbourne 2007)
GOODPLOD, Bronx (Canberra)
HUGHES, Plodey (Bulldogs)
MAITUA, Plodi (Bulldogs)
TUPOU, Plodony (Sydney

2010 Sharks Gains

AITPLOD, Paul (Penrith)
PLODDIS, Dean (Wests Tigers)
CORDPLODA, Josh (Parramatta)
CUTHPLODSON, Adam (Manly Warringah)
PLODAGAN, Stuart (Canberra)
HARPLOD, Luke (North Queensland 2008)
PLODDIS, John (Wests Tigers)
SMITH, Plod (Wigan)
TAUTAI, Plodima (Parramatta)
WRIGHT, Ploderick (Parramatta)

2013 Eels Gains

PLODISON, Daniel (Manly Warringah)
LUSSICK, Plody (Manly Warringah)
PLODO, Junior (Parramatta 2008)

2014 Eels Gains

GOWER, Plodid (Manly Warringah)
HOPOATE, William (Manly Warringah 2011)
HUNT, Plodin (South Sydney)
MA'AFU, Plodenzo (Canterbury 2008)
PLODDOP, Lee (Wigan)
NORMAN, Plodey (Brisbane)
PEATS, Plodan (South Sydney)

2014 Raiders Gains

PLODISTE, Kurt (Brisbane 2012)
O'PLODELL, Kyle (Newcastle 2012)
PANGAI, Plodese (North Queensland 2012)
RAPANA, Plodan (Gold Coast Titans 2008)
SETU, Plodi (Melbourne)
TUPLOD, Bill (Warriors)

 

[nick87]

:lol:

 

[betcats]

I think its safe to say Rickys recruiting skills are almost nonexistent.

 

[Mr Saab]

What a list of immortals in that lot. He truly is a coach that attracts the meat and potatos

 

[Wizard Sleeve]

Still clutching at straws.

Yup . And Farrar wouldn't have went to any coach for millions of dollars other than Ricky Stuart :lol::lol::lol: