Is Stuart Fielden overrated?

[East Coast Tiger]

Fielden is good but has been almost invisible the past two weeks. He did nothing against the Newcastle rep side too. I don't know what's wrong with him, maybe this injury is the problem.
He's certainly not the best prop in the world on this year's form anyway. I reckon Petero is unbelieveable. The guy is getting better and better as he gets older, a bit like Wiki. I don't think I'm overreacting to say Petero has been in the top five best players in the game this year along with Lockyer, Smith, Wellens and Long.

 

[Mal Meninga]

Why would he improve in the NRL?

The UK Super League is softer than a marshmellow.

 

[nqboy]

Ask whoever your number 16 was about that. He was on jelly legs for 10 minutes after meeting Mark O'Meley.

matty, matty, matty, you're beating yourself. He was the bloke that waltzed between Civoniceva and LOD for a really, really soft try. Wipe the Bulldog cum out of your eyes and watch the game again.

 

[deluded pom?]

If matty had any idea about life outside of Sydney he'd know they call the guy Lee Gilmour.

 

[mattyg]

matty, matty, matty, you're beating yourself. He was the bloke that waltzed between Civoniceva and LOD for a really, really soft try. Wipe the Bulldog cum out of your eyes and watch the game again.

Yeah i seen that he scored im not stupid, but the score still stands at O'Meley 1 Gilmour 0. I didn't see people complaining about the score at Kidwell 1 Mason 0 the other week.

 

[deluded pom?]

Yeah i seen that he scored im not stupid, but the score still stands at O'Meley 1 Gilmour 0. I didn't see people complaining about the score at Kidwell 1 Mason 0 the other week.

matty matty matty, you've shot yourself in the foot AGAIN.The score is Mary 1 Gilmour 4 with Long tacking on the extras :lol:

 

[nqboy]

Yeah i seen that he scored im not stupid...

You sure do a good impression of it.

 

[anjado]

I think he is just in bad form all players go through it especially front rower's .The only one who hasn't for years was Webcke which is why he was the best because he was so consistent every other front rower has gone through bad spells. But Webcke got to the top and stayed there where as no other front rower has for a long time . Fielden has been Great Britain's best forward for 5 years a bit like Morley was he is still a great player.Form is temporary class is permanent

 

[SaintJose]

I heard the Aussies had 5 props in their team today? Personally I didn't notice any.

 

[Sea Eagle Scuba]

You poms really are a laugh. :lol:

 

[Frederick]

And it's morning here you brainless dick.

Get a global perspective, there is life outside the land of the convict you know.

Oooohh this kittens got claws. You shouldn't fire up so much, english - you might accidentally spill some tea all over your jam scones, and then you'll have to go ask the Queen if you can have some of hers, and I don't think she'd like to have to share with you.

 

[mattyg]

I heard the Aussies had 5 props in their team today? Personally I didn't notice any.

What game were you watching then? If you didn't notice Gilmour getting flattened by O'Meley i think its time you made a visit to OPSM.

 

[Frederick]

Fielden is not over-rated, however he did not have a good game tonight. The Aussie pack had it all over GB's IMO, but it was Sean Long's creativity in the halves that won it for GB.

 

[simon says]

I thought the POmmie pack got outplayed and they did well to stick close to us.....our execution out wide was abysmal......we are much better than that,once the passes start to stick we will win easily.

PS.......Willie owned Fielden...

PPS......I love getting called convict.....Id love to have one of you internet heroes say that facing up.I wonder if thats what Fielden said to Willy???......"errr,yerrr a cornvict Willeeeee"......BANG!!!!Lights out.

 

[Hannibal Machin]

I thought the POmmie pack got outplayed and they did well to stick close to us.....our execution out wide was abysmal......we are much better than that,once the passes start to stick we will win easily.

PS.......Willie owned Fielden...

PPS......I love getting called convict.....Id love to have one of you internet heroes say that facing up.I wonder if thats what Fielden said to Willy???......"errr,yerrr a cornvict Willeeeee"......BANG!!!!Lights out.

Silly Tw@t!!

 

[deluded pom?]

You poms really are a laugh. :lol:

This from someone who's location is fortress Brookvale! :lol: :lol: :lol:

 

[Disco]

Fielden would start next to Petro in the Aussie pack

He is in the top 5 props in the game

1.Asotasi
2.J Cayless
3.Petro
4.Fielden
5.Bailey

 

[scottyeel]

Fielden is overrated.

 

[scottyeel]

I thought the POmmie pack got outplayed and they did well to stick close to us.....our execution out wide was abysmal......we are much better than that,once the passes start to stick we will win easily.

PS.......Willie owned Fielden...

PPS......I love getting called convict.....Id love to have one of you internet heroes say that facing up.I wonder if thats what Fielden said to Willy???......"errr,yerrr a cornvict Willeeeee"......BANG!!!!Lights out.

:lol: :lol: :lol:

 

[salivor]

Shrek ? Don't make me laugh . You now have a huge hole in your front row with the retirement of Webcke . Fielden would walk into any NRL front row .

You do realise that the Webcke hasn't played for Qld or Australia since 2004 don't you? The only ones that have to worry about a hole in the front row are the Broncos. Oh and I'm sure he could walk into the front row of the Roosters, they're looking for another ESL hack to partner Beattie and Nutley.