What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Is the Rugby season too long

jbl31649

Juniors
Messages
820
I had crap this morning that was too long...:oops:

I'd like to see only 1 trial match (WCC) included in that. I watched Newie v Sharks last year and will again this year.

Must be hard to play a match that means nothing, then getting injured before the season has even begun. They didn't really play a full pace and this can lead to more unwarranted injuries.

The superleague is even longer, albeit only a handful of clubs are up to standard.

Maybe they could play everyone once then the top 10 go into a pool match, then into knock-out or something.

Who knows so many issues and know one capable of fixing it.
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
69,324
World 9's + All stars Feb
SL/NRL seasons + World GF March-Sept
Oct-Nov Internationals

That's what I'd like to see
 

Teddyboy

First Grade
Messages
6,573
Soccer in England seems to go for about 10 months. Based on that fact the NRL season is not long enough.

Soccer seems to be on all year round with some international comps and friendly's and international club tour's and pre-season:x
 

VictoryFC

Bench
Messages
3,786
The constant never ending Soccer season toll in the UK is mentality draining in my mind.

I don't think there is enough being played. Twice a week year round should be minimum as their bodies can more or less take it, especially with rotation. I think thats part of its success - its relentless. You mention the NFL, and they pride themselves on their short 4-5 month season but I see it the other way around. Short seasons mean that the public goes months without the sport on their radar. NFL doesn't suffer but I dont think they're stronger because of it. Soccer doesn't allow you to take a break, and it doesn't really allow other sports to breathe that much (at least in the regions where its strong). There isn't really a pre season even though its only like 8 weeks long, as there is always some international comp or pre season tours taking place during the "off season". Recently a uefa honcho said that they don't want one weekend in the calendar where there isn't top action taking place.

I think thats one of the reasons why cricket isn't as popular in England as it is here. Its popular no doubt, but it doesn't have that room to breathe that cricket has here. Our winter codes have a fairly long off season.
 

docbrown

Coach
Messages
11,842
people say faking injury is a reason to dislike soccer.i disagree.seriously,people..this delayed dive from the african cup of nations is nothing short of epic
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BJbSxMt7oH8&feature=player_embedded

220px-Oscar_statuette.jpg
 

supercharger

Juniors
Messages
2,008
With the Super League starting on the 3rd of February and the All Star game the next day, do you think for a full contact sport it's to too long a season.Last season Super League started on the 12th of February and the last game being the 4 nations final at Leeds of the 19 of November.
I love the NFL for it's season as it gives you at least a good 4 months rest from the sport to wet your appetite.
I do think the season is too long.but it's not something thats restricted to the NRL and Super League.All sports seasons are too long these days
Baseball should start mid-April and be finished by mid-October at the latest.
Football is a Fall sport.Championships for the College game should be decided by january 1st and mid January for NFL
the NHL season is too long aswell,in fact the Red Sox season was one- third over before game one of last year's Stanley Cup between the Bruins and Canucks.
and the ice conditions in June are generally not the greatest ,which can be a sauce for concern for the players' health
Some guys are playing well over 100 games a year an examle is Duncan Keith in 2010 played 82 Regular season games,7 Olympic and 22 Playoff games for a total of 111 games excluding preseason
 

CC_Roosters

First Grade
Messages
5,221
I dont think its too long, mostly as i miss it as soon as the internationals finish and my anticipation for the next season begins. IF the league went down the NFL/NCAAF route and had a short regular season say 17 weeks, just imagine the intense boredom for 2/3 of the year
 

supercharger

Juniors
Messages
2,008
I dont think its too long, mostly as i miss it as soon as the internationals finish and my anticipation for the next season begins. IF the league went down the NFL/NCAAF route and had a short regular season say 17 weeks, just imagine the intense boredom for 2/3 of the year
We will never be in a position that enables us to have a season like the NFL.But to me it comes down to quality vs quantity a long season means more injuries,fan boredom,
and meaningless games.
 

Wilson1

Juniors
Messages
497
It would be great if there was a foreign league competition of reasonable quality which ran over our summer.
 

ali

Bench
Messages
4,962
RL is struggling a little in the heartlands of England at the moment. A lot however is down to the state of the British economy which is badly struggling, aprticularly outside of London. If Super League crowds can come in close to an average record in 2012 then that will be a very good result. The current situation in the north is very different to 5 or 6 years ago when it was far more awash with cash during a credit fuelled boom.

It's true Manchester is not a RL city, which has always baffled me as it is directly surrounded by heartland towns such as Wigan, St Helens, Salford, Warrington and Widnes. Hopefully the relocation of Milenium Magic to Manchester from this year will help the city become a little more RL centic. Leeds however, is a city where RL is king. RL is very much equally as popular as in Sydney, and you regularly see people wearing all sorts of jerseys around the streets including NRL teams and jerseys of the surrounding RL towns such as Castleford, Halifax, Wakefield, Bradford, Huddersfield etc.

One of the big problems in England is a lack of coverage in the media. Despite RL regularly getting attendances and TV ratings the equal or better than Rugby Union, the media coverage is rediculously biased in favour of Union. This is probably due to the media being mostly controlled by the middle to upper class, whose game of choice has always been Union. Even in RL heartlands such as Yorkshire (the county Leeds sits in), there is no shortage of middle class towns where Union is the game of choice. Similarly Union dominates the better schools as well, no matter where you are in the country.

The RFL for all it's criticism, isn't doing a bad job on a few fronts. They have dramatically increased the number of schools playing the game. This is shown in the huge rates of growth for schools taking part in the Champions Schools knockout tournament. A lot of these schools are from non traditional areas.

Further to that, backed by around £30 million in Sport England funding, the RFL has agressively expanded the game in the midlands (think Birmingham and surrounds), London and surrounding areas and into the South West (Bristol and surrounds). In all these areas a number of new clubs have sprung up in recent years meaning there are now decent senior leagues in most corners of the country and some ever growing pockets of junior development. Combining this with the large increase in schools playing the game and some strong deveopment in Universities over recent years, means there will be quite a few non northern raised English RL players emerging at the top level over the next decade. We've already seen a few such as the Griffin brothers, Tony Clubb, Louis MS and Bryan Carney. But I have no doubt this is just the tip of the iceberg. Krasniqi and Dixon at London Broncos are two to watch for 2012!

The next step in the RFL's plan is 4 new expansion clubs joining national league 2 (the third and bottom level of the professional game) from 2013. Northampton (a staunch Union town in the southern part of the midlands) has already been announced as joining, with 3 new clubs to be annouced in the coming months. Those rumoured to be in the mix include Coventry, Bristol, Medway and Hemel. It will be very interesting to see how this experiment goes, as you will be adding 4 teams with little support (especially away from home) to a league used to having plenty of Lancashire and Yorkshire local derbies. Crowds and income for the established teams will take a hit, with travel costs rising. Hopefully the new and old teams will thrive, but I expect some major hiccups. The best case will be two to three of these teams thrive, with one climing the ladder to Super League, but I'm not holding out massive hopes. At least these expansion teams are backed by fairly robust local amatuer scenes unlike RFL expansion in the past, which has very much been top down.
 

VictoryFC

Bench
Messages
3,786
We will never be in a position that enables us to have a season like the NFL.But to me it comes down to quality vs quantity a long season means more injuries,fan boredom,
and meaningless games.

Injuries aplenty in the NFL, and when they do come, they can ruin teams entire seasons. There are more season affecting injuries in the NFL than in any other league, partly because the season is so short.

Fan boredom? Does anyone actually have evidence for this, or are they just assuming that fans get bored? I haven't seen any evidence of apathy.

Meaningless games. Sure, I guess. But people still attend and watch long season leagues, and the media still reports. Not sure theres anything wrong with that.
 

Valheru

Coach
Messages
19,079
I don’t think the NRL season is to long although the addition of a couple more teams will minimise the amount of games played twice in a season.

The super-league season is way too long and needs to be reduced by 6 weeks at least.
 

Kirky

Juniors
Messages
255
I Find myself in two minds about this issue. On the one hand, yes, towards the end of the regular NRL season there are a lot of pointless games between teams with zero chance of making the finals (though some of these can often prove to be closer and more exciting than games between finals contendors lol), and the longer the season goes, the greater the chance of soft tissue injury to our stars.

But damnit, i've been going insane in the off season. I hate when there's no league. The more the better. I love the addition of the All Stars game, I love the fact that Internationals are now competitve, making the post season more bearable. I'd love more rep games in the summer (Best NSW club players Vs Best QLD, Vic and NZ club players for example). Anything that makes these few summer months bearable.
 

Latest posts

Top