- Messages
- 20,104
That would give us the third best defence based on this year. Better then Melbourne.As long as we can get our points conceded per game under 18, we will be in a lot more matches next season then we were this season.
That would give us the third best defence based on this year. Better then Melbourne.As long as we can get our points conceded per game under 18, we will be in a lot more matches next season then we were this season.
Well a new coach and fresh start will help.That sounds like a Brthurism.
I’m kind of with Gronk that while defence was shit under BA, you can’t absolve the players of wearing some blame. Whilst there’s a simple response to fixing a lot of our defensive issues, it’s not a simple course of action to fix it. I hope they can and I think the players we’re moving on and bringing in indicate we’re going to focus more on mobility, that’ll mean that certain players who maybe focus more on the attacking side will have less spots available if they don’t equally fix up their defence/attitude, which is what I think Gronk meant.
Let’s not beat around the bush, Ryles/Moa need to fix problems with Paulo, Matto, Lano & Greigo for us to see real improvement. What’s the likelihood they can?
*methNo, you're just made of glass. Harden up merkin. Same pack + 1. You do the math.
The team wasn’t shit this year, it underperformed. If it performs to standard next year (and has average luck with injuries/suspensions) it should comfortably finish mid-table, just like in 2023.Well if you read my initial post i said realistically i think we will finish around 12th with the surgery Ryles has done with the roster. With the experience lost and the young kids being brought in it will bring inconsistency.
You do the math that's 3 spots above where we finished this year.
I never said Ryles would have us in the top 4 next year if he does how good and his a genius.
If injuries don't hit and we stay injury free we have the potential to push for a top 6 spot because there isn't much between 6th-12th in most seasons.
Sometimes its just down to the close games and how many of those you win.
Defence can be fixed pretty easily attitude and effort. That's what i want to see and will be keeping my eyes on.
Your kidding yourself if you think we showed consistent defensive grit and attitude during much of BA's tenure we finished bottom 4 in defence in 4 out of the 11 years under BA.
A lot of RCG’s attacking output will be covered by Lomax, with the rest split between Paulo and the other forwards. Jack Williams is a better defender than RCG in the modern game.lol minus our best forward of course.
Then it is clearly a mistake to let Gutho go and not replace him with a suitable option for 2025.If Gutho sticks around its a game changer for next year. As we have an elite backup to cover every position in the backline for any injury.
And i would be more confident of us making a push for finals with full availability across our top 6 or 7 players.
But going off gut feel i don't think that Gutho will be here next year.
I agree that Ryles is doing good things but just because he is, doesn’t mean others will. We’ve seen it in the past when sometimes bad things happen, we decide it’s all a bit too tough for us. I think there’s a good chance that the prospect of Stevie’s rumoured preseason may not appeal to some players.Well a new coach and fresh start will help.
Its a new era and will bring fresh excitement.
We have been stale and stagnant for a long time and the players/coaches all got too comfortable under the previous regime.
@Stevie said the pre-season schedule will be different this year and a lot tougher.
So for starters i expect our players will be fitter next year which will help have us have less fatigue and should mean our defence is better then what it has been with better commitment and attitude.
Matto's problem is getting him on the park most weeks. The bloke misses on average 6 games per year with injury. It hasnt been anything to do with ability.
I could’ve sworn that somewhere in the 300 posts about it being the end of civilisation and you never ever going to post again and swearing that was the last post you were going to do, you posted that you were never coming back.I never said I was leaving the forum.
Not that I'm aware of.I could’ve sworn that somewhere in the 300 posts about it being the end of civilisation and you never ever going to post again and swearing that was the last post you were going to do, you posted that you were never coming back.
Just like CiraldoI agree that Ryles is doing good things but just because he is, doesn’t mean others will. We’ve seen it in the past when sometimes bad things happen, we decide it’s all a bit too tough for us. I think there’s a good chance that the prospect of Stevie’s rumoured preseason may not appeal to some players.
Nice insight. BA and his crew basically had no f**king idea how to consistently defend. The last two years were an abomination which tells me that he should have been sacked after the lucky GF appearance.I want to see improvement in defence what we do in attack is basically irrelevant.
History is a big indicator and unless your Top 4 in defence then 80% chance you won't be winning the comp.
You get the defence sorted your are well on your way to winning a premiership.
Look at the Roosters & Manly this year awesome in attack but come finals time they got swallowed up and flogged because of there shit defence. What they had in attack was redundant in the end.
Since 1998 the two seasons 2005 & 2001 were the years teams who won the comp weren't in the top 8 in defence. Ironically that was also the years we were ranked 1st.
Brian Smith had us consistently in top 4 in defence for majority of his tenure and while we didn't win a comp we were certainly in with a shot by making it to the preliminary final on a regular basis.
Year Premiers Rank in Defence Parramatta Rank 2024 1st - Penrith 16th 2023 1st - Penrith 11th 2022 1st - Penrith 8th 2021 1st - Penrith 4th 2020 2nd - Melbourne 3rd 2019 2nd - Sydney Roosters 7th 2018 1st - Sydney Roosters 13th 2017 1st - Melbourne 8th 2016 3rd - Cronulla 5th 2015 5th - North Queensland 13th 2014 1st - Souths 13th 2013 1st - Sydney Roosters 16th 2012 1st - Melbourne 16th 2011 2nd - Manly 12th 2010 1st - St George Illawarra 5th 2009 2nd - Melbourne 6th 2008 2nd - Manly 9th 2007 1st - Melbourne 7th 2006 1st - Brisbane 7th 2005 10th - Wests Tigers 1st 2004 3rd - Canterbury 11th 2003 7th - Penrith 8th 2002 1st - Sydney Roosters 4th 2001 9th - Newcastle 1st 2000 1st - Brisbane 2nd 1999 5th - Melbourne 1st 1998 1st - Brisbane 2nd
Agree, with the halves we have we should always be top 8. Next year is a consolidation year for us I reckon so bottom of top 8 with an expected top 4 finish for 2026 as the young fellas in the squad develop experience and learn the systems put in place. These systems should filter down to the lower grades as well so continuity throughout all grades.I think we're a top 8 side.....and if we don't make the 8, Rylesy will feel my WRATH...
Which is what I believe Gronk was attempting (hamfistedly) to say.Just like Ciraldo
Ryles will weed out the soft cocks very quickly.
Ciraldo had Dogs top 4 defence within 2 years.
That should be goal for Ryles & Moa.
Next year is the transitional year to set things up.
Hopefully we jump up out of the blocks and the rebuild is quicker then we anticipate.
The injury was a blessing because BA would have stuck around like Robbie Farah at the tigers.I think people forget that Moses played 3 games, got injured and our season was over.
If Gutho sticks around, Moses plays every game, we should at a minimum make the Top 8.
Not denying that it had its long term benefits.The injury was a blessing because BA would have stuck around like Robbie Farah at the tigers.
That’s like saying that turd doesn’t stink, it’s just brown.The team wasn’t shit this year, it underperformed. If it performs to standard next year (and has average luck with injuries/suspensions) it should comfortably finish mid-table, just like in 2023.