Quite frankly if you take away the first 8 games last year I cant say his influence on the field has been worth the rather large pay packet he must be taking home.
Some of the best football this team has played in the past two seasons have been on exhibition in the last two games ... and guess what, there was no J.Smith to be seen.
There is no doubt in my mind that he has played one season too many and that we should have been looking to giving youngsters with talent the experience in FG that they can only get from being there.
The likes of Carney, Zillman and Herbert, not to mention Dobson, need to be given all the support necessary to assist in confidence building that will eventually accompany the undoubted talents they have.
At the moment we have a coach that is hell bent on proving the critics such as myself wrong. I can remember early 2005 when we had a run of good form with Smith and Withers running the show ... Elliott mentioned at the press conference how these two were proving the critics wrong ... well quite frankly I think we were correct.