Judic Rd24

[JessEel]

 

[eloquentEEL]

can this thread please be renamed "Jokedic Rd24"

 

[Belly in Brisvegas]

The NRL are having a laugh with the Mason one.

 

[mickdo]

7 points over :lol: I see what you mean!

 

[strider]

let me in on the joke - i don't get it

 

[eloquentEEL]

let me in on the joke - i don't get it

his existing carryover points make it just enough to keep him out for 2 matches

 

[Belly in Brisvegas]

It is the grading of Careless that has me rolling around on the floor!!

If that wasn't as bad a Fui's (or bad enough to be classed as reckless) I'll eat the chair I'm sitting on.

 

[Maroubra Eel]

Don't know how the two Cowboys got away with the dangerous lifting tackle.

 

[Maroubra Eel]

If they like you its careless.

Otherwise its reckless.

 

[eloquentEEL]

It is the grading of Careless that has me rolling around on the floor!!

If that wasn't as bad a Fui's (or bad enough to be classed as reckless) I'll eat the chair I'm sitting on.

then you better strap yourself down if you're yet to notice the complete absense of one Mr Schillington from the charge sheet

 

[eloquentEEL]

Don't know how the two Cowboys got away with the dangerous lifting tackle.

the one and half flip with a half twist? it probably helped their cause that he didn't end up in the pike position

 

[Bazal]

Well isn't that a joke! Shillingtons hit was worse than Masons, yet he isn't charged? Even when they are running near last the Roosters can influence the jokediciary it seems...

 

[strider]

his existing carryover points make it just enough to keep him out for 2 matches

ohhhh - do they add the 67 to the 140? - i thought the 140 was after the 67 was included

willie pretty much watched his arm onto the guy's chin .... i don't think he connected properly tho ... obviously the grade is all about how many medicabs and doctors run out on the field

 

[El Diablo]

Well isn't that a joke! Shillingtons hit was worse than Masons, yet he isn't charged? Even when they are running near last the Roosters can influence the jokediciary it seems...

and he had Morro doing the Berbick shuffle. It was clearly high and the commentators thought he was lucky not to be sent off.

 

[Freak2]

Well everyone now who gets charged with a high tackle charge shuold now plead not guilty and use evidence from the Shilington's shot as their defence.

Sets a massive precedent!! And cannot be looked upon lightly!

The hit was a shocker. IMO, not a send off but a severe grading and some time on the sideline was more than worthy.

UNBELIEVABLE OBMISSION!!

 

[eelsrocks]

Is there any reason given for the no charges?

 

[mickdo]

The thing I find amazing about Shillington's is that is was placed on report, so there is no way the MRC can have missed it. Maybe they are just taking pity on the Rorters because they have just lost Lewis and Harrison for the season anyway, not that it should be any excuse.

 

[El Diablo]

Fui should seek leave to appeal and use the footage

 

[Belly in Brisvegas]

then you better strap yourself down if you're yet to notice the complete absense of one Mr Schillington from the charge sheet

Fudge me...how could I have missed that...I suppose my eyes clouded over when I saw what Mason is up for.

That will do me.

 

[parra pete]

I want Mason to play in the Bulldogs next two games. They need to win both to further the Eels cause....(Am I selfish????)