Judiciary Charges 2019

[Lebbo73]

Hahahahaha.

Just f**king lolol at the NRL....
McGuire pays a few fines for worse , now is looking at 4 weeks for less.

Maybe if these fools had an ounce of credibility around SOO time, this could have been avoided.

Consistency, as always, is over-rated

I didn’t even think that last nights effort was an eye gouge. It looked like he just grubbed it up by pushing his head into the ground.

 

[Someguy]

wrong thread

 

[gerg]

I thought I saw something live so I just went and rewatched it. At 47.15 McGuire and Lodge had a bit of a tustle and McGuire, again, has his fingers near Lodge's eyes. Why isn't the MRC looking at that one as well?

Edit.... If you freeze it at exactly 47.20 you can see it, but I don't know how to copy a freeze frame.

 

[Maximus]

Penrith about to get a view to next year. It will be glorious

Yep future is bright.

 

[League Unlimited News]

 

[Knuckle-dragger]

 

[League Unlimited News]

Josh McGuire (Cowboys)
9th minute, Grade 2 Contrary Conduct on David Fifita
Base penalty 200 points
2 x similar prior offences last 2 years (2 x 50% loading)
1 x non-similar prior offence last 2 years (20% loading)
5 carryover points to add
Guilty / no contest 440+5=445 points (4 matches)
Early guilty plea 330+5=335 points (3 matches)
PLEA: TBC
OUTCOME: TBC

Ronaldo Mulitalo (Sharks)
69th minute, Grade 1 Contrary Conduct on Josh Mansour
Base penalty $1500 fine
Guilty / no contest $1500 fine
Early guilty plea $1150 fine
PLEA: TBC
OUTCOME: TBC

Brian Kelly (Titans)
31st minute, Grade 1 Dangerous Throw on Patrick Kaufusi
Base penalty 100 points
Guilty / no contest 100 points (1 match)
Early guilty plea 75 points (0 matches)
PLEA: TBC
OUTCOME: TBC

Tyrone Peachey (Titans)
44th minute, Grade 1 Careless High Tackle on Korbin Sims
Base penalty $1500 fine
Guilty / no contest $1500 fine
Early guilty plea $1150 fine
PLEA: TBC
OUTCOME: TBC

Luke Garner (Wests Tigers)
23rd minute, Grade 1 Dangerous Contact (other) on Lachlan Lewis
Base penalty 100pts
1 x non-similar prior offence last 2 years (20% loading)
35 carryover points to add
Guilty / no contest 120+35=155 points (1 match)
Early guilty plea 90+35=125 points (1 match)
PLEA: TBC
OUTCOME: TBC

Chris Smith (Bulldogs)
77th minute, Grade 1 Dangerous Contact (other) on Ryan Matterson
Base penalty 100 points
Guilty / no contest 100 points (1 match)
Early guilty plea 75 points (0 matches)
PLEA: TBC
OUTCOME: TBC

Elliott Whitehead (Raiders)
28th minute, Grade 1 Dangerous Contact (other) on Joseph Manu
Base penalty 100 points
Guilty / no contest 100 points (1 match)
Early guilty plea 75 points (0 matches)
PLEA: TBC
OUTCOME: TBC

Monday's Expert - https://leagueunlimited.com/news/33901-mondays-expert-round-21-wrap/

 

[azza29]

Base penalty 200 points
2 x similar prior offences last 2 years (2 x 50% loading)
1 x non-similar prior offence last 2 years (20% loading)
5 carryover points to add
Guilty / no contest 400+5=405 points (4 matches)
Early guilty plea 330+5=335 points (3 matches)

I'm confused by the maths on this.
200 point base charge
50% loading x 2 for similar priors = 200 (50% of 200 points, multiply by 2)
20% loading for non-similar prior = 40 (20% of 200 points)
5 carryover

Comes to 445 for me? Or does some other rule come into play?

 

[Cockadoodledoo]

I'm confused by the maths on this.
200 point base charge
50% loading x 2 for similar priors = 200 (50% of 200 points, multiply by 2)
20% loading for non-similar prior = 40 (20% of 200 points)
5 carryover

Comes to 445 for me? Or does some other rule come into play?

It's the NRL.

 

[Timmah]

I'm confused by the maths on this.
200 point base charge
50% loading x 2 for similar priors = 200 (50% of 200 points, multiply by 2)
20% loading for non-similar prior = 40 (20% of 200 points)
5 carryover

Comes to 445 for me? Or does some other rule come into play?

Corrected.

 

[Surely]

So you get a week.for licking the ear of a half or a fine for knocking one out.

 

[Captain Apollo]

Luke Garner is off to the judiciary. Pleading not guilty.

Josh McGuire has plead guilty and won't try to get the charge downgraded.

Source: https://www.nrl.com/news/2019/08/09/round-21-charges-josh-mcguire-facing-four-week-ban/

 

[League Unlimited News]

Updated pleas:

Josh McGuire (Cowboys)
9th minute, Grade 2 Contrary Conduct on David Fifita
Base penalty 200 points
2 x similar prior offences last 2 years (2 x 50% loading)
1 x non-similar prior offence last 2 years (20% loading)
5 carryover points to add
Guilty / no contest 440+5=445 points (4 matches)
Early guilty plea 330+5=335 points (3 matches)
PLEA: Guilty - early plea
OUTCOME: Suspended 3 matches. 35 carryover points accrued.

Ronaldo Mulitalo (Sharks)
69th minute, Grade 1 Contrary Conduct on Josh Mansour
Base penalty $1500 fine
Guilty / no contest $1500 fine
Early guilty plea $1150 fine
PLEA: TBC
OUTCOME: TBC

Brian Kelly (Titans)
31st minute, Grade 1 Dangerous Throw on Patrick Kaufusi
Base penalty 100 points
Guilty / no contest 100 points (1 match)
Early guilty plea 75 points (0 matches)
PLEA: Guilty - early plea
OUTCOME: No suspension. 75 carryover points accrued.

Tyrone Peachey (Titans)
44th minute, Grade 1 Careless High Tackle on Korbin Sims
Base penalty $1500 fine
Guilty / no contest $1500 fine
Early guilty plea $1150 fine
PLEA: Guilty - early plea
OUTCOME: $1150 fine.

Luke Garner (Wests Tigers)
23rd minute, Grade 1 Dangerous Contact (other) on Lachlan Lewis
Base penalty 100pts
1 x non-similar prior offence last 2 years (20% loading)
35 carryover points to add
Guilty / no contest 120+35=155 points (1 match)
Early guilty plea 90+35=125 points (1 match)
PLEA: Not guilty. To face judiciary Tuesday night.
OUTCOME: TBC

Chris Smith (Bulldogs)
77th minute, Grade 1 Dangerous Contact (other) on Ryan Matterson
Base penalty 100 points
Guilty / no contest 100 points (1 match)
Early guilty plea 75 points (0 matches)
PLEA: Guilty - early plea
OUTCOME: No suspension, 75 carryover points accrued.

Elliott Whitehead (Raiders)
28th minute, Grade 1 Dangerous Contact (other) on Joseph Manu
Base penalty 100 points
Guilty / no contest 100 points (1 match)
Early guilty plea 75 points (0 matches)
PLEA: TBC
OUTCOME: TBC

https://leagueunlimited.com/news/33901-mondays-expert-round-21-wrap/

 

[Wayne's World]

Why would teams coming 15th and 16th let player's take 75 carryover points for?
May as well fight it, if they lose they miss a week and no carryover points which will go into next year.

 

[League Unlimited News]

Last two pleas are in with Mulitalo ($1150 fine) and Whitehead (0 matches, 75 CO points accrued) both taking the early guilty plea.

Garner faces the judiciary tonight.

https://leagueunlimited.com/news/33901-mondays-expert-round-21-wrap/

 

[Vic Mackey]

Garner suspended. End yourself NRL

 

[lockyno1]

Garner suspended. End yourself NRL

Was never ever going to get off. Beyond dumb even going to the judiciary.

 

[JB04]

Yet Sam Burgess gets off after decapitating Moylan. This really shits me to tears

 

[joel caine number 1 fan]

Garner suspended. End yourself NRL

I don’t expect anything less from the nrl the game has got so bad as of late is nearly unwatchable
It’s becoming a chore now days to even watch a tigers game

 

[Vic Mackey]

Was never ever going to get off. Beyond dumb even going to the judiciary.

Was getting a week either way