The Game Judiciary & Match Review charges - 2022 season

[soc123_au]

Now Taylan May should really have been sitting down anyway, but based on on field charges how he is suspended and Milne isn’t beggars belief.

 

[yobbo84]

Milne's was 10x worse than Burgess'. The charges should be the other way around.

The MRC clearly get affected by who is fouled.

 

[mave]

Lmao.
JWH finally cops a suspension instead of the usual fine, conveniently now the Roosters are finished for the year.

MRC roulette.

 

[lockyno1]

Milne's was 10x worse than Burgess'. The charges should be the other way around.

The MRC clearly get affected by who is fouled.

Just be thankful Paulo won’t be playing

 

[Babyface O'reilly]

I would. Tedesco was doing his usual 'fall to his knees' at the line trick.

If he loses, he potentially misses a GF - but even if we get past the Sharks there's absolutely no way Souths forwards can win vs Penrith without him, so it's worth the risk.

He was nowhere near being on his knees when contact was made

 

[SLRBRONCOS]

Teddy has an extremely odd running style - he kinda does the opposite to what my old schoolboy AIS coach would want, where he often has his torso almost parallel with the ground rather than upright and straight. Sometimes defenders need to go so low to avoid his head that they end up getting done for a swinging arm if they misjudge it.

If he just kept a good sprinting posture he would be hit in the face less. Not trying to victim blame the guy, but if I were him I'd work with a new sprinting coach.

 

[Munky]

Teddy has an extremely odd running style - he kinda does the opposite to what my old schoolboy AIS coach would want, where he often has his torso almost parallel with the ground rather than upright and straight. Sometimes defenders need to go so low to avoid his head that they end up getting done for a swinging arm if they misjudge it.

If he just kept a good sprinting posture he would be hit in the face less. Not trying to victim blame the guy, but if I were him I'd work with a new sprinting coach.

I thought the issue was after he did his knee in his first game he wears less grippy studs so now falls over a lot shifting his momentum?

 

[Babyface O'reilly]

Teddy has an extremely odd running style - he kinda does the opposite to what my old schoolboy AIS coach would want, where he often has his torso almost parallel with the ground rather than upright and straight. Sometimes defenders need to go so low to avoid his head that they end up getting done for a swinging arm if they misjudge it.

If he just kept a good sprinting posture he would be hit in the face less. Not trying to victim blame the guy, but if I were him I'd work with a new sprinting coach.

But he darts quickly left and right, putting his body at an angle which naturally lowers his head, doesn’t it? It’s definitely difficult for the defender, though.

 

[Mr. Shaman]

Burgess getting what is deserved, Milne not getting enough.

 

[Maximus]

With the "personal deterrent" charge that Annesley was talking about a couple of weeks ago, does that mean JWH should get a minimum of grade 2 any time he is charged next year?

 

[SLRBRONCOS]

I thought the issue was after he did his knee in his first game he wears less grippy studs so now falls over a lot shifting his momentum?

But he darts quickly left and right, putting his body at an angle which naturally lowers his head, doesn’t it? It’s definitely difficult for the defender, though.

I think his lower centre of gravity has something to do with it too, he knows if he keeps low he is more likely to break the line but he has the same posture in a straight line, Papz is similar but straightens up after the first few strides

 

[The Lounge Lizard]

Teddy has an extremely odd running style.

Tedesco has the shortest running stride in NRL history.

He appears to be running barefoot over broken glass.

 

[Captain Apollo]

 

[GongPanther]

Teddy has an extremely odd running style - he kinda does the opposite to what my old schoolboy AIS coach would want, where he often has his torso almost parallel with the ground rather than upright and straight. Sometimes defenders need to go so low to avoid his head that they end up getting done for a swinging arm if they misjudge it.

If he just kept a good sprinting posture he would be hit in the face less. Not trying to victim blame the guy, but if I were him I'd work with a new sprinting coach.

Teddy runs low to the ground with exposing less of his body mass to tackle.

 

[blue bags]

Maybe post pone the suspension until 2024 when he is in super league

 

[Apey]

If Tom Burgess gets a downgrade, Tariq Sims should feel really hard done by. His tackle on Connor Tracey had similar action to Burgess.

I am confused how Milne was only a grade one. He jumps up, swings his arm, and collects a taller player high.

Yeah but who did Milne hit? It wasn't Teddy.

 

[Valheru]

I would. Tedesco was doing his usual 'fall to his knees' at the line trick.

If he loses, he potentially misses a GF - but even if we get past the Sharks there's absolutely no way Souths forwards can win vs Penrith without him, so it's worth the risk.

I hope for your sake souths have a better defence than that because he actually wasn't falling. He runs low and compact but his height didn't change from the moment burgess started his action and the result was teddy out of the game.

There is absolutely 0 chance he gets a downgrade on that argument. The better bet is to find some other tackle that was similar and only got a grade 1 which given the "consistency" of the NRL, I am sure there are many.

 

[Valheru]

He was nowhere near being on his knees when contact was made
View attachment 66101

And he was in no way falling.

 

[Valheru]

Yeah but who did Milne hit? It wasn't Teddy.

I think it is more the result.

If sualli left the field for the game Milne would have got the book thrown at him.

It is still ridiculous he isn't missing any games.

 

[Babyface O'reilly]

I hope for your sake souths have a better defence than that because he actually wasn't falling. He runs low and compact but his height didn't change from the moment burgess started his action and the result was teddy out of the game.

There is absolutely 0 chance he gets a downgrade on that argument. The better bet is to find some other tackle that was similar and only got a grade 1 which given the "consistency" of the NRL, I am sure there are many.

I thought precedents can’t be used in defence anymore or is there a precedent for revisiting precedents lol