Judiciary

[2010Dragons]

Dragons are the usual whipping boys team by the match review committee idiots. Hook is too soft at the media conference. We get really dodge bad calls and hook never arch up. Ever other coach is happy to arch up and spend $10,000.00
Our captain never questions any calls and just rolls his eyes and waves his arms up in the air. Cherry evens, cleary, tedisco questions all bad calls on the field.
Dragons have a soft polite coach and soft captain the referees just walk all over.
Hook and Hunt need to go to Bunnings and buy bags of quick set cement then drink it and then harden the f**k up.
Referees have one rule for the top teams and one scam rules for the soft cock coach’s and captain. Respect is not given it must be earn. Squeaky doors always get the most oil. Start complaining you bunch of soft cocks imposter leaders.

 

[charlesv]

bet you didn't see that coming

I SURE DID its a given good old Uncle Nick at work lol

 

[St Tangles]

To be honest there wasn't much in any of the Roosters ones this weekend

We wouldn't be happy if any of our players were suspended for any of these

The 2 that should of been suspended from the weekend are Nathan Cleary and Kafusi

 

[BLM01]

To be honest there wasn't much in any of the Roosters ones this weekend

We wouldn't be happy if any of our players were suspended for any of these

The 2 that should of been suspended from the weekend are Nathan Cleary and Kafusi

Yes in reference to the judcial process namely MRC and Luke Patten who is in charge and the inevitable bias or inconsistency
It is funny how some clubs
Bulldogs & Penrith had their 1st charge fine this weekend . (How TPJ has escaped anything is beyond me)
Manly, Canberra and Roosters have not been charged or fined from games R1 - R6.
Yes people say we are more ill disciplined but somehow our hits and high shots are harder (force) than anyone else.

 

[St Tangles]

Yes in reference to the judcial process namely MRC and Luke Patten who is in charge and the inevitable bias or inconsistency
It is funny how some clubs
Bulldogs & Penrith had their 1st charge fine this weekend . (How TPJ has escaped anything is beyond me)
Manly, Canberra and Roosters have not been charged or fined from games R1 - R6.
Yes people say we are more ill disciplined but somehow our hits and high shots are harder (force) than anyone else.

I agree with what you say

We are an easy target because we don't complain

 

[BLM01]

I agree with what you say

We are an easy target because we don't complain

Yes maybe, but we are not the only easy targets. There is a theme going on here.

 

[St Tangles]

Yes maybe, but we are not the only easy targets. There is a theme going on here.

Then we as a club need to address it or it will continue

 

[Dragon David]

There is just no consistency in rulings other than being consistent by not charging players of the "better" clubs the same penalties as the minor clubs for the same wrong doing. The emphasis has been I think on how hard someone is hit. A slap is so much, a thump is another and a whack is something else. It's like a coffee addict. The MRC/Judiciary charges are like an addict of coffee ordering either small, medium or large depends on how much "kick" they want to hand out.

They like to be seen to be applying jurisprudence by hitting some minor clubs' players harder so it looks like they are doing their job.

They have some agenda in place I feel sure.

Our club should make a stand if there is any sign of bias.

 

[Lindsay Moss]

To be honest there wasn't much in any of the Roosters ones this weekend

We wouldn't be happy if any of our players were suspended for any of these

The 2 that should of been suspended from the weekend are Nathan Cleary and Kafusi

Could not believe Cleary just got fined for his tackle absolute joke but par for the course with bunch.

 

[BLM01]

Then we as a club need to address it or it will continue

I dont know how or you can!.
Annesley just comes on as says the MRC are independant..blah blah....
They spend a certain amount of time reviewing games..blah blah
They look at all angles..blah, look at degree of force..blah
Have their systems..blah
End of the day it is their so called educated time spent opinion against the world, even the NRL cant step in.
Why do you think minimal clubs fight it at the judiciary?..except Roosters

 

[Gareth67]

We all know that it has become a sham - the monetary penalties imposed upon some clubs are ridiculous and the judiciary itself is absolutely shameful .

The top-of-the-tree clubs are receiving $1000 or $1500 fines whereas the lesser lights of the competition receive the full brunt of the law - disgusting. Felise Kafusi from the Storm , a renown offender escapes with a $ 1500 fine for a late tackle and in the same game for a crusher tackle and the guy receives a monetary fine . He was either guilty of those illegal tackles or he wasn’t , so the sentence should had been time out off the game .

The judiciary panel requires a complete clean out and in their place individuals who will judge the players that come before them fairly and with equality . Piss Patten off from his cubby hole in the bunker , in fact piss the bunker off itself and place the onus back to where it belongs , to the referees themselves .

End of rant !

 

[Dragon David]

Uncle Nick must be Eliot Ness in disguise as the Roosters are the "Untouchables". The "Untouchables" brandish their shotguns to get whatever and whoever they want. The person they didn't get but we did was Uncle Wayne. They do have a winner though in trendy Trent so they are continuing to have the last laugh.

They also got the Morris boys - "Hi Brett and Josh - play with us because we are the greatest. We will give you some money and in the end you can help us with some of the coaching". They plan well and truly into the future and leave no stone unturned.

 

[jak]

We all know that it has become a sham - the monetary penalties imposed upon some clubs are ridiculous and the judiciary itself is absolutely shameful .

The top-of-the-tree clubs are receiving $1000 or $1500 fines whereas the lesser lights of the competition receive the full brunt of the law - disgusting. Felise Kafusi from the Storm , a renown offender escapes with a $ 1500 fine for a late tackle and in the same game for a crusher tackle and the guy receives a monetary fine . He was either guilty of those illegal tackles or he wasn’t , so the sentence should had been time out off the game .

The judiciary panel requires a complete clean out and in their place individuals who will judge the players that come before them fairly and equality . Piss Patten off from his cubby hole in the bunker , in fact piss the bunker off itself and place the onus back to where it belongs , to the referees themselves .

End of rant !

roosters don't get penalties mate they are sent straight to uncle nick and his judiciary.

 

[SEAT 1A]

I dont know how or you can!.
Annesley just comes on as says the MRC are independant..blah blah....
They spend a certain amount of time reviewing games..blah blah
They look at all angles..blah, look at degree of force..blah
Have their systems..blah
End of the day it is their so called educated time spent opinion against the world, even the NRL cant step in.
Why do you think minimal clubs fight it at the judiciary?..except Roosters

Agree with all of that BLM01.

The NRL can't step in however, they can come out and say the judiciary were wrong. I remember back in the day, ref's were sacked for errors.

 

[Gareth67]

Snapshot from the Sharks / Storm game - how to tackle without breaking your opponent’s neck !

 

[Dragon David]

Snapshot from the Sharks / Storm game - how to tackle without breaking your opponent’s neck !

View attachment 60485View attachment 60485

Why is that guy doing yoga? I thought it was rugby league!

 

[Gareth67]

Why is that guy doing yoga? I thought it was rugby league!

The player’s head is almost at a right-angle , I don’t know whom it’s is but his neck must be thick to absorb so much downward pressure . I hope he went for a scan afterwards and sent the bill to the Storm .

 

[Dragon David]

The player’s head is almost at a right-angle , I don’t whom it’s is but his neck must be thick to absorb so much downward pressure . I hope he went for a scan afterwards and sent the bill to the Storm .

It is scary when you see tackles like this and they occur in almost all games. Some are reckless and careless but some are also accidental and unfortunately cannot be avoided. The players who cop it must think for a fraction of time am I going to be in a wheelchair? and some who cause it must think - am I going to be playing next week? Well that bald headed guy in the purple named Kaufusi will be.

 

[Gareth67]

It is scary when you see tackles like this and they occur in almost all games. Some are reckless and careless but some are also accidental and unfortunately cannot be avoided. The players who cop it must think for a fraction of time am I going to be in a wheelchair? and some who cause it must think - am I going to be playing next week? Well that bald headed guy in the purple named Kaufusi will be.

Alex McKinnon must had had the same exact thought .

 

[getsmarty]

Not Found | Fox Sports Videos

www.foxsports.com.au

Wonder if this will even get a mention..let alone the JWH tackle.