Looking at other teams forwards especially props

[Rabbits20]

I am going to compare them with Clark, Tyrrell and Turner.

 

[Rabbits20]

Dogs:

Tolman
Graham
Klemmer
Jackson
Kasiano

Storm:

Bromwich
McLean
Finucane
Asofa Solomona
Glasby

Cronulla:

Fifita
Gallen
Lewis
Prior
Heighington

Brisbane:

McGuire
Sims
Gillett
Blair
Pangai Junior

 

[Rabbits20]

Compare that with:

Musgrove
Tyrrell
Turner
Sam
Clark

Fug me. Look at the comparisons.

I will continue with other teams too.

 

[Rabbits20]

Dragons:

Vaughan
Packer
De Belin
Frizell
Ah Mau

Penrith:

Tamou
RCG
Merrill
Cartwright
Latu

Cowboys:

Bolton
Scott
Taumalolo
Lowe
Asiata

Raiders:

Boyd
Paulo
Papalii
Bateman
Tapine

 

[Rabbits20]

Titans:

James
J. Wallace
Pulu
Proctor
Paasi

Roosters:

Napa
Hargreaves
Guerra
Cordner
Evans


Warriors:

Vete
Gubb
Mannering
R. Hoffman
Lillyman

Eels:

Mannah
Matagi
Moeroa
N. Brown
F. Pritchard

 

[DiegoNT]

Compare them with the twins.
That's where all our money is tied up.
But of course criticise our 200k a year players for playing like 200k a year players.
The the burgii cost more then most packs. Let's compare them to everyone elses middle 3 on current form

Tamoulolo, Scott, Bolton > burgii
Blair, McGuire, Thaiday > burgii
James, Wallace, paasi > burgii
Boyd, paulo, soliola > burgii
Vaughan, packer, de belin ,> burgii
Tolman, Graham, Klemmer > burgii
Fifita, prior, gallen > burgii
McLean, Bromwich, glasby > burgii
Napa, jwh, Guerra > burgii
Tamou, rcg, merrin > burgii
Woods, suama-whatever, Taylor > burgii
Mataulino, Gubb, mannering = burgii
Matagi, mannah, Scott > burgii
Tapau, Lawrence, trbovjtch > burgii
Safiti, starling Barnett ,< burgii

The knights are the only ones who would legitimatly swap their middle 3 for ours yet ours is possibly the highest paid

 

[Pommy]

Have to agree with Diego why compare them with squad players when we've got high earners on the bench and at norths?

 

[Rabbits20]

I'm getting bad asthma as I type in this thread.

I'm appalled how we've ended up like this!!!

Shadow where are you mate!!!

I'm starting to burn up!!!!!!

 

[Rabbits20]

12 teams have superior packs to us plus the Tigers are fast.

That places us in f**king 14th.

I believe we are equal with Manly with our pack and better than the Knights.

Fug me.

I didn't make this thread up to read your trash either Diego.

I made this thread up as it speaks truth for itself!!!!!!!!!

 

[Rsag85]

Compare that with:

Musgrove
Tyrrell
Turner
Sam
Clark

Fug me. Look at the comparisons.

I will continue with other teams too.

Four premiership winning forwards and one rookie

 

[Rabbits20]

So are we all happy settling for 14th?????

That's about where we will be unless Madge makes changes.

I'm quite frankly tbh embarrassed. How the hell did things turn bad again!!!!!!!!!

Where are you alien.........

Cmon Shadow join in mate and tell me what you think of the other 12-13 teams forwards compared to ours!!!! I am fired up!!!!!!!!!

 

[Pommy]

12 teams have superior packs to us plus the Tigers are fast.

That places us in f**king 14th.

I believe we are equal with Manly with our pack and better than the Knights.

Fug me.

I didn't make this thread up to read your trash either Diego.

I made this thread up as it speaks truth for itself!!!!!!!!!

Deep breaths, nobody is trying to insult you.
I have said before the only reason I support this fine club is because of the brothers but if your going to criticise our forwards how can you leave out the twins who are stealing a living. The real issue we have is that back up players are having to play ahead of our supposed first team as their in awful awful form.

 

[Rabbits20]

Four premiership winning forwards and one rookie

Stop living in the past!!!!!

They were lucky to get that ring and they've deteriorated quicker than old man since then!!!

Let's be fair dinkum here Rsag. Let's not sugar coat things. Well that is unless you want mediocrity!!!!

We have to stop living in the bloody past and look to the frogging future!!!!!

They way most are looking at it is they don't want to be in the 8 or top 4. They don't want to win 22. They want to persist with a bunch of has beens who we can't put with anymore!!!!!!

 

[Rabbits20]

Can't blame Sam Burgess. He's doing it all himself and if he wasn't there we'd lose by 50.

 

[DiegoNT]

Titans:

James
J. Wallace
Pulu
Proctor
Paasi

Roosters:

Napa
Hargreaves
Guerra
Cordner
Evans


Warriors:

Vete
Gubb
Mannering
R. Hoffman
Lillyman

Eels:

Mannah
Matagi
Moeroa
N. Brown
F. Pritchard

You've named everybody's best/highest paid pack to compare with our Reserve/depth forwards. a more accurate representation would be
Burgess
Burgess
Sutton
Turner
Burgess.

 

[callmack1]

It's not Madge who needs to make changes, it's the twins.

 

[Rsag85]

Stop living in the past!!!!!

They were lucky to get that ring and they've deteriorated quicker than old man since then!!!

Let's be fair dinkum here Rsag. Let's not sugar coat things. Well that is unless you want mediocrity!!!!

We have to stop living in the bloody past and look to the frogging future!!!!!

They way most are looking at it is they don't want to be in the 8 or top 4. They don't want to win 22. They want to persist with a bunch of has beens who we can't put with anymore!!!!!!

No I'm not going crazy and over the top just after one damn game you need to relax our pack isn't that bad as you make it out to be likes of the 3 Burgess boys all internationals. Sutton and rising stars like Angus and Musgrove. Come on serious relax. Madge just needs to get his balance right.

 

[Pommy]

Can't blame Sam Burgess. He's doing it all himself and if he wasn't there we'd lose by 50.

I don't blame Sam we've only seen flashes of his brilliance but he's by no means awful. Even during his worst form last season I wouldn't have dropped him.
I'm shocked George hasn't played more for norths.

 

[DiegoNT]

Can't blame Sam Burgess. He's doing it all himself and if he wasn't there we'd lose by 50.

Why not?
Compared to most locks his workrate is the same.
Compare him to merrin, gallen, McGuire, Jake turbo, de belin, klemmer, mannering etc and they are getting through similar amount of work. So all this 'he does so much work' is malarkey. We are paying Burgess that extra on top of that to provide X Factor and he isn't bringing it consistently like a taumololo can.

 

[Rabbits20]

No I'm not going crazy and over the top just after one damn game you need to relax our pack isn't that bad as you make it out to be likes of the 3 Burgess boys all internationals. Sutton and rising stars like Angus and Musgrove. Come on serious relax. Madge just needs to get his balance right.

It's hard to relax when Madge has the tendency to take to long to make the changes!!!!

I can see him losing his job if this continues.