LU Panthers Forum Player of the Year

[Panfa]

Give a 10 to ivan for stupidity katoa was going so bad in the 1st half yet he waited till the 51st min to put luai on things started to improve for us but the game was all but over when he made the change surely this cant go on for 5yrs.

 

[mxlegend99]

Edwards 1
To'o 1
Whare 1
Blake 1
DWZ 0
Maloney 1
Cleary 1
Tamou 1
Katoa 0
Grant 1
Kikau 2
Fisher-Harris 1
Martin 2

Luai 1
Fuimaiono 1
Leota 0
Ellis 1

When you're allergic to scoring... i feel like those who manage to do so should get something extra even though the whole team was bad. Likewise bombing what should be a try gets a big fat zero.

I dont think a single player can hold their head up and say they did their best after that game. Which makes it our worst game since Elliott was here.

 

[TheFrog]

Round 10 closed, update tomorrow.

 

[TheFrog]

Edwards 6
Mansour 7
Whare 7
Blake 4
To'o 6
Luai 7
Cleary 8
Tamou 7
Katoa 6
Grant 6
Kikau 6
Winterstein 6
Fisher-Harris 6

Campbell-Gillard 7
Fuimaiono 5
Leota 4
Kenny 5

 

[age.s]

Edwards 6
Mansour 6
Blake 5
Whare 6
Too 7
Luai 6
Cleary 8
Tamou 6
Katoa 4
Grant 6
Kikau 6
Winterstein 5
JFH 7

RCG 7
Fuimaono 6
Leota 5
Kenny 6

 

[Flashstep]

Edwards 7
Mansour 7
Whare 6
Blake 5
To’o 8
Luai 5
Cleary 7
Tamou 6
Katoa 4
Grant 6
Kikau 5
Winterstein 5
JFH 6

RCG 7
Fuimiano 5
Leota 5
Kenny 5

 

[Tronald Crump]

The Tronalds ratings

Edwards 6
Mansour 7
Whare 7
Blake 4
To'o 7
Luai 7
Cleary 8
Tamou 7
Katoa 5
Grant 6
Kikau 6
Winterstein 6
Fisher-Harris 6

Campbell-Gillard 7
Fuimaiono 5
Leota 5
Kenny 5

 

[Bob]

Luai for the tackle on Mitchell Moses, deserves player of the year for me

 

[TheFrog]

Round 10 (Warriors) Average Ratings

Edwards 2.9
To'o 2.7
Whare 3.0
Blake 2.1
DWZ 2.3
Maloney 2.9
Cleary 3.0
Tamou 4.0
Katoa 1.7
Grant 2.7
Kikau 3.4
Fisher-Harris 3.3
Martin 3.1

Luai 3.0
Fuimaiono 2.6
Leota 2.7
Ellis 2.6

Standings (Games)

1. Tamou 620 (10)
2. Fisher-Harris 604 (10)
3. Cleary 552 (10)
4. Maloney 522 (10)
5. Leota 484 (10)
6. DWZ 467 (10)
7. Blake 458 (9)
8. Campbell-Gillard 446 (9)
9. Egan 418 (8)
10. Kikau 392 (7)
11. Katoa 392 (9)
12. Yeo 389 (7)
13. Whare 353 (8)
14. Mansour 330 (8)
15. Sele 279 (5)
16. Martin 249 (5)
17. Edwards 223 (6)
18. Grant 216 (5)
19. MWZ 206 (4)
20. Fuimaiono 158 (4)
21. Aekins 152 (3)
22. Luai 148 (4)
23. Winterstein 144 (3)
24. Hetherington 98 (2)
25. Ellis 54 (2)
26. To'o 27 (1)

 

[Thirsty Panther]

A wins a win no matter how ugly.

Edwards 6
Mansour 6
Whare 6
Blake 4
To'o 6
Luai 7
Cleary 8
Tamou 7
Katoa 5
Grant 7
Kikau 6
Winterstein 6
Fisher-Harris 6

Campbell-Gillard 7
Fuimaiono 5
Leota 5
Kenny 6

 

[Panther Pete]

Edwards 7
Mansour 7
Whare 6
Blake 4
To'o 6
Luai 6
Cleary 7
Tamou 7
Katoa 4
Grant 6
Kikau 6
Winterstein 5
Fisher-Harris 6

Campbell-Gillard 7
Fuimaiono 5
Leota 5
Kenny 7

 

[Kilkenny]

It's interesting to compare our ratings with the thoughts of the Eels fans on there forums.

The consensus of many Eels fans (other than they were awful) seemed to be our two wingers were most responsible for our victory.

To'o and Mansour almost 400 metres gained between them which is a pretty fair effort given they were all hit up's basically. No line breaks or intercepts involving 40-50 runs. All the hard stuff.

 

[TheFrog]

Round 11 will close midday Thurs.

 

[betcats]

It's interesting to compare our ratings with the thoughts of the Eels fans on there forums.

The consensus of many Eels fans (other than they were awful) seemed to be our two wingers were most responsible for our victory.

To'o and Mansour almost 400 metres gained between them which is a pretty fair effort given they were all hit up's basically. No line breaks or intercepts involving 40-50 runs. All the hard stuff.

Yeah I think To'o isn't getting the wraps he deserves for that effort. Id have him at an 8 for the game at least.

 

[age.s]

Yeah I think To'o isn't getting the wraps he deserves for that effort. Id have him at an 8 for the game at least.

Played for quarter of the game busted too (heh). Only blemish would be spilling a tricky grubber (which Edwards cleaned up) but I'll overlook it given he was close to going off with what looked like a shoulder issue only moments before. Got his head driven into the turf for the trouble.

To do over 200 tough meters in your second NRL game while half busted is pretty impressive. Didn't have a huge moment though which is why I settled on a 7.

 

[Fangs]

Late but here I am:

Edwards 7
Mansour 7.5
Whare 7
Blake 4
To'o 7
Luai 6
Cleary 8 (MOM)
Tamou 7
Katoa 4.5
Grant 7
Kikau 6
Winterstein 7
Fisher-Harris 7

Campbell-Gillard 7
Fuimaiono 5
Leota 5
Kenny 7.5

Such a better effort. Far grittier and a lot more effort in defence.

 

[betcats]

Played for quarter of the game busted too (heh). Only blemish would be spilling a tricky grubber (which Edwards cleaned up) but I'll overlook it given he was close to going off with what looked like a shoulder issue only moments before. Got his head driven into the turf for the trouble.

To do over 200 tough meters in your second NRL game while half busted is pretty impressive. Didn't have a huge moment though which is why I settled on a 7.

I think he picked up that injury before halftime but yeah that’s fair.

 

[Pomoz]

Edwards 5
Mansour 6
Whare 5
Blake 4
To'o 6
Luai 4
Cleary 6
Tamou 6
Katoa 3 (the wrong options taken slowly, too many times)
Grant 5
Kikau 4 (injury hampering him)
Winterstein 5
Fisher-Harris 6

Campbell-Gillard 6
Fuimaiono 3 (7 tackles, 60 m. lazy)
Leota 5
Kenny 6

Effort good, football intelligence and skill poor. We may have won, but are playing so badly I can't see how any player is good enough to get more than 6. We are still rubbish and out of form. Barge over tries and deflected kicks is about all we have in our locker.

 

[TheFrog]

Round 11 (Parra) Average Ratings

Edwards 6.3
Mansour 6.6
Whare 6.3
Blake 4.3
To'o 6.6
Luai 6.0
Cleary 7.5
Tamou 6.6
Katoa 4.4
Grant 6.1
Kikau 5.6
Winterstein 5.6
Fisher-Harris 6.3

Campbell-Gillard 6.9
Fuimaiono 4.9
Leota 4.9
Kenny 5.9

Standings (Games)

1. Tamou 686 (11)
2. Fisher-Harris 667 (11)
3. Cleary 627 (11)
4. Leota 533 (11)
5. Maloney 522 (10)
6. Campbell-Gillard 515 (10)
7. Blake 501 (10)
8. DWZ 467 (10)
9. Kikau 448 (8)
10. Katoa 436 (10)
11. Egan 418 (8)
12. Whare 416 (9)
13. Mansour 396 (9)
14. Yeo 389 (7)
15. Edwards 286 (7)
16. Sele 279 (5)
17. Grant 277 (6)
18. Martin 259 (5)
19. Luai 208 (5)
20. Fuimaono 207 (5)
21. MWZ 206 (4)
22. Winterstein 200 (4)
23. Aekins 152 (3)
24. Hetherington 98 (2)
25. To'o 93 (2)
26. Kenny 59 (1)
27. Ellis 54 (2)

 

[mxlegend99]

Edwards - 6. Tracking for an 8 that first half
Mansour - 7.
Naden - 7. Like the look of him. Powerful and quick. Agressive . Plenty of potential
Yeo - 7
Too - 8
Luai - 8
Jimmy - 7
Grant - 6
Kenny - 8
Tamou - 7
Martin - 10
Winterstein - 6
JFH - 7

Katoa - 3
RCG - 7
Fuimaono - 5
Leota - 5

Very happy with the effort. Bench was ordinary though.