Magnay- vendetta or good journalism

[Perth Red]

She's a tabloid hack who knows people are in interested in the NRL so picks it as an easy target to get a readership. It's not news, just toilet paper filler. I thought teh West was poor journalism till I read the Sydney papers!

 

[Everlovin' Antichrist]

Come on fellas, enough of the personal insults. The fat girl doesn't deserve that.

 

[myanonymoususername]

Alternatively, it could just be the case that the Sharks are the idiots who keep putting their heads up ready for a good kicking.

 

[S.R.]

Alternatively, it could just be the case that the Sharks are the idiots who keep putting their heads up ready for a good kicking.

Nah mate.
She has something against the Sharks. The amount of digging that this "woman" has done to "break" these stories is crazy.

Dig that deep at any organisation and you will find some dirt. So why stick to one organisation and drag it out this long?

 

[Rexxy]

It wasnt deep. the surface of the custard was broken with a pin, and a torrent poured forth.

dont shoot the messenger

Dig that deep at any organisation and you will find some dirt. So why stick to one organisation and drag it out this long?

 

[Twizzle]

yeah, lets get more women on League Club boards

why ?

just because they are women

or because they deserve to be there and they are the best candidate for the job

I dont have a problem with women, after all I married a women, but putting them on a Leagues club board just because someone in the press thinks its going to undo any bad PR caused by sex scandals is living in far away land

positions on boards should be subject to the candidates suitability, not their gender

 

[S.R.]

It wasnt deep. the surface of the custard was broken with a pin, and a torrent poured forth.

dont shoot the messenger

Why were you having sexual relations with the custard Rexxy?

Can just see Magnay's headline tomorrow!!!

 

[Pig Champion]

Classic!:lol:

Meant to quote S.R.

 

[Ausguy]

Does Magnay actually analyse the on-field action...ever?

Of course she does, she said Josh Dugan was going to be the difference in the sharks raiders match last week. I tell ya josh nearly scored a try against the first grade side too.... only problem was he ran out for the under 20's didnt he??

Dumb cow.... if she keeps this up she seriously should watch her back.

yeah, lets get more women on League Club boards

why ?

just because they are women

or because they deserve to be there and they are the best candidate for the job

I dont have a problem with women, after all I married a women, but putting them on a Leagues club board just because someone in the press thinks its going to undo any bad PR caused by sex scandals is living in far away land

positions on boards should be subject to the candidates suitability, not their gender

Oh be careful Twizzle.... check out the footy show thread.... i got lambasted last week for suggesting a similar idea. I think i mentioned that there would be little interest from females in being on an nrl board and i asked someone to find me how many people there are on nrl boards. Magnay did that for me "3". out of 114. I suggested there would be none. I was wrong. I never said women couldnt do it, i merely said there is IMO little interest from women to take up the role. Hell i work for a large australian organisation where the GM is female and her 2 direct sub-ordinates are female.

I agree they can do it, but im deadset agaisnt a "quota" of 2 females per club just to make all things equal. If they want the job apply and get voted in, dont just give them 2 token positions to be politically correct.

 

[myanonymoususername]

Of course she does, she said Josh Dugan was going to be the difference in the sharks raiders match last week. I tell ya josh nearly scored a try against the first grade side too.... only problem was he ran out for the under 20's didnt he??

Dumb cow.... if she keeps this up she seriously should watch her back.

Hate to nitpick, but Dugan didn't actually play U20's either - he played Q Cup for Souths Logan. So you're as wrong as her on that one.

 

[ibeme]

Magnay and co are obsessed with creating a league scandal where none exists. Sure, this Clint Elford saga deserves coverage, but the passive watcher would be excused for thinking the Sharks were somehow at the centre of it pulling the strings, when the truth is that they (Zappia), along with several other highly reputable organisations were swindled. Why does the coverage still centre around the Sharks and Zappia?

They were all going after the Rugby League angle from the outset, and haven't changed course even after the scale of Elford's deception has been exposed. This is way bigger than Zappia and the Sharks now.

 

[Ausguy]

Of course she does, she said Josh Dugan was going to be the difference in the sharks raiders match last week. I tell ya josh nearly scored a try against the first grade side too.... only problem was he ran out for the under 20's didnt he??

Hate to nitpick, but Dugan didn't actually play U20's either - he played Q Cup for Souths Logan. So you're as wrong as her on that one.

There was a reson i left a ? at the end of it. I wasnt sure, but i sure as hell knew he wasnt playing first grade before Thursday Night.

Its even worse in her case he wasnt even at the same ground!!!

 

[LESStar58]

David Gallop was nominated for best sporting CEO.
The Footy show also keeps winning Logies.

Yeah. The Melbourne one!

 

[myanonymoususername]

yeah, lets get more women on League Club boards

positions on boards should be subject to the candidates suitability, not their gender

If board positions were based on suitability, as in competence to perform the responsibilities of board members, that rules out about 75% of the blokes currently on various club boards.

Having played for the club, and being mates with the chairman, don't equal suitable for board (generally, there could well be the odd exception who by sheer coincidence also happens to be competent)

 

[El Diablo]

Yeah. The Melbourne one!

pretty sure the League version has won the last two

 

[myanonymoususername]

There was a reson i left a ? at the end of it. I wasnt sure, but i sure as hell knew he wasnt playing first grade before Thursday Night.

Its even worse in her case he wasnt even at the same ground!!!

Fair point.

 

[sass]

I dont have a problem with women, after all I married a women

hahah awesome.

there are a few arguments for affirmative action ... but the main one is that it's actually the structure of an organisation that discourages a minority participating. so if you put people in who are black/female/whatever then the whole structure can change and develop and become a kind of organisation that is more open to diversity in its employees and bosses.

 

[Kiki]

Dumb cow.... if she keeps this up she seriously should watch her back.

is that a threat?

 

[Ausguy]

is that a threat?

More of a promise actually.

 

[Apey]

would bun fo sho.