McCrone is the worst halfback in the comp

[God-King Dean]

Completely incompetent in his position, & the worst kicking halfback I have ever seen.

His kicking cost us the game.

But he's a good tackler tho....

 

[Michaeldragonslife25]

In the comp ? I think it's safe to say the worst professional halfback ever

 

[TomRedVRiver]

Field completed outclasses McCrone tonight.

You may claim that I am scapegoating here, but McCrone literally lost us the game tonight. Giving away four 7 tackle sets (3 back to back) when momentum was in our favour is completely unacceptable.

 

[Farrquarr]

We never grubber stupid chips

 

[OzDragon]

I liked his kick on the very last play that went down the field to a heavily covered area with no chasers in sight. Truly was a sight to behold.

 

[Smack]

field needs to start this is geniused keeping mcgroan in the line up

 

[BlackDuckSaint]

I do agree, he has been commendable as second fiddle to Widdop. But he has never been a Half that you would build a team around and he has been found out the last 2 games.

 

[dino2170]

GET RID OF HIM

 

[ozbuck]

Completely incompetent in his position, & the worst kicking halfback I have ever seen.

His kicking cost us the game.

But he's a good tackler tho....

You're the worst supporter in the NRL

 

[hazzbeen]

Why do we keep kicking to McDonald , he just jumps for the sake of jumping , never contests the ball . For a big man terrible ......

 

[St_Bondi]

I liked his kick on the very last play that went down the field to a heavily covered area with no chasers in sight. Truly was a sight to behold.

That is one of the best comments

 

[Old Kogarah Boy 1]

GET RID OF HIM

Ahhhhhhhhhhh, welcome my new best friend.

 

[ozbuck]

cry babies.

good game. we lost. they won. earlier this season we won, they lost. get ready for next week

 

[yassdragon]

Yep he was shite but alas he is our best option. Looking forward to 2018 with class halves. Give us Hunt tonight, we win. Give us Hunt againt rorters, we win. Hang in there guys. So much to like about our performance. Forwards have been outstanding and i reckon dominated the sharks pack tonight. Need to wrap up Packer.

 

[kit66]

I understand your frustration but he plays a good role when Widdop is on the field and is part of the reason Widdop is playing so well this year so you kinda have to take the good with the bad. If Mann could show a little more dominance in his roll maybe he'd be a genuine contender for the 7 jersey when Wids comes back but I don't think he's convinced anyone yet. Great to see Field get some game time, would love for him to get a real shot at 7 but again if the McCrone / Widdop combo is working, be a bit silly to f**k with it.

 

[coast_dragons]

cry babies.

good game. we lost. they won. earlier this season we won, they lost. get ready for next week

People have the right to be annoyed and not have some smart arse tyring to be cute.

 

[coast_dragons]

I understand your frustration but he plays a good role when Widdop is on the field and is part of the reason Widdop is playing so well this year so you kinda have to take the good with the bad. If Mann could show a little more dominance in his roll maybe he'd be a genuine contender for the 7 jersey when Wids comes back but I don't think he's convinced anyone yet. Great to see Field get some game time, would love for him to get a real shot at 7 but again if the McCrone / Widdop combo is working, be a bit silly to f**k with it.

Funny enough if Hutchison doesn't get hurt McCrone would have never seen first grade.

 

[Blood Shot Eyes]

Field completed outclasses McCrone tonight.

You may claim that I am scapegoating here, but McCrone literally lost us the game tonight. Giving away four 7 tackle sets (3 back to back) when momentum was in our favour is completely unacceptable.

Have to agree I'm afraid....we had enough ball up to the 50 minute mark as Cronulla were woeful we should have lead by 20...I started to have doubts at half time because with the error riddled Sharks we only lead by 2 ...but that aside we invited them right back into the contest with unbelievable bad kicks by McCrone...and the annoying part he didn't learn he just kept doing it ....I bet their coach will go and put the lotto on because he knows they got out of jail .....I'm a big Nightie fan but some of his kicking options were very ordinary

 

[ozbuck]

People have the right to be annoyed and not have some smart arse tyring to be cute.

People have the right to realise that its just a game as a reminder to have perspective. what goes around comes around. you win some, you lose some. you lose some off the back of some rough penalties, you win some off the back of some rough penalties.

Have a good night mate! Get home safe!

 

[Saints Forever]

Doing his best

If Josh had an excellent kicking game he would have played a lot more FG during his career

The spotlight is shining brightly on him with Widdop out.

Would love to see Mann given a chance at 7