Melbourne "No Try"

[Diesel]

Looked like a try but then held up

not sure what the bunker looks st

 

[Apey]

The strip penalty before the Storm try was dodgy too

don't worry the strip from Turuva after his charge down and Sorensen stepping out after he caught it made up for it

 

[Vlad59]

I know you're not that stupid

For what it's worth I don't even subscribe to the "it cost storm the game" point of view.

The bunker system needs to be blown up and overhauled. I'd start with the refs at least being involved in the decision making like in union or even being solely responsible for it ala the NFL.

Exactly. It was a shite decision. It didn’t change the result. Move on lads.

 

[Apey]

The NRL’s explanation checks out, that part of Howarth’s arm just happens to be a ghostly Steeden-white.

His arm had just brushed the try line paint.

I'd be keen to see the angle the bunker some reason reserved for only the media.

 

[Diesel]

Do we get an Annersley school lesson tomorrow?

 

[Valheru]

don't worry the strip from Turuva after his charge down and Sorensen stepping out after he caught it made up for it

Yeah that Sorenson one didn't get mentioned at all, his foot was definitely in the air when he caught it.

However, he did put his foot down over the line first then lifted it so not sure if that means he was in the field of play or not.

 

[Iamback]

don't worry the strip from Turuva after his charge down and Sorensen stepping out after he caught it made up for it

I am sure there were many errors

That is Klein

 

[Diesel]

Has Bellamy said anything about it?

 

[Brutus]

They better release this mystery camera angle to prove otherwise.

It was a try for your life.

 

[League Unlimited News]

They better release this mystery camera angle to prove otherwise.

It was a try for your life.

Your wish is Dean Ritchie's command:

 

[Chins get the wins]

Melbourne scored 0 legitimate points. Cry harder cucks

 

[League Unlimited News]

Has Bellamy said anything about it?

 

[Chins get the wins]

Your wish is Dean Ritchie's command:

Thanks Tim. Another view showing its held up you sad little f**k

 

[gerg]

Was a try. Would have been a much more interesting last 30 minutes if they didn't f**k it up.

Congrats to Panthers. Such a great team.

 

[Mr. Shaman]

Thanks Tim. Another view showing its held up you sad little f**k

Video in first post shows it clearly down famalam

 

[some11]

Needs more trump

"It was the most fair and uncontroversial decision, maybe in the history of sports.. ever"

 

[some11]

Panthers fan here.
Thought it was a Try on live viewing. Thought it was a Try based on bunker footage.

Terrible decision, and absolutely changed the course of the second half.

Really disappointed that this decision will now dominate parts of the discourse around the game, rather than just focussing on the end result and the unrelenting Panthers juggernaut.

Good take. Give it a few weeks and no one will remember/care.

It happened against Melbin so I dont have a whole lot of sympathy for them anyway

 

[chrisD]

Bit harsh, wouldn’t say no try at all, I felt they did kind of try at specific periods of the 80. I remember one big forward run in particular.

 

[Maximus]

Forgetting the grounding, why is pushing Coates in the air not a penalty? Why would it be different if he was grabbed instead of pushed

 

[MRN]

Needs more trump

"It was the most fair and uncontroversial decision, maybe in the history of sports.. ever"

I read that in his voice.