11 mill is not unders for a guy with a career average of 9.6 ppg and 5.8 ass for a pg playing with 3 of the best players of the last 15 years!!!!
Agree with you sort of - agree that it isn't unders per se, but it's about right. Maybe a touch high (somewhere around $10m feels right) but at the end of the day, he is the best defensive point guard in the game, and over the past twelve months, has been in the top 4 or 5 at running an offence. He's never going to score 20 points a night, but his shot is improving and if he continues to defend at his high level and create easy shots for others, he's worth that sort of money.
I firmly believe that, outside of Billy King or some other geniused GM, no team will offer Gay a big contract. He
might get somewhere around the $12m mark, and if so Memphis can be satisfied that that's his market value and match, if they want to, or attempt a sign and trade. Just granting him a large contract - when he hasn't really improved since entering the league, hasn't reached the playoffs and so on - was my issue, and was directly in response to:
At least if you try and comprimise with Gay and pay him 12 million, you have a nice piece who you can move to further your team
They're clearly playing hardball, and I can't fault them for that. I don't agree with Aldridge's money, but ultimately that's a separate issue. Perhaps I shouldn't have referenced Rondo, which has muddied the waters somewhat. The point I've been trying to make is that there's a litany of teams that have overpaid average players (which is why I mentioned Randolph and the contract Portland gave him), and for once, Memphis seems to be exercising caution. Don't forget that Memphis could have extended Gay irrespective of other personnel moves, so trading for Randolph has no bearing. They opted not to extend him, seemingly because his asking price was too high. I agree with that, based on his career to date.
I also think that Gay took a step backwards last year - his scoring, rebounding, passing and shooting numbers were all down from the year before. If he's levelled off and will be an 18 point (off 16 shots), 1-2 assist player for the next five years or so, he isn't worth $13m a year (which is what he wanted) - unless you can establish that that's his market worth, which is impossible to do until he enters free agency. If he has another year like this year, I all but guarantee no team will offer a contract starting at $13m a year. On the other hand, if he starts measuring his shots a bit more, passing a bit more and actually playing defence, that sort of money seems a touch more palatable.