Mergers and Premiership Tallies

[andrew057]

41 pages of this crap?

Anyone with an ounce of sense knows it's 1 premiership for the St George Illawarra Dragons.

 

[RockWheel]

Anyone with an ounce of sense stopped caring a 40 pages ago.

 

[SoftSydney]

41 pages of this crap?

Anyone with an ounce of sense knows it's 1 premiership for the St George Illawarra Dragons.

one would think so

 

[andrew057]

Anyone with an ounce of sense stopped caring a 40 pages ago.

Spot on, Ive only read the last 5 or so posts of this page.

 

[Willow]

 

[Willow]

Spot on, Ive only read the last 5 or so posts of this page.

Fresh meat.

 

[andrew057]

Wonder if your other 61,913 posts are as spectacular.

 

[This Year?]

Yes.

 

[andrew057]

Thats saying something :lol:

 

[Willow]

Wonder if your other 61,913 posts are as spectacular.

61,914 thank you.

That never gets old.

Tell me Andy, what is your view on deception? For example, if someone misrepresented another man's words and when confronted they continue to repeat the lie. And finally, when proof is shown that they lied, they then deny any wrongdoing.

What would you say to the liar?

 

[Tigger Madness]

Taken from the St George Leagues Club Journal :lol:

 

[SoftSydney]

61,914 thank you.

That never gets old.

Tell me Andy, what is your view on deception? For example, if someone misrepresented another man's words and when confronted they continue to repeat the lie. And finally, when proof is shown that they lied, they then deny any wrongdoing.

What would you say to the liar?

Geez talk about beating a dead horse, thats old news now Willow move on move on

 

[SoftSydney]

Taken from the St George Leagues Club Journal :lol:

I think its now like a country club with a nice Indian and Chinese restaurant, a few pictures on the wall of the good ol days when they had a team. It is nice of them to put out propaganda for the die hard dinoursors..

 

[ANTiLAG]

SoftSydney - the brunette avatar was wayyyy hotter than this blonde one you have now.

Bring her back?

 

[SoftSydney]

SoftSydney - the brunette avatar was wayyyy hotter than this blonde one you have now.

Bring her back?

I thought I would have a new one weekly, I have had many complaints re the blonde.

 

[InThatNumber]

Link and I retract.

I would love to do that but alas, I cannot, because no such link exists. He was never on Fox Sports declaring anything about a 17th premiership.

I made the post (hell let's call it a lie for that is what it is) to see what reaction you would have. And your reaction speaks volumes.

You asked me for proof before you would retract your lie about Gasnier and you are absolutely right. By making that claim, the onus is on me to back that up with evidence. Not change the story or my point after being caught out.

Now why do you think the onus of proof does not apply to you? I am not having a go because it is obvious you are an intelligent person, but I am curious as to why you do not hold yourself up to the same scrutiny and expectations you desire from others who make similar unprovable comments like the one you made?

Just because Gasnier has never come out to refute the article's claim of one premiership does not mean he agrees with it.

That would be like saying because Wayne Bennett has never refuted the claim that Jamie Soward is a better 5/8th than Darren Lockyer, his silence is proof of his agreeing to Soward being the better 5/8th. But it doesn't stand up to scrutiny and neither does your Gasnier claim.

Anyway, keep up the fight, I still admire your tenacity in the face of adversity. The Knights could have used a bit more of that on Old Boys Day this year, no?

 

[cleary89]

I would love to do that but alas, I cannot, because no such link exists. He was never on Fox Sports declaring anything about a 17th premiership.

I made the post (hell let's call it a lie for that is what it is) to see what reaction you would have. And your reaction speaks volumes.

You asked me for proof before you would retract your lie about Gasnier and you are absolutely right. By making that claim, the onus is on me to back that up with evidence. Not change the story or my point after being caught out.

Now why do you think the onus of proof does not apply to you? I am not having a go because it is obvious you are an intelligent person, but I am curious as to why you do not hold yourself up to the same scrutiny and expectations you desire from others who make similar unprovable comments like the one you made?

Just because Gasnier has never come out to refute the article's claim of one premiership does not mean he agrees with it.

That would be like saying because Wayne Bennett has never refuted the claim that Jamie Soward is a better 5/8th than Darren Lockyer, his silence is proof of his agreeing to Soward being the better 5/8th. But it doesn't stand up to scrutiny and neither does your Gasnier claim.

Anyway, keep up the fight, I still admire your tenacity in the face of adversity. The Knights could have used a bit more of that on Old Boys Day this year, no?

Made me lol

 

[20knights10]

At no time did I say there was a formal debate. That was your red herring.

So you say....

I did say the club has raised the matter with the NRL in the past and imo they need to do more.

So they raised the matter with the NRL..?? was this informal? I mean if you raise something, especially something as important as this issue, wouldn't it be considered to be a request for formal discussion? and by discussion I mean debating the issues that are raised..??

I know you get easily confused Rambo, so I offer you the opportunity to retract.

Speak for yourself wallow..... I'll retract nothing. You've just contradicted yourself... you have however not shown any evidence that there was any "matters raised" with the NRL by the St George Dragons club... it's just an unsubstantiated claim by yourself... and for all intents and purposes it's a claim that there was a formal debate between the club and the NRL.....

and you have the hide to call others liars..... :roll:

 

[20knights10]

btw wallow... I notice you left alone the point I made about your claim the NRL had a dilemma regarding "what to do with St George"... no comment eh..?? :lol:

There will never be an official record showing that the StG Dragons have won 16 premierships, unless the JV folds and they once again win a premiership as a one club team.... in exactly the same way as the Illawarra Steelers will never have an official record of winning 1 premiership unless the same situation were to occur for them..... ie: neither will ever happen.... pretty pictures, petty insults, idle threats, flaming, repeated mantras, etc etc will do nothing to change these simple facts.... just as it should be.....

 

[muzby]

Funny things is he gave you two black eyes and left you drinking through a straw, face it he ate you man and spat you out and you continue with lame comebacks

did i miss a thread did i?

the turncoat had a hissyfit after i called him out for what he is.. a sad old man wasting far too much of this time arguing over a club which chose to stop supporting and moved on to another one..

from there he proceeded to try and talk himself up by boasting about the fact he doesn't need to work, didn't graduate from high school and has a swedish wife who is significantly younger than he is..

if in your opinion that's giving someone two black eyes, he must have hit me with his e-penis.. man, that thing seems huge..


but hey, this coming from someone llike you who claims others "don't like ladies" after they say they don't like the tranny in your avatar, so i'm guessing life for you doesn't exist far past your computer screen..