Moimoi - suspended or not IYO?

[Eelementary]

TBH IMO the tackle was NOTHING. I'd be surprised if he got a week.

 

[ElectricEelMan]

TBH IMO the tackle was NOTHING. I'd be surprised if he got a week.

Harrigan should be suspended for two months for thinking that tackle should be put on report. What a softc*ck!!

 

[Eels Dude]

Haha he won't even be charged. Nothing incident. Same as his 'hit' on Michael Luck last year.

 

[EelDredd]

nothing in it tbh

 

[hineyrulz]

Wasn't even a penalty, joke of a decsion.

 

[Bazal]

It'd be a joke if it was penalised in game...oh wait....

 

[Eelementary]

I agree with you all and was furious when we were denied possession and they were given a penalty over it.

However, Fui's record worries me...

 

[jono]

Not a worry , Harrigan STILL has it in for us (remember the 2002 game at Newy)

 

[Gronk]

Once again the ref reacts when there is an injury. Blake had neck issues from the bingle near the line earlier on. Nothing in it. It's a contact sport FFS.

 

[El Diablo]

shouldn't have even been a penalty

 

[pedge]

i must have seen it totally different
i was worried at the time, and kinda still am
the point of the shoulder hit him flush on the jaw/cheek
if there is any facial damage, then fui is gone fore sure, and even still, wouldnt surprise me if he got a week or two
he'll b picked for the kiwis, so theres 1 game anyways

 

[Eels Dude]

i must have seen it totally different
i was worried at the time, and kinda still am
the point of the shoulder hit him flush on the jaw/cheek
if there is any facial damage, then fui is gone fore sure, and even still, wouldnt surprise me if he got a week or two
he'll b picked for the kiwis, so theres 1 game anyways

He's got nothing to worry about. The ran bloke into his shoulder before Fui even made an attempt at a tackle. His arms were by his sides. He wasn't the one who made contact = no charge whatsoever.

 

[Suitman]

i must have seen it totally different
i was worried at the time, and kinda still am
the point of the shoulder hit him flush on the jaw/cheek

No mate, you didn't see it different at all.

Since when is the point of the shoulder an attacking weapon?

FMD this game is getting soft when there are comments like that. :roll:

Suity

 

[Fee]

It was an absolute idiotic decission to not only give a penalty but put it on report, Harrigan needs his head read. There was nothing in it.

 

[bradeel]

not a chance this should have even been a penalty.

Amazing that we could win a game so convincingly when the refs were absolutely giving us nothing all game. Apart from that ridiculous penalty they let the Dogs lie all over us in the play the ball. I was screaming at the TV calling for penalties and couldn't believe how much latitude they were giving the Bulldogs in the ruck.

Great that we still ground it out for the win anyway.

 

[Jake the snake]

not a chance this should have even been a penalty.

Amazing that we could win a game so convincingly when the refs were absolutely giving us nothing all game. Apart from that ridiculous penalty they let the Dogs lie all over us in the play the ball. I was screaming at the TV calling for penalties and couldn't believe how much latitude they were giving the Bulldogs in the ruck.

Great that we still ground it out for the win anyway.

Exactly, it was as if the refs were trying to change the game. That penalty on Fui was a disgrace and the bulldogs were allowed to lay all over us.

Did we receive a penalty from Archer? It seemed we won against the odds last night. Great effort.

 

[oldmancraigy]

We got 4 penalties all night.

If anyone wants to compile a dossier of video evidence to send to the NRL, get some tape of the penalty AGAINST Ben Smith in the first half for being 'too long' in the play the ball; then send the second half - every single time Parra was tackled - the dogs were allowed to lie on us for at least 4 times as long as Ben Smith got penalised for....

It was getting Parra frustrated - thought Reddy was going to elbow someone in the head again??

Actually - did anyone see Reddy throw the elbow into someone's side? It was about the 65 minute mark, he was tackled mid field about 35 out from our line and was standing in the tackle. Threw the elbow behind him...

 

[Stagger eel]

Exactly, it was as if the refs were trying to change the game. That penalty on Fui was a disgrace and the bulldogs were allowed to lay all over us.

Did we receive a penalty from Archer? It seemed we won against the odds last night. Great effort.

sure made the win even more sweeter..

 

[pazzaeel]

We got 4 penalties all night.

If anyone wants to compile a dossier of video evidence to send to the NRL, get some tape of the penalty AGAINST Ben Smith in the first half for being 'too long' in the play the ball; then send the second half - every single time Parra was tackled - the dogs were allowed to lie on us for at least 4 times as long as Ben Smith got penalised for....

It was getting Parra frustrated - thought Reddy was going to elbow someone in the head again??

Actually - did anyone see Reddy throw the elbow into someone's side? It was about the 65 minute mark, he was tackled mid field about 35 out from our line and was standing in the tackle. Threw the elbow behind him...

Couldnt agree more with your post regarding the refs. iwas blowing up in the second half. the "charge down" call was the icing on the cake.

KK could be in some trouble for that lifting tackle. i also noticed Hayne swinging at Noddy's head a few times in a tackle down near our goal line. think it was the 2nd half.

 

[Twizzle]

nothing in it at all