Most games/least achievements

[firechild]

3 x All Star
2 x Country Origin
2 x PMs XIII
1 x Dally M Captain of the Year
1 x Provan Summons Medal
1 x Toyota Cup premiership winner
18th man for NSW
Australia train-on squad twice.
Captained the Raiders to a grand final.

Jog on, buddy

For a start, selection in the PMs XIII is an achievement of failing to make the top 8. If that's how low we're going to justify "achievements" then Croker has achieved plenty.

 

[mozza91]

Made the Australian train on squad after missing the finals. Something to tell the grandkids about that one.

 

[kdalymc]

Jake Granville

 

[King hit]

Jake Granville

Premiership winner

 

[Munky]

Jake Granville

He was pretty good in the 2015 GF.

Then used that performance to play another nine seasons.

 

[Reflector]

He was pretty good in the 2015 GF.

Then used that performance to play another nine seasons.

AKA Carl Webb's Origin career - built off the back off one good game...

Too soon?

 

[Bazal]

AKA Carl Webb's Origin career - built off the back off one good game...

Too soon?

Even Webby...at least he had the mad merkin in him. Like, was there ever a footballer who saw they were up against him on the team sheet and went "yeah I'm on here, gonna be a great weekend"?

It's debatable whether he was more good than bad but he was the kind of bloke who you could completely dominate, or he could run over you all day, or he could just straight up take your head off and spit on your half dead corpse.

 

[Rabbit toes]

David Nofoaluma been mentioned?

 

[Brutus]

Darryl Jenner

 

[MKCS]

Has to be Luke Brooks doesn't it? 231 NRL games and all he has to show for it is 2 finals games, an NRL All-Stars game and a halfback of the year award. The rest of the Tigers "big four" went onto Origin series victories, grand finals, playing for the national team whilst Luke has had nothing.

I still remember when he had that cracker debut game about 10 years ago and they all said that he was the next Joey, how disappointing.

 

[Penrose Warrior]

David Nofoaluma been mentioned?

Should be after that ridiculous instagram post. What a cock. Sounds like a real average person

 

[Trifili13]

Has Wobbo been mentioned in this thread? Or is it for players only?

 

[soc123_au]

Has Wobbo been mentioned in this thread? Or is it for players only?

3 Premierships probably excludes him I reckon.

 

[Trifili13]

3 Premierships probably excludes him I reckon.

No harm in just asking the question.

 

[kdalymc]

Has to be Luke Brooks doesn't it? 231 NRL games and all he has to show for it is 2 finals games, an NRL All-Stars game and a halfback of the year award. The rest of the Tigers "big four" went onto Origin series victories, grand finals, playing for the national team whilst Luke has had nothing.

I still remember when he had that cracker debut game about 10 years ago and they all said that he was the next Joey, how disappointing.

yep
I'd like to add Luke Patten. a million games and only played city country

 

[King hit]

yep
I'd like to add Luke Patten. a million games and only played city country

Grand final winner and plenty of finals games. He is to good for a debate like this.

 

[kdalymc]

Grand final winner and plenty of finals games. He is to good for a debate like this.

finals schminals. any pleb can play in a good team

 

[Cheese sandwich]

Gutho

 

[T.S Quint]

Gutho

If we're going for Eels players, then Luke Burt is more deserving than Gutho.

264 first grade games. No premierships. No individual awards. No Origins.
1 game for NSW Country. 1 game for PM XIII.