Most overrated second rower

[Sparkles 2001]

Who is the most overrated second rower in the NRL?

 

[Griffoshark66]

Some bloke not from my club.

 

[Charlie124]

Boyd Cordner and Josh Jackson are in the grand final for this one.

 

[THE CHAMP]

I’m gonna say Darius because I reckon he’ll play there at some point next season

 

[Sparkles 2001]

Haha yeh fair call. I think John Bateman would get a run in this category too

 

[Spot On]

Some bloke not from my club.

Wade Graham

 

[AlwaysGreen]

@gitano

 

[Dave's mate]

Boyd Cordner and Josh Jackson are in the grand final for this one.

Yep and its pretty clear cut

 

[Vic Mackey]

Boyd Cordner and Josh Jackson are in the grand final for this one.

Prior to this season I would have agreed however Josh Jackson’s 2019 was amazing, a mile better then what he was throwing up when he was somehow an automatic NSW selection

 

[toomuchsoup]

I hate the roosters, but I don’t get the Cordner hate. He’s a great 2nd rower

 

[Ron's_Mate]

Cryan Matterson. That's why we got rid of him.

 

[TheDalek079]

John Bateman. Runs sideways too much. Grand final showed why Cordner is the best second rower in the game whilst Bateman will only be remembered as a pom who tries hard

 

[Captain Apollo]

I hate the roosters, but I don’t get the Cordner hate. He’s a great 2nd rower

Not many second rowers running around in the game at the moment who've won three NRL Premierships and captained NSW to consecutive Origin series wins.

 

[Tommy Smith]

According to LU:

Boyd Cordner
Angus Crichton
Victor Radley

In reality, I think Tariq Sims consistency over the course of his career leaves a lot to be desired for an Origin rep when you consider how good he can be (i.e. his finals hattrick vs Brisbane last year).

 

[adamkungl]

According to LU:

Boyd Cordner
Angus Crichton
Victor Radley

In reality, I think Tariq Sims consistency over the course of his career leaves a lot to be desired for an Origin rep when you consider how good he can be (i.e. his finals hattrick vs Brisbane last year).

Going back to back with a forward pack entirely of overrated players
Yet another adversity we've defeated that would have sunk lesser clubs

 

[Bazal]

Cordner will get masses of votes because of the large percentage of brainlets on LU.

Tariq Sims is a good call. My bold call is Tyson Frizzell. Not that he's a bad player by any means but he just doesn't have a lot of skill, yet gets talked about as one of the premier backrowers. I think he's a rung or so below personally

 

[Tommy Smith]

Going back to back with a forward pack entirely of overrated players
Yet another adversity we've defeated that would have sunk lesser clubs

Our team is full of overrated hacks and was carried to b2b titles by James Tedesco; in the same way that he carried the Tigers to finals success on his own.

 

[Dave's mate]

Cordner is a good first grader

 

[adamkungl]

Our team is full of overrated hacks and was carried to b2b titles by James Tedesco; in the same way that he carried the Tigers to finals success on his own.

With the power of secret-undeclared-TPAs injected into his veins, Tedesco was able to single-handedly carry 16 plodders to victory 2 years in a row

 

[Raiders_Premiers]

This thread was made by the OP with the intention to have Boyd Plodner put on blast.