Nah
There is plenty of good stuff on DM mate, a few songs wouldn't be out of place on justice
I liked DM. I even liked St. Anger. I maintain that if a young up and coming band did St. Anger it would have been well received.
IMO too similar to Death magnetic. It is too clean and polished.
Clear as it may seem (again IMO) it needs the raw Metallica sound of Ride the Lightning or Kill Ém All to get this song better rather than a paint-by-numbers track making its money from reproducing Death Magnetic (which the fans bought only because it was better than Saint Anger)
St. Anger isn't that bad, I agree. Some chunky as hell riffs (in a good way). Take out the sound of Lars banging on a Milo tin and add a couple of Kirk solos and it would have improved it 5-fold.
Have they confirmed that this album will be it?
I liked DM. I even liked St. Anger. I maintain that if a young up and coming band did St. Anger it would have been well received.
There's nothing that Metallica have done that I have hated (didn't hear the collab album with Lou Reed,) but this is honestly the closest thing I've heard to their premier years (Lightning to Justice.)