Non Penrith games

[Panther Pete]

I can’t believe I am saying this but would be great to see Parra win just to put an end to the storms winning streak.

 

[murraymob]

Parra matching the storm half time interesting parra are attacking the right defence of storm and doing well

 

[Smug Panther]

I can’t believe I am saying this but would be great to see Parra win just to put an end to the storms winning streak.

That helps Melbourne not us

 

[Thirsty Panther]

Funny how Parra seem to trouble the Storm.

 

[Smug Panther]

Storm fading like we did in 2020. Difference is they have a gun coach who will probably turn them around

 

[Thirsty Panther]

Eels beat them early this year and once last year.
There is something they do that is uncomfortable for the Storm.
Ivan should investigate this.

 

[WestyLife]

I keep reading that Michells suspension could/may cost the Bunnies the premiership. I guess if you can put 60 or 50 on lesser sides you have some kudos but the bunnies are the only side we’ve scored 50+ against and so have the Storm.

They were missing a lot against the Storm. That game is no indication of their potential.

 

[WestyLife]

If we want to have discussion around honesty Moylan has been awful since 2017.

His last two games have been very good since returning.

 

[WestyLife]

Laui sustained an MCL, his halves partner sustained a shoulder injury, both were out for certain periods during which we had to play makeshift combinations. Is it any surprise Jerome perhaps hasn’t been at his best given the circumstances.

Moylan - injuries make him a bad player

Luai - injuries are an excuse for poor form

 

[murraymob]

Could be a bad day for the storm losing and several players on report .could be interesting at the judiciary next week long night for them

 

[Munky]

Melbourne kneecapped themselves with two small benchies.

Hopefully they do that in the finals.

 

[unKwn]

Well all of you will be cheering for Moyza next week cos if Sharks beat Storm and we win our next 2, we take the minor prem

 

[Original Name]

Melbourne's back up wingers aren't nearly as strong defensively. They're different when Ado Carr and Jennings play the full game.

 

[mxlegend99]

Forgive me if I back our players as opposed to former players, particularly the likes of Moylan who other than one really good season plays one good game in 10 and that is when is he is not injured. You’re talking up a bloke who let our club and his team mates down big time with his off field issues.

One good season? One good game in every 10? That's just bullshit

He was great more often than not for us right up until his last season. Had a killer 2018 season too for Sharks.

Injuries and poor discipline in rehab held him back in 2017 and 2019 onwards. But even injured he played more than 2 good games a season. Without doubt we are better off with Luai. But that take on Moylan is just lies.

 

[Kilkenny]

Moylan - injuries make him a bad player

Luai - injuries are an excuse for poor form

That is so brain dead. I understand you stick solid with your fan boys but seriously, what a stupid assessment.

 

[Smug Panther]

Well all of you will be cheering for Moyza next week cos if Sharks beat Storm and we win our next 2, we take the minor prem

I couldn't care less about the MP. We have a bigger goal

 

[Kilkenny]

One good season? One good game in every 10? That's just bullshit

He was great more often than not for us right up until his last season. Had a killer 2018 season too for Sharks.

Injuries and poor discipline in rehab held him back in 2017 and 2019 onwards. But even injured he played more than 2 good games a season. Without doubt we are better off with Luai. But that take on Moylan is just lies.

Moylan was a match winner, I talked him up if you want to go back a few pages or so. The Mudgee game I was all over it just a week or so back but don’t attempt to rewrite history, he was our captain, he let us down badly and his conduct was unforgivable. He did well tonight, always pleased for him when he does well, but i won’t have certain members talking down the players who currently serve our club and serve us well.

 

[Smug Panther]

Moylan was a match winner, I talked him up if you want to go back a few pages or so. The Mudgee game I was all over it just a week or so back but don’t attempt to rewrite history, he was our captain, he let us down badly and his conduct was unforgivable. He did well tonight, always pleased for him when he does well, but i won’t have certain members talking down the players who currently serve our club and serve us well.

Such a sanctimonious little princess aren't you

 

[Kilkenny]

Such a sanctimonious little princess aren't you

Stupid mate. You have gone out in a limb and talked down our players. I don’t get it. You want to somehow justify your position and call me a princess when you have carved up Jerome in goodness knows how many posts. Look in the mirror mate, it isn’t pretty.

 

[mxlegend99]

Moylan was a match winner, I talked him up if you want to go back a few pages or so. The Mudgee game I was all over it just a week or so back but don’t attempt to rewrite history, he was our captain, he let us down badly and his conduct was unforgivable. He did well tonight, always pleased for him when he does well, but i won’t have certain members talking down the players who currently serve our club and serve us well.

I didnt rewrite history. You did with the bullshit one good game in 10 claim and saying he only had one decent season.

What i said was fact. I never said he didn't let us down. But his unforgivable conduct was not as bad as a certain coaches favourite who's conduct was apparently forgivable.

Moylan wanted out because of a coach who he didn't get along with who singled him out when the team was playing terribly. He had issues too. But he wasn't solely responsible for how that mess ended either. No reason to lie about how good he was for us. Hook was just the wrong coach for a player like Moylan. Funnily enough Ivan was one of the better coaches for him. I think Bennett would have been another great one for him.

But yes he did do plenty wrong and he let himself down more than anyone in not putting in the effort in rehab. Doesn't change his onfield form for us though.