NRL All Stars voting: Who did you choose?

[Tiger_Gold]

A premiership captain who's about to have the most appearences for the greatest club of all (let's not deny it....) who's played for Aus + NSW, played fullback, lock, 5/8th, halfback & hooker has no football ability.

St George Illawarra Dragons are the greatest club ever?
With only 1 premiership? I disagree.

 

[no name]

A premiership captain who's about to have the most appearences for the greatest club of all (let's not deny it....) who's played for Aus + NSW, played fullback, lock, 5/8th, halfback & hooker has no football ability.

You talking about Hornby or Israel Falou?

 

[firechild]

A premiership captain who's about to have the most appearences for the greatest club of all (let's not deny it....) who's played for Aus + NSW, played fullback, lock, 5/8th, halfback & hooker has no football ability.

How so? A merged entity with a little over a decade and a single premiership to its name can hardly be regarded as the greatest club of all.

 

[_snafu_]

Haha GKD threw some bait out and got some bites.

 

[sputneek]

So Hornby is out and is replaced by.....

Nathan Fien.

FFS

 

[joshie]

wonder who will be replacing Smith

 

[Tigger Madness]

Just when we thought Hornby was a bad choice.........in steps Nathan Fein :crazy:

 

[skeepe]

Nathan Fien? :crazy:

Has Bennett gone senile? Be afraid Knights fans, be very afraid.

 

[innsaneink]

wonder who will be replacing Smith

Jake Friend would deserve a call up imo

Good season last year...hes matured well

 

[Spanner in the works]

Can't remember who I picked. I did base it on:
a) Getting big game experience for future NSW players
b) Getting big game experience for my young club players

Not that the All Stars is a big game by any means, but there is some class out there, and even just to hang around players of that quality can be of huge benefit.

 

[sputneek]

Smiths replacement should be the VC of Australia, who logically should be Paul Gallen. But Gallen is already in the team, so he becomes the Aus rep instead of the Cronulla rep. So a new Cronulla rep should be selected, and that should be Todd Carney.

 

[Walt Flanigan]

Aaron Payne is Smith's replacement.