What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Nrl & Nfl

TheBourbonBeast

Juniors
Messages
801
Anyone think of any Rugby League players who could step up and play NFL? And not as a punter and kicker. I've played both sports and have a good knowledge of both games. I know a lot off small minded, territtorial aussies think american football is a pussy sport..."they wear all that padding, and this one time they saw RL players and wear like WOW they couldnt believe it" ....*usuall comment* But this isn't the case. Its a tough game. And the NFL is a VERY tough league.

Here are a few of my suggestions:

Lockyer - (for his speed. Don't know what his 40m time is but i reckon its good)
Mason - (the boy is big, and could get bigger. Probably the only NRL player big enough
to be some kind of lineman)
Peachy - (too old now but his freakish skills, height and speed could have seen
play reciever)

Thoughts?
 

Gibbo

Juniors
Messages
579
Out of interests sake do you think it would be possible to play a game of rugby league in full american football gear? Scrums would probably be a no-go, but i think it would be interesting....
 

greg

Juniors
Messages
593
The original question is whether any NRL players could "step up" to NFL. Who says it is a step up?
 

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
theBourbonBeast eh?
Clever but you gotta get up early in the morning to fool ol raider_69

welcome to LU, Rebecca Wilson!
 
Messages
42,632
novacastrian_panther said:
Brett Hodgson, Matt Bowen, Preston Campbell and that would get hammered.

Which is the point, the two games are too far apart to compare.

Which of those blokes you mentioned would a nose tackle catch?
 

NK Arsenal

Juniors
Messages
1,849
Everlovin' Antichrist said:
Which is the point, the two games are too far apart to compare.

Which of those blokes you mentioned would a nose tackle catch?

what is a nose tackle??? :?
 

ShineDog

Juniors
Messages
934
Beast of Bourbon ....long time no see.

I can vouch for this guys ability on the gridion field...he can play and knows his stuff.

Unfortunately , he has no idea when it comes to rugby league. Not only is he a wild child on the field he tends to direct all his energies towards suppoting crap teams....come over to the darkside - join us as a doggies fan.


In regard to your question : I do agree that an inform Peachy (3yrs ago) would have been devasting as would big Willie Mason. But Gasnier would have been the man!!
 

TheBourbonBeast

Juniors
Messages
801
greg said:
The original question is whether any NRL players could "step up" to NFL. Who says it is a step up?

NRL, while being as tough as it is, still aint what the NFL is in terms of toughness, talent, intensity, and popularity. Only a small percent of highschool players make it to college, and of them only 300 or so get drafted into the NFL. And of these most will never start. It really is the cream of the crop.

But i suspect that quite a few NRL players, given the chance, could do quiet well. Even the raiders tackling machine Allen Tongue, would be a good defensive player.

As for an NFL player playing league, any starting running back from the NFL should carve up. They weigh in at about 95kg - 120kg, just right for RL

As for NRL players suiting up, I have always LOVED that idea. The hitting would insane.
 
Messages
329
Before this thread gets overrun with 'NFL is a pansies sport because they wear padding stupid yanks hurf durf' crap here are mine

Greg Inglis would make a fantastic wide reciever

Willie Mason might make a good linebacker but he doesn't have the speed

Most NRL players would have trouble coping with the intensity of the collisions in the NFL
 

Gibbo

Juniors
Messages
579
Not nearly the same i know BUT this is still interesting reading for anyone who is into the history of 'football' (all types).

http://www.rl1908.com/articles/American-Rugby-League.htm

The American All-Stars Rugby League Team

Sean Fagan of RL1908.com

One of the more positive attempts to introduce Americans to Rugby League took place in Australia in 1953.

Mike Dimitro, a wrestling promoter, brought together in the USA a team called the American Rugby League All Stars. After preparing in a training camp, the team embarked on an ambitious 26 match tour of Australia and New Zealand.

Fans in Australia flocked to see the Americans. In Sydney they attracted over 100,000 to three games. In other rugby league cities they also proved to be popular. In Brisbane 24,397 saw them play Queensland, while crowds in Newcastle (14,160) and Wollongong (11,787) were also solid.

But what was at first seen as a trailblazing step to make Americans aware of the game of rugby league, ultimately finished as a disaster.

None of the 22 players had previously played rugby league - and it showed. In 18 matches in Australia, the All Stars won three, lost 13 and drew two. They scored 406 points, but had 560 scored against them. In their eight New Zealand matches, they won three and lost five, scoring 157 points to 211 against.

Player-manager Mike Dimitro was an outstanding American gridiron player. He was in Australia during World War 2 and became involved in Services boxing and wrestling matches. He had been approached by the Australian Board of Control to organise a rugby league tour by a USA team on the recommendation of a New Zealand official.

When it was known that a US team was to tour, 52 prospective tourists went into training, including Bob Waterfield, the husband of movie star Jane Russell. However, many of the trialists dropped out and in the end Dimitro had difficulty finding sufficient players for the trip. Two players arrived by plane the day before their first match.

The Americans opened their tour in Canberra against a combined Monaro and Southern Division team, and won 34-25. In their next match, against a strong Sydney team at the Sydney Cricket Ground, a sellout 65,453 came to watch them play.

But the novelty wore off quickly. The Americans were beaten 52-25 and in their next match at the SCG, against NSW, just over 32,000 saw the Americans thrashed 62-41 in a farcical match. It was too much to expect a team of novices, most of whom had never seen a game of rugby league, to be competitive against one of the game's most powerful nations.

Dimitro had players who had either played American football or knew something of rugby union. Norm Latchem Robinson was appointed coach of the Americans and was given some assistants after the second match of the tour. As the tour wore on, the All Stars team included local players to bolster their ranks.

The American Rugby League team toured country centres in New South Wales, then Brisbane, through Queensland country and across to New Zealand. They won six games in total, with the most notable victories being wins over Newcastle (19-10), Ipswich (16-15) and South Auckland (22-19). The All Stars drew games against North Queensland (17-17) and Wide Bay (33-33). The "Yanks" also took on other strong sides including Sydney, Brisbane and Auckland without success.

Australian crowds were bemused by some of the American tactics. Not surprisingly, they used the long gridiron style throw from one side of the field to the other, and for the first two matches, the Americans wore long gridiron trousers. After that they changed to shorts. So poor were their attempts to play the ball that New South Wales hooker Ken Kearney had to kick the ball through to ensure they kept possession. If nothing else, the Americans wore colourful outfits - royal blue jerseys with red and white stripes on the sides.

One redeeming aspect was the decision of Al Kirkland, the best of the Americans, to stay in Australia. He worked at St Marys Munitions Factory in Sydney's west and joined the Parramatta club in 1956. He started the season as a winger but learned the game so well that he played some matches in the centres or five-eighth. He appeared in all 18 first grade matches in 1956 and scored four tries. It was his only season in Sydney football.

The All Stars manager, Mike Dimitro, did not give up on his hopes of establishing rugby league in the United States. He organised two exhibition matches that were held in California between Australia and New Zealand after the conclusion of the 1954 World Cup in France. Sadly, few spectators turned up to watch.

In the late 1960s Dimitro tried to persuade the international bodies to let him stage a Rugby League World Cup in North America. He was unsuccessful.
 

Latest posts

Top